Android Smart watch

speccy48

speccy48

Recruit
Hi
I am impressed with Apple Series 9 & 10 GPS watches. But I am a die hard Android Fan
So which are the best options for me.
As I am a Sr Citizen, I am looking for a large dial, long battery life and features like ECG, Heart Rate alerts, Sleep Apnea, Fall alert to name a few.
Budget is not a constraint as I was keen to go for Apple Watch but then held back and decided to get some quality feedback here.

Thanks
 
1. Google Pixel Watch 3
2. Whoop band

I would strongly recommend going through Quantified Scientist youtube channel to make a informed decision.
This guy is a scientist working in biomedical field. He regularly tests different wearables for their accuracy and posts his results without any bias.

www.youtube.com

The Quantified Scientist

Looking for a scientific view on wearables? Look no further! My name is Rob, and I am a scientist who is into all sort of wearables, but wants to make sure they are accurate. On this channel, I test different devices, and see how I can use them to improve my life. I am life-logging and...
www.youtube.com www.youtube.com
 
Android has no competitor to Apple watch if you want accurate readings, if your main usecase is just monitoring, then Garmin is the only choice for you
 
altair21 said:
Android has no competitor to Apple watch if you want accurate readings,
Click to expand...
Samsung is catching up. Step counter is more accurate since gen 4 than Apple.


Was not aware of these devices over counting or under counting and what the correction factor is :)
altair21 said:
if your main usecase is just monitoring, then Garmin is the only choice for you
Click to expand...
This might be worth looking at.

But the bottom line is pick whatever watch as your brand of phone as they may not play well with each other.

Garmin would work well with both I would think
 
blr_p said:
Samsung is catching up. Step counter is more accurate since gen 4 than Apple.
Click to expand...
yeah but still not comparable to Apple at all, you can watch the quantified scientist's reviews for your conclusion, for me atleast, there's still a long way to go
blr_p said:
But the bottom line is pick whatever watch as your brand of phone as they may not play well with each other.

Garmin would work well with both I would think
Click to expand...
Garmin has a basic integration with both ios/Apple, but if you want "smart" features like gallery on your watch etc, then Garmin is not for you. Garmin makes watches primarily for athletes/hikers, and their stuff is geared towards them
 
What i noticed is this guy is a senior citizen and he is looking for a watch with accurate heart features...specifically watch that notifies regarding irregular heart rhythms, fall alert, ecg....in that case the best choice would be Google Pixel Watch 3...rest of the android watches lack many advanced heart features or if present are just for the namesake with no accuracy...

Since i have these health concerns i myself use Google Pixel Watch 2 to monitor my health condition
 
I have had several Garmin watches and had friend using Apple watch too.

I will strongly suggest Apple watch if Heart rate and accuracy is of highest priority.
But hate the battery life on all its watches.

Samsung also I have used but it was galaxy 2 (iirc) . It's accuracy was quite poor tbh but the watch was good.

Having said that Garmin is very close too in terms of accuracy. With great battery life.

Other brands like Whoop and Coros all have some amazing reviews too.


If I was in place for buying a watch. Here is the thing if I need a watch for accuracy but okay with charging everyday ....I would go definitely go for Apple.

If I need really good life and equally good accuracy... I would go for Garmin.

If I am on bit of budget but ready to adjust slightly with accuracy .. I'd go for Coros.
This Chinese brand is offering great watches for really amazing prices. Their accuracy is very close too.


I just read the part about you mentioning that you are Senior citizen... definitely go for Apple.

It has really saved life. A sort of One incident has happened in front of me only.
Where I had to stop a friend from hiking when his heart beat has spiked very high and even on resting it was warning signs.

Had I pushed him further things could have gone wrong too.

So go for Apple if health is important.
 
bigb123 said:
...in that case the best choice would be Google Pixel Watch 3...
Click to expand...
This is certainly one Google product we have no issues getting in India

www.reliancedigital.in

Google Pixel Watch 3 45 mm Smartwatch, Silver Aluminum Case, Porcelain Active Band

45 mm AMOLED LTPO Display with 2000 Nits Brightness: Experience ultra-bright visuals even under direct sunlight, providing clear and vivid details on the AMOLED LTPO display.,Snapdragon W5 Gen 1 Cortex-M33 Chip: Powered by the cutting-edge Snapdragon W5 Gen 1 chipset, ensuring smooth performance...
www.reliancedigital.in www.reliancedigital.in

What's the options for service if needed?
 
bigb123 said:

Find a local service centre in India - Pixel Phone Help

Click below to go to our Pixel Walk In Center locator to find a center nearest you.
support.google.com
Click to expand...

Find an authorized repair partner for your Pixel phone - Pixel Phone Help

If your Pixel phone needs repair, the damage might be covered under warranty (based on the type of issue and your device model). Learn more about getting your Pixel phone repaired. Repair options may
support.google.com

^ I don't see pixel watch under list of devices they repair?

Only shows phones
 
blr_p said:

Find an authorized repair partner for your Pixel phone - Pixel Phone Help

If your Pixel phone needs repair, the damage might be covered under warranty (based on the type of issue and your device model). Learn more about getting your Pixel phone repaired. Repair options may
support.google.com

^ I don't see pixel watch under list of devices they repair?

Only shows phones
Click to expand...

Replace or file a warranty claim for Google Pixel Watch - Google Pixel Watch Help

Step 1: Troubleshoot the problem If you experience issues with Google Pixel Watch, these can help you fix common issues: Fix a blank, unresponsive, or error message on the Google Pixel W
support.google.com
 
I won't recommend pixel watch to anyone simply because even Google has admitted it's not repairable, it's a straight replacement. might want to keep that in mind before you buy it
 
Only two walk in centres for now in Delhi & bangalore. Bombay will come soon.


These centres are seemingly designed to offer the highest levels of service for a wide range of Google products available in India, including Pixel phones, Pixel Watch, Pixel Buds, as well as FitBit and Nest devices.
Click to expand...

This article mentions watch which is no where to be found on Google's watch support for India
 
speccy48 said:
Hi
I am impressed with Apple Series 9 & 10 GPS watches. But I am a die hard Android Fan
So which are the best options for me.
As I am a Sr Citizen, I am looking for a large dial, long battery life and features like ECG, Heart Rate alerts, Sleep Apnea, Fall alert to name a few.
Budget is not a constraint as I was keen to go for Apple Watch but then held back and decided to get some quality feedback here.

Thanks
Click to expand...
If you have an iPhone, Apple Watch is your only solid option. Apple Watch has been iterative since series 6. Between 6 and 10, get whichever has best offer. ECG on Apple Watch is single node reading and cannot be taken seriously. Sleep apnea is over rated. Heart rate alerts are very useful though and there are not many that can match accuracy of Apple Watch. I use series 6 mainly for cycling and workouts and it is solid.
Apple Watch does not work with Android btw.
 
altair21 said:
I won't recommend pixel watch to anyone simply because even Google has admitted it's not repairable, it's a straight replacement. might want to keep that in mind before you buy it
Click to expand...
Who even repairs smartwatches ? It is straightup replacement if it is under warranty or a paperweight if out of warranty. You openup a smartwatch for repair the waterproofing goes poofff...most of the reputed brands of smartwatches have a very good build quality that lasts several years given that you take good care of it...
 
bigb123 said:
Who even repairs smartwatches ? It is straightup replacement if it is under warranty or a paperweight if out of warranty. You openup a smartwatch for repair the waterproofing goes poofff...most of the reputed brands of smartwatches have a very good build quality that lasts several years given that you take good care of it...
Click to expand...
Bhai, Apple Watch series 6 display replacement cost is 7k. New Series 10 costs about 47k. I won't throw my watch away if display is gone. Same is the case with battery change. Battery change costs 4.5k and I am planning to get it replaced as I am not getting full day battery life. No way I am going to throw it away just coz battery is now weak.
 
bigb123 said:
It is straightup replacement if it is under warranty or a paperweight if out of warranty.
Click to expand...
Question is if they will honour the warranty in India?
bigb123 said:
You openup a smartwatch for repair the waterproofing goes poofff...
Click to expand...
With Gshocks its a question of changing the gasket. Ideally there should be a device that checks the watch for depth but that is not available in India. So won't be able to go diving with it down to 200m like when it was new but doing the dishes is fine
bigb123 said:
most of the reputed brands of smartwatches have a very good build quality that lasts several years given that you take good care of it...
Click to expand...
Yeah, this is what we have to bank on.

Keep in mind its not difficult to bump the dial somewhere and crack it.

What do you do then and how much does it cost with this replacement only agreement?
 
blr_p said:
Question is if they will honour the warranty in India?
Click to expand...
They will have to. They are obliged to follow Indian Laws if they are doing business here.
blr_p said:
With Gshocks its a question of changing the gasket. Ideally there should be a device that checks the watch for depth but that is not available in India. So won't be able to go diving with it down to 200m like when it was new but doing the dishes is fine
Click to expand...
Gshock uses gasket...most of the brands use sticky glue to seal their watches...if the technicians repairing the watch are not careful there is a high chance the glue after repairs is not waterproof...
blr_p said:
Keep in mind its not difficult to bump the dial somewhere and crack it.
Click to expand...
Using a good protective case for such expensive devices is a must and if by chance you break it and it is out of warranty there are places in india where jugadu repairs can be performed...and if that also fails then time to say Goodbye ..
 
Last edited:
Back
Top