Reply to thread

Watched Sherlock Holmes yesterday. As a movie, I'd give it a 7.5 but as a Holmes movie it won't get higher than 5.5 ( and that too for Downey jr's acting ). The action part should have been lesser. Jude law's acting talent has been wasted by the director. And above all, the story doesn't show Holmesian deduction that much. The sign of the four or Valley of fear would have been much better choice. Relationship with Irin got extra importance.