I've played the entire Sh and Re series and IMO -
the remake of resident evil on the gamecube pretty much the scariest game i've ever played. That, and Re4, isn't exactly scary, but the ganados are so much smarter than your typical zomby's, they even work and live like normal people! But when it comes to intruders, they're worse then zomby's. and when you hear a chainsaw motor turn on sound from nowhere, you're in for some major decapitation treat if you don't get the **** out of there ASAP.
After that, Silent Hill 3. Easily the scariest game of the series. Sh4 blowed in every way :no: and Sh1 was scary too. Fans on the PC might want to give SH.
And where did Fatal Frame series go in that list? I didn't complete the games because it didn't feature any guns
but i can easily tell its way scarier than the SH series.
Alone in the Dark:new Nightmare - at first, i sold the game back, because of a shock it gave me :rofl: i was checking this gate, all of a sudden lightning strikes in that split sec you can see a the room filled with zombies lightened up by the light of the lightning :0 got it back 6 months later, and finally beat it.
Have to try Clive Barker's Undying though...