Urgent : Tell me which one of these 3 Lappies to buy..

hirumon

hirumon

Disciple
Jun 13, 2008
101
1
79
36
Trivandrum
HI,
I have selected 3 Laptops around 50k..
Pls give me ur opinions about them..

1. Acer Aspire TimelineX 4820TG - 50k
Ci5 430, 4GB, 500 GB 5.4k rpm, HD5650

2. HP Dv6 3057tx - 50k
Ci3 370, 3GB, 500GB 7.2k rpm, HD5650

3. Lenovo Y560 - 48.5k
Ci3 350, 4GB, 500GB 5.4k rpm, HD5730

These are the ones i have in mind.. My primary use is for Gaming and Movies.. Which one of these will be better in games?? how much difference CPU makes in games??

Any of u use any of these lappies?? whats ur opinion??
Is there any other Laptops under 50k which is better than these??
Im picking one this week.. Pls help.
 
hirumon

hirumon

Disciple
Jun 13, 2008
101
1
79
36
Trivandrum
kidpikoon said:
I think Acer , cause its i5...

--- Updated Post - Automerged ---

Sorry, didnt notice the 5730 in Lenovo ...

Lenovo would be better...
Click to expand...
okie.. so CPU is not so important right..

Which company of 3 has better build quality and A.S.S??
 
hA1d3R

hA1d3R

Adept
Oct 1, 2008
672
10
82
there isnt much of a difference between 5650 and 5730 . few months back when i read abt lenovo i found too many display problems posted on the internet . check that yourself . no laptop in the market offers the portability and power 4820TG offers
 
hirumon

hirumon

Disciple
Jun 13, 2008
101
1
79
36
Trivandrum
haider_up32 said:
there isnt much of a difference between 5650 and 5730 . few months back when i read abt lenovo i found too many display problems posted on the internet . check that yourself . no laptop in the market offers the portability and power 4820TG offers
Click to expand...

I wont be needing much portability.. HP will be better than Acer na??
 
M

motorheadinc

Adept
Jun 17, 2008
391
2
0
39
www.awishcar.com
I would recommend to forget

Acer: Not that good build quality

HP/Compaq: Terrible failure rate

Lenovo: You have better options

Most people on this forum recommend Dell and I wont be an exception. The NBD warranty gives you immense peace of mind.

Whatever they lack in specifications they more than make up for it in reliability and after sales service.

My suggestion buy the Dell Vostro Vostro 3400 Laptop Details | Dell India

Looks good and withing your budget you will get i5 and NVIDIA(R) Geforce(TM) 310M, 512MB Graphics

Would suggest you to check this out.
 
hirumon

hirumon

Disciple
Jun 13, 2008
101
1
79
36
Trivandrum
motorheadinc said:
I would recommend to forget
Acer: Not that good build quality
HP/Compaq: Terrible failure rate
Lenovo: You have better options

Most people on this forum recommend Dell and I wont be an exception. The NBD warranty gives you immense peace of mind.
Whatever they lack in specifications they more than make up for it in reliability and after sales service.
My suggestion buy the Dell Vostro Vostro 3400 Laptop Details | Dell India
Looks good and withing your budget you will get i5 and NVIDIA(R) Geforce(TM) 310M, 512MB Graphics

Would suggest you to check this out.
Click to expand...
No man...310 is very inferior compared to 5650/5730.. At least GT335 needed..
 
M

motorheadinc

Adept
Jun 17, 2008
391
2
0
39
www.awishcar.com
Well if you want a higher specced laptop that dies on you and then you spend days trying to get it fixed.

Not to mention paying for repairs even in Warranty. Thats what has been happening with many of my

friends who have bought HP.

Plus on a laptop you would hardly be able to notice the difference in the graphic card capability.
 
RS4

RS4

Skilled
May 16, 2010
1,941
301
173
India
Go for the Lenovo Y560 with Ati 5730 graphics card as you will be gaming a lot in hostel:eek:hyeah:
The i3-350m cpu is more than enough for your usage conditions.I agree that dell support is no.1 in India and provides on-site warranty but lenovo is not bad,the only thing is that you have to take it to their service centre,BUT Dell inspiron/studio/vostro come with very very weak graphics card such as Ati 5470 or nvidia G310M whose performance is like 50% of ati 5730 and you wont be able to run future(next 2 yrs) games even at low resolution and detail,heck these cards cant play even current games in medium resolution and detail:no:
 
G

gauviz

Adept
Mar 19, 2009
330
13
82
motorheadinc said:
Well if you want a higher specced laptop that dies on you and then you spend days trying to get it fixed.

Not to mention paying for repairs even in Warranty. Thats what has been happening with many of my

friends who have bought HP.

Plus on a laptop you would hardly be able to notice the difference in the graphic card capability.
Click to expand...
I agree HP has worst ASS, you wont even believehow bad it is. Never ever buy an HP no matter how good the deal is.
 
P

prashantrana

Adept
Mar 17, 2005
211
3
29
44
New Delhi, India
www.prashantrana.com
Notebookcheck: Mobile Graphics Cards - Benchmark List

I would consider the following dell system also

The Dell Online Store: Build Your System

Though its an inspiron but is 15" , 4 GB RAM, ATI Mobility 550V 1 GB Graphics card (based on 4650 with a slower clock speed, it is DirectX 10.1 but performs better than 5470)

I have added

Genuine Home Premium

ATI Mobility Radeon 550V

Targus Curve 16" Backpack

1 Year Complete Cover Accidental Damage Protection

which take the price to 47837 + 900 = 48737

I would have loved a 9 Cell battery and Creative XFi Software Sound Solution but that's available only in studio range but then you won't get the ATI Mobility Radeon 550V

Also note that the Graphics Card updates are only provided by the laptop manufacturer and not by ATI.
 
hirumon

hirumon

Disciple
Jun 13, 2008
101
1
79
36
Trivandrum
Thanks for the help guys..

I have booked Lenovo Y560 today..will get it on Monday.. :)

--- Updated Post - Automerged ---
motorheadinc said:
Plus on a laptop you would hardly be able to notice the difference in the graphic card capability.
Click to expand...

Yes u can dude.. My friend's Dell Inspiron 15R with 5470 cant do COD MW2 / NFS shift etc on medium settings...while other friends EB16 with 5650 does so with ease.. Try playing more dude then u can understand..
 
Top Bottom