Android Poco F1 long term review

TinTinSnowy said:
Is there any evidence to support this claim? If a company were consistently plagued by such a significant issue, it would likely face dire consequences and struggle to survive in a competitive market with plenty of alternatives. POCO sold 6 million devices in 2022.


I respectfully disagree. Price is not the sole determining factor. I have a friend who recently purchased a Pixel 7a and is experiencing issues such as overheating and a slow fingerprint sensor. Another friend who owns an S21 FE 5g is facing problems with WiFi and data speed throttling. On the other hand, my mom's affordable POCO device maintains proper connectivity consistently. Thus, it's evident that issues can occur across different price ranges and brands.
Click to expand...
techcrunch.com

Is Xiaomi's shine dimming in India? | TechCrunch

Xiaomi faces challenges in India, with key local departures and declining shipments in world's second-largest smartphone market.
techcrunch.com techcrunch.com

The techcrunch article covers most of what has gone wrong with Xiaomi. However, the fact that Xiaomi fell from first place to fourth in the smartphone segment within a year also says that the Indian consumer has moved on.
 
t3chg33k said:
The techcrunch article covers most of what has gone wrong with Xiaomi. However, the fact that Xiaomi fell from first place to fourth within a year also says that the Indian consumer has moved on.
Click to expand...
Thanks! I'll read about the problems. However, a single quarter might not provide the complete picture, and Xiaomi was the number one brand overall in 2022. Samsung is becoming more competitive in the lower range with their M & F series. Vivo, iQoo, Motorola, and Realme are now offering more value-for-money options. That being said, it doesn't imply that Xiaomi is producing subpar phones.
 
xiaomi.eu

Hardware issue in my Mi 11 Pro

Hi After updating stable ROM 13.0.13 over A12 in my Mi 11 Pro, my device suddenly died. Hardbricked, no signal, no fastboot. No sound or vibration when connecting to PC. Even no sound or light of charging when connect to charger. After trying to fix by software with test points (via Telegram)...
xiaomi.eu xiaomi.eu
https://www.reddit.com/r/Xiaomi/comments/obs4ae
forum.xda-developers.com

Motherboard replaced and different smartphone model! HELP

hi guys, I recently sent my Xiaomi MI 11 Lite 5G NE to repair for a problem with the mobile networks ... Picked up yesterday and everything works fine. Tonight I was tweaking a bit in the settings and I realized that the model in the phone info...
forum.xda-developers.com forum.xda-developers.com

You will find mentions of it all over the web, mostly from the past 2 years. They are also incompetent enough to install motherboards from another model.

www.forbesindia.com

Why Xiaomi Is In A Downward Spiral - Forbes India

Three consecutive quarters of slowdown in the mass smartphone market, Xiaomi's stronghold, takes a toll on the Chinese price-warrior. As the market moves towards premium, can the company retain its throne?
www.forbesindia.com www.forbesindia.com

Also, they have stopped putting money into Xiaomi India considering that they will have to pay 5500+ crore for the FEMA violations, in trying to remit money back to China through illegal means.

At this point, there is not much reason to vouch for Xiaomi or Poco.
 
1687454275455.png



@t3chg33k Replace 11r with any phone of any price range and you will find enough complaints. When you sell a million hardware some will fail no matter how strict is your quality control. Most people will leave bad reviews but hardly good reviews. A local ISP which I used before switching Jio have 1 star on google reviews and yet I never had any trouble with them. This make me believe mostly unhappy people will write about their experience. I never left a good review on their google local page yet I was happy with them for more than a decade.
 
Last edited:
I have no idea if it is 0.001% or 0.1% or 1% of users complaining about Xiaomi, but it is a lot more prevelant now on the web or social media and the declining financial numbers are speaking for themselves.

The 1+1 warranty scheme came up on account of this backlash which indicates Xiaomi acknowledged the unreliability of their devices and is trying to address it with this scheme.

Additionally, the brand engages in far too many unethical shenanigans such as sending review units with different panels and better binned processors, false marketing, custom duty evasion, illegal remittance and probably much more. As a former Xiaomi user, I have lost complete trust in the brand and switched to alternatives, but it will of course have a place in the market and appeal to some users.
 
TinTinSnowy said:
@t3chg33k: My family and I have been using four Poco phones, and recently my brother purchased a new POCO F5. I wasn't aware of the motherboard issues associated with these phones until they were brought up here. I wonder what the ratio is of people experiencing these issues. Considering POCO's price range and target market, they must have a significant annual sales volume. Perhaps a few isolated issues are being highlighted too much? My brother still has his Xiaomi Mi3, which he purchased during the first sale in India (2014???), and it is still working fine.
Click to expand...
same thing/rule apply for Samsung & Mi also, till now family used (from 1.5k to 15k range) motorola, sonyericson, nokia, micromax, SRT (smartron), Xiaomi (Note 7s & Note Pro 5), Samsung (A50s & M21-2021)... user satisfaction is very good with Mi & Samsung.

but please note & mind that Mi phone are made before June 2020. As after June 2020, india china clash, mobile hardware quality issue starts.
 
Last edited:
Emperor said:
same thing/rule apply for Samsung & Mi also, till now family used (from 1.5k to 15k range) motorola, sonyericson, nokia, micromax, SRT (smartron), Xiaomi (Note 7s & Note Pro 5), Samsung (A50s & M21-2021)... user satisfaction is very good with Mi & Samsung.
Click to expand...
Have used around 5-6 , mi-redmi devices within my family. ALL budget models from 5-9k ,no issues till date except the mi a3 where i had to change the power buttton after 2-3 years.

Do note that i normally sell them on olx after 3-3.5 years .
Had bought a nokia 5.1 due to stock android, but it was plagued by a daughterboard issue where the charging port would get damaged automatically after certain time, they even increased the warranty to 1.5 years, had to exchange off after warranty period .

Mi budget phones are built well compared to the competition but the software is shit (for my taste) and updates as well well the data collection situation is pathetic .
I have only used their Amdroid one A series myself, rest miui models were used by my parents.
 
Xiaomi has been a mess leadership-wise for the past 3 years but it should be noted that the reliability issue is much more prevalent in India and has not been reported as much globally. Xiaomi has cut too many corners, is under closer scrutiny for imports for duty evasion and part of it might be on account of the 5500 crore fine hanging over their head. Wouldn't be surprised if they pull out once they are forced to pay the fine after running out of all legal options.
 
TinTinSnowy said:
I respectfully disagree. Price is not the sole determining factor. I have a friend who recently purchased a Pixel 7a and is experiencing issues such as overheating and a slow fingerprint sensor. Another friend who owns an S21 FE 5g is facing problems with WiFi and data speed throttling. On the other hand, my mom's affordable POCO device maintains proper connectivity consistently. Thus, it's evident that issues can occur across different price ranges and brands.
Click to expand...
There are two things you have to avoid, if possible.

1. A phone with MIUI software.
2. A phone with Exynos chip (eg: Sammy's and Pixels).

From what I have seen, if I have to pick one device among the above two only, I would pick one with MIUI and flash custom ROM. Any phone with hardware limitation/issue is as good as dead for me.
 
This phone still has great custom rom support. Currently my daily driver.

Android 14 custom rom is confirmed. They have booted A14 in poco f1.
Derpfest and Awaken a14 rom is expected to be released soon.

Derpfest A14.jpg


AOSP A14.jpg
 
Back
Top