ggt said:
Heard that the gameplay is not that slick for fifa 12.
People have moved on to PES just for the gameplay sacrificing for the graphics.
Is the above statement true?
Asking this because friends are of this opinion.
Might play Anyone of the those games now.
PES 2008, 2009, 2010 were very arcadish and FIFA was a better game. (Especially, FIFA 08). PES 2011 returned to its roots and there are quite a few people (including me) who think it is one of the best football games ever made. Thing is, FIFA is technically an excellent game but they don't seem to be inclined to model a lot of football behaviour. (AI, player individuality, momentum and inertia for player models, etc). They were headed that way with FIFA 08 but have regressed since then.
What FIFA does well is have a great technical engine (smooth animations) and good passing controls (though their control philosophy makes it so that every player passes very similarly. Not a huge variation). Players turn on a dime but it is not very realistic.
Compared to that, PES has this.
Basically, it boils down to individual preferences. Some of us are willing to live with the negatives of PES 2012 to play what we believe is a better approximation of football.
You should download both demos and decide which you prefer.
I played FIFA 08, 09, 10 but went back to PES 2011.