Western Digital 500GB Caviar Green SATA HDD Review

With the whole world going green, Western Digital has offered Eco-conscious users an
alternative with the Cavier Green hard drives.

Western Digital claims that this green series of hard drives use lesser power. Also they
are supposed to run cooler. This is done, in my opinion, to remove he excess power usage due to hard drive coolers.

The Packaging:-
There is nothing different from ny other drive on the market. This comes in a silver
conductive bag with a sachet of silicon gel in it, for keeping static electricity and
moisture at bay.

Now, lets get to business. The part where it matters.
The Benchmarking Tools Used:-
ATTO
PCMark Vantage x64
HD Tune Pro
Everest Disk Benchmark.

Test System Setup
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/sys specs.png

Hard Disk Specifications
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/hdd specs771.png
ATTO Benchmark Results
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/atto benchmark.png
More is Better

HD Tune Benchmark Results
Read Benchmark:-
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/hd tune benchmark.png
The curve is sloping downward.. this is mainly due to the fact that read speed is fastest at the centre and slow at the ends.

File Benchmark:-
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/hd tune file benchmark.png
This benchmark is performed by writing and reading files to a disk.
The read speed is quite high at latter ends is quite good. It is normal for the write speed to lag.
Health Info:-
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/hd tune health.png
Everest Disk Benchmark:-

Read suite:-
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/everest read benchmark.png
Begin stands for areas closer to the centre,
End stands for ends closer to the ends of the disk
Middle is for anything in-between.

Linear Read
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/everest linear read benchmark.png
The results are astounding.
Summary and Conclusion
With an average write speed of 70 MB/s this hard disk is pretty neat.
http://img.techpowerup.org/101006/HDD idle temp comparison845.png
Temperatures at Idle is just 36C with an ambient of 30C is really prooving the point of being a ECO and COOL drive.
**Pros:-
Price is just Rs.1742 (inclusive of all taxes)
Speed is more than enough for simple storage and acceptable for some gaming.

Cons:-
NONE!**

hope you enjoyed this review. and that it was helpful.

2 Likes

Price just 1742 INR for a 500GB HDD ?? How come?

some pics showing HDD’s thickness etc would be goo. nice review. and congrats on purchase.

The price dropped this month. thats why i got it :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:
muahahahaha!

yeah! good idea!
for the time being, lemme say that its big and fills the whole drivebay pretty well.

nice review really informative.

Yes. Seagate 7200.12 costs some 2.1k. Price of HDDs has come down drastically recently.

You mean to say none for now. Newer WD green and blue drives are just dying out after some months of use.

Edit: You copy pasted from here: Western Digital 500GB Caviar Green Review | TechPowerUp Forums and you’ve hotlinked the image. Are you the same guy?

7200.12 is 1.85k now.

check this>

http://www.techenclave.com/dealers-paradise/seagate-desktop-laptop-internal-drive-price-175381.html

i am the same guy my dear friend. LOL.

even our signatures are the same!!!
LOL. you even sent me a PM over there!

anyway, thanks..

good review mate !!!

Nice review buddy! :slight_smile:

Ofcourse he is the same guy!!!

Didn’t you notice the same name???

The WD 500GB blue cost just 1950/-

Isn’t it the other way around?

thanks! i do proffesional. sorry i dont have a camera though. :frowning:

THANKS dude!

i tried sooo hard. but i couldn’t find a blue or a black one in Kolkata!!!

i dont think so mate, check the everest results.
you know how the tracks are made on the disk right?
its just concentric circles divided by radii.
so for a single track to be read, a track will be read faster at the center(due to lower circumference) and slower at the edges(due to greater circumference). Note that the speed of rotation is a constant 7200RPM.

the speed on the disk at the centre and at the edges is different (law of mechanics)

Eg. the higher speeds in gears have an overall lower circumference since they increase the speed of the wheel at the same rpm. i.e if the rpm is kept constant, the gears increased, the circumference of the gears gets reduced, the speed at the edges increases, the wheels rotate faster.

dude, this is more depended on the angular velocity than the linear velocity.
mechanics and computers are unfortunately different.

^but then do you infer that there is equal amount of data distributed among the concentric circles?