Corsair H50 : Feedback and Queries

Status
Not open for further replies.
|Anish| said:
Not sure how metal would react when in contact with water.

The coolant - distilled water in this case which is the purest form of water does not have any ions (such as chloride ions) or minerals which may corrode the internals of the water block (made of copper. Besides, additives are added to distilled water which behave as corrosion inhibitors.
 
So its not really recommended for me ? :(

And how much time do you think after which it will start corroding? Will it atleast work fine for 6-8 months?

The reason why i am after this is because even with air coolers my situation is bad. Fans emit some greasy gooey stuff and drop on other components thus killing them instantly. I lost 2 gfx cards that way.

I think thats mostly moisture.
 
|Anish| said:
So its not really recommended for me ? :(

And how much time do you think after which it will start corroding? Will it atleast work fine for 6-8 months?
The reason why i am after this is because even with air coolers my situation is bad. Fans emit some greasy gooey stuff and drop on other components thus killing them instantly. I lost 2 gfx cards that way.

I think thats mostly moisture.

:huh:
didn't get you..he tried to say that it wont corrode easily with a coolant inside combined with distilled water.

and what is with the stuff leaking out of the fans?? :O:crazy:
does it happen with all system fans?
could you shed more light on the same please?
 
^^

Anish, you house is on the beach or what. (No offense meant). :)

As The Desecrator highlighted, the coolant is ion free, so oxidation should not take place. And also since the coolant will be in a sealed loop, and cooled via non-direct contact by the radiator (in the pipes), so external elements would not permeate into the coolant.

What you meant by the fan emitting greasy substance..?
 
|Anish| said:
Fans emit some greasy gooey stuff and drop on other components thus killing them instantly. I lost 2 gfx cards that way.

Wow that's really bad! What makes are those fans anyway? :P
 
Oh! Sorry. I must have interpreted him wrong. So its corrosion free! Thanks for clearing that guys :ashamed:

And yes, my house is literally beach facing. Can see the Bandra-worli sealink even if i strafe a lil' :lol:

The greasy substance is emitted just before, during and after monsoon. So, approx. 6 months i am in deep sh!t. It happens with all moving parts in my system.

If you observe a new fan which is on continuously for a week, you will find a sticky layer of that similar gooey substance on the fins.

Oh yes, btw when that gooey substance falls and dries off, it looks like crow shit :| Scary eh?
 
Now to bother Desecrator some more:

Will the "Swiftech Apex Ultima" follow the same logic for corrosion free..?
 
If you're going to watercool, build a kit. If you don't want to hassle of that, buy a Megahalems or TRUE. Sounds cliche, but the cost/benefit in addition to the risk of a shoddily built water cooler is not something you want to mess with.
this 'kits' offer nothing as far as learning about water cooling, but if your not after that then i guess it doesn't much matter.

Recently we build a experimental water cooling kit in our office and the results were very good indeed compared to the cost we had spent . These are some thing that you would need

CPU waterblock
GPU block (If you're planning on it)
Northbridge block (you really don't need it, it is a novelty at best. Just get a good Air Cooler if your's is passive or loud)
Pump (We got Danger Den )
Resivoir (or T-line, take your pick)
Tubing (I'd recommend Tygon, 1/2 inch)
Radiator (If only CPU block, 1 or 2 fan rad. CPU+GPU: 2fan, and a 1 fan)
Coolant (or just get an additive that you mix into distilled water.)
Clamps (You can pick up some "worm drive" tube clamps at your local hardware store.)

All these came for less then 3.4k and the results were far better then a h50 can take . If you are interested we would help you assemble the kit .
 
One can build a kit when he has the knowledge of all this. My say is that one can learn with the kit and then upgrade/modify/customize it accordingly when he acquires the knowledge of w/c.
 
|Anish| said:
Oh! Sorry. I must have interpreted him wrong. So its corrosion free! Thanks for clearing that guys :ashamed:

And yes, my house is literally beach facing. Can see the Bandra-worli sealink even if i strafe a lil' :lol:

The greasy substance is emitted just before, during and after monsoon. So, approx. 6 months i am in deep sh!t. It happens with all moving parts in my system.

If you observe a new fan which is on continuously for a week, you will find a sticky layer of that similar gooey substance on the fins.

Oh yes, btw when that gooey substance falls and dries off, it looks like crow shit :| Scary eh?

ok, then im aware of what you mean, i kind of face similar issue in that time period...but not in that much proportion.

to avoid dust/dirt accumulation, i generally clean my cabby (complete paring of all components and assembling them back) every month...once in 2months in winters... (have to do that due to dusty environment)

you can perhaps use a tissue paper as an air filter on evach and every vent in the cabinet..air intake/outlet whatever it maybe.. may save you from moisture..

also...you can always get those patches like small pouches which one finds in HDD packaging and other electronics packages generally..they are good for absorbing moisture and maybe helpful in saving ur gpus :P

|Anish| said:
One can build a kit when he has the knowledge of all this. My say is that one can learn with the kit and then upgrade/modify/customize it accordingly when he acquires the knowledge of w/c.

the only problem is that more the knowledge you get about it the harder it becomes to decide and costlier to build. :P

currently Swiftech H2O 220 Compact does look like a good kit to start with..with possibility to add a waterblock for gpu without having to alter rest of the kit.

regardless, i would prefer not jumping to water cooling considering the price point simply because i do not plan to OC extreme 24x7 at least for now.

i upgrade my cpu once every 1.5yrs... assuming i would want to use the watercooling kits for say 5yrs.. i will be cycling it over 3 CPUs... that is... 10k for 3cpus...at max 4cpus.. gives me about atleast 2.5k per cpu.. which imo would be more significant if i invest it in a better cpu..everytime...would it not ??!!
 
|Anish| said:
One can build a kit when he has the knowledge of all this. My say is that one can learn with the kit and then upgrade/modify/customize it accordingly when he acquires the knowledge of w/c.

You are right but the cost/benifit ratio is indeed very good . I had no knowledge whatsoever when we first started the project but its not that difficult if there is some1 to show how to do it .
 
Creating a customized DOY water unit, would be really fun. But it is so difficult to easily procure the parts (water blocks, tubing, clamping, reservoirs, clamps) on the fly -- and am not talking about harvested parts from a/c's, pumps, refrigeration units. I would still prefer to buy a company made liquid cooled kit. Though, Rohan, if you could give a summary of how you assembled your kit, it would be nice. Or is it proprietary to your office. If the parts are readily available, and I can go back to shops and choose what I want, then creating a simple blue print, and implementing it should not be that difficult.

Regarding the price / performance ratio vs. a standard HSF, I see it as a good benefit, if I want to keep my chip always on highest possible OC. Some things are done just for 'kicks' sake. Liquid cooling would fall in that. Also as Madnav mentioned, it could be worth while, if the kit is reused for different sockets. (Though there could be an issue for the back plate and water block compatibility). I am swaying towards the 'Swiftech Apex Ultima'. Lets see what else this great discussion brings up.
 
asingh said:
. Though, Rohan, if you could give a summary of how you assembled your kit, it would be nice. Or is it proprietary to your office. If the parts are readily available, and I can go back to shops and choose what I want, then creating a simple blue print, and implementing it should not be that difficult.
.

I would be glad to . We managed to buy all these items just within a week when we first had the idea of water cooling . A colleague of mine got most of the stuff from a local hardware shop in Powai (mumbai )and lamington but i will have to verify the cost with him .
 
^^There are several members in the forum who have gone the DIY way for liquid cooling. The most impressive of the lot IMO was the one made by ninbychoice aka Raghunandan. There must be a thread around. He made one using parts salvaged from a lot of places - a heater core IIRC from a car, a machined copper CPU block with barbs brazed onto it and an immersible pump.

Going DIY IMO does not lend a professional touch to the setup since you end up with parts from a lot of places and the enclosure may not house a heater core.

Will the "Swiftech Apex Ultima" follow the same logic for corrosion free..?

Any WC kit would if you use the right coolant and the material for construction.
 
Desecrator said:
^The 200mm fan in your enclosure - isn't it mounted as an exhaust? How is it blowing the air over the block then? :P

U didn't read my setup which i pointed out earlier .. Front + Side 200 mm intake, Top 200 mm out .. so Rear 120 mm blows into the radiator ...

asingh said:
deathvirus_me, why do you not mount the radiator fan as an exhaust. Flip it around. Would be better. Or is your case cooling, set up different.

The logic is to blow in cool air over the radiator .. now internal ambient temps are obviously gonna be more than the room temps .. so blowing in cooler air from the outside seems more logical .. and in my case i have an immediate exhaust on top .. seems to work fine

Also a RealTemp screenie ...

 
Nope! You got a typo there -

deathvirus_me said:
Also, in my case it doesn't gets slightly warm. .. but the guess 200mm fan blowing in air over it makes it stay cool ..

You mentioned a 200mm fan blowing air over the block which's why I asked! :cool2:

EDIT: Just noticed the side fan being a 200mm one! :P
 
deathvirus_me/Descrator:

Pretty nice. Thanks for the informative posts. Will request more insights..!
 
Believe it or not, i got a Corsair H50 !

got it for 2.9k from my cousin who hardly used it for 4-5 months, top notch condition !

Though i am sort of disappointed with the idle temps, but its touching well inside 67 on all cores when clocked to 4G @ 1.23-1.26v.
 
^^

Gosh, that was fast. What were the temperatures like, before the H50 was installed..?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.