Women in India Aren’t Safe on Twitter Either

vivek.krishnan

BLR~ZRS-TX-1-MX
Keymaster
Sadly, this is true. And its not limited to just Twitter. I saw an online review of Bobby Jasoos, which was reviewed by a 'lady', and the comments were not extremely sexist, but still above where we would draw the line.

I feel that yesterdays SC judgement on Sharia courts is a step in the right direction, since in many cases, these courts usually impose harsh judgements on women. Nor are khap panchayats better.

Link : https://medium.com/matter/no-safe-places-d59af0c3ba58

Every morning Nilanjana Roy, the Indian novelist, goes through the same routine in her New Delhi apartment: a few minutes of yoga and meditation, before turning on some Hindustani classical music to drown out the sounds of the traffic, flipping open her laptop, and refreshing Twitter. Roy has 100,000 followers; today there are 300 replies. The first one sets the tone: “You hole who should be raped by a bamboo lathi.”

Sagarika Ghose, who has 361,000 followers on Twitter, calls them “communal techies.” She also coined the now-ubiquitous term “Internet Hindu” in a reference to their infatuation with the Hindu right wing nationalist ideology of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which won an overwhelming majority in the general elections that were held in April. The Hindu far right is famously patriarchal, and blind to the humanity and individuality of women.

fair game for everything, including rape.

Meena Kandasamy. She writes about sexuality with a rare frankness, has over 25,000 followers on Twitter, and is a regular target of abuse. Speaking to me from Chennai, she said that the particular vulgarity of the tweets she is subjected to is influenced by the fact that she belongs to a low caste.

Sabbah Haji runs a public school in the northern state of Jammu & Kashmir, and has over 18,000 followers on Twitter. Like Kandasamy, she expresses her politically liberal views without a filter. She is a Muslim, and can’t count the number of times she has been called a jihadi, she told me on the phone from Doda district. She is asked whether her Muslim “terrorist” “brothers” are enjoying their virgins in heaven.

galvanized thousands of volunteers in India and abroad to flood Twitter and Facebook with right-wing rhetoric. These volunteers sought out tweets, hashtags, and even the handles of prominent liberal intellectuals and responded to expressions of mistrust in the BJP, or disagreement with the views of its leader Narendra Modi—and not in ones or twos, but in the hundreds. Their responses— “b**ch,” “Bimbo,” “Hate monger”—were uniformly crude.

the tweets were also bigoted. If the handle was a woman’s, the tweets were loaded with threats that conjured images of women being sexually assaulted during India’s infamous and not infrequent riots.

Natasha Badhwar, who has 20,000 followers and publishes a fortnightly newspaper column on the seemingly “safe” subject of family and relationships, mentioned her Muslim husband, she was deluged with abuse. “The tweets,” she told me over email, were terrifyingly graphic. “They threatened to rape, kill and dump the bodies of my daughters,” she said. All three of them are under the age of ten.

a tradition of stifling critical thought, was likely to come to power. Words like secular, tolerant, liberal, and intellectual—which most modern, forward-thinking societies consider badges of praise—have been reduced to mere slurs in the already slur-filled lexicon of India’s online Hindu right.

it was revealed that she had been the subject of much bitterness for having migrated in search of a job, and then for returning with envy-inducing items such as a small TV and a tinny music system.

“For the (all-male) elders,” said one villager, “These were a source of anguish.”

The gang rape, said another, was a “punishment” for her “way of life.”
 
the internet has become a refuge for cowards who will not dare say the same things in public even when provoked. a minor instance happened to me today. i have a youtube channel where i had uploaded a video piano tutorial. apparently judging by my accent, a utuber left the comment "terrorist" on my video.
 
I'm going to quote what a friend said. It's in Hindi, so apologies for the non-Hindi speakers.

India mein har cheez ki kami hai, bas c****** har kone mein bhare hain
[DOUBLEPOST=1404842685][/DOUBLEPOST]Btw, you'll be glad to know the government is taking strict action on this...by banning depositfiles, luckyshare etc.
 
Last edited:
Safe from what and from whom ?

Personal attacks online are sure sign of people that lack real ammo to counter what is said. They are a school yard tactic to divert the conversation. It is amazing how many will resort to this, when they don't like what you say. Not liking what is said is their problem alone.

If the biggest risk is from these characters then these women are relatively more safe than otherwise as they can continue as they like. A mob going after them (online) means nothing. Unpleasant but does not pose a risk to their person. Because it does not matter if a hundred monkeys disagree but cannot counter what she said.

Women are not the only ones that will face this kind of abuse, anyone with an unpopular view will as well.

So what is the purpose of this article ?

abusive comments are dealt with in a similar fashion in many areas, they are disappeared. Do these people have the power to do that in their twitter accounts or are they helpless damsels that require protection.
 
Safe from what and from whom ?

Internet bullies. Right wing ones.

Personal attacks online are sure sign of people that lack real ammo to counter what is said. They are a school yard tactic to divert the conversation. It is amazing how many will resort to this, when they don't like what you say. Not liking what is said is their problem alone.

Yep

If the biggest risk is from these characters then these women are relatively more safe than otherwise as they can continue as they like. A mob going after them (online) means nothing. Unpleasant but does not pose a risk to their person. Because it does not matter if a hundred monkeys disagree but cannot counter what she said.

Correct. But, if you are continuously bullied online, you initially might fight back, then you step down if alone.

Women are not the only ones that will face this kind of abuse, anyone with an unpopular view will as well.

Maybe, but women are viewed as soft targets

So what is the purpose of this article ?

To bring awareness, duh. You see the same elsewhere too.

abusive comments are dealt with in a similar fashion in many areas, they are disappeared. Do these people have the power to do that in their twitter accounts or are they helpless damsels that require protection.

:facepalm:
 
To bring awareness, duh. You see the same elsewhere too.
My point is this article does not help those that get taunted. Fails to mention that the web levels the playing field. Does not matter how many idiots taunt, you can still post and ignore or laugh at the ones that cannot challenge. You can't do this offline without worrying about physical safety. So online vs offline are not equal.

In passing it mentions Sagarika ignores it who i'm sure gets her share of hate mail.

Correct. But, if you are continuously bullied online, you initially might fight back, then you step down if alone.
Then they have surrendered when they did not have to. Why ?

It is much easier for women to grow a backbone than expect idiots to go away isn't it.

Maybe, but women are viewed as soft targets
Teens and those in the twenties who have been on the net for some time have learnt to deal with it. Ones that are new to the net are going to have to learn.
 
The only solution I see is proper education and by "education" I mean proper upbringing of the child having good thoughts, manners and compassion.
It is very difficult to change an adult, even if a change is seen it is only superficial and with the slight hint of opportunity the person will strike.
This not is valid for only the men/boys but also the women/girls. There should be not a shred of differentiation between, as I think this differentiation is the seed of of all the hatred/injustice towards women and also ultra feminism.
 
Back
Top