Storage Solutions External HDD free fall!

Status
Not open for further replies.

teche

Contributor
Hi, I am using a WD-My Essential 320gb external hard drive. It had almost reached capacity when accidently it fell down in the morning.
When I picked it up, I could see panel gap in its casing, tried correcting it but it gave clicking sounds but did not fix properly.
In panic I checked its data situation & thankfully things were working fine.
I can still the gap in its panel though from which inside contents of the disk can be seen.

1) Now, should I get in touch with WD service & ask for replacement? I could always tell them that this is how it came out of the box!

Later I got a 320gb Transcend Shock proof HDD & quickly transfered data to it. I first tried to back it up but Vista says that contents of "C" would be backed up simiutaniously. This could not happen because total data crossed 400GB.

2) Then I copy pasted the contents from WD to Transcend. It did take time but is it the right method or should I have adopted some diff. approach?

Later in the day, I set a few torrents downloads on remaining portion of Transcend. After about 1-2% download, they showed Data Error - cyclic redundancy check. This was related to HDD & not u-torrent.

3) Does this mean the new Transcend is corrupt or copying files caused this?
What should I do should I defragment the new disk & convert it to FAT32?

For future I've thought of backing up all the data (Comp + WD hdd + Transcend hdd) on a 1tb HDD.

Also suggest should I transfer data from HDD to DVD's & keep the HDD free for further use?
How much does a DVD cost & how much data can it accomodate?
 
Imagine ur 1TB HDD going conk all of a sudden...:bleh:

Backup all ur data on DVDs for a longer lifetime and data security. :cool2:
And DVDs are just 10-11 bucks a piece.
 
Dude,
Before u even think of using DVDs as a long terms solution for data storage, please try to access a media from any DVD which u might hav burnt 1 1/2-2 yrs back & ull get the answer abt the reliability of DVDs over a external HDD...
 
ranjitonly said:
Dude,
Before u even think of using DVDs as a long terms solution for data storage, please try to access a media from any DVD which u might hav burnt 1 1/2-2 yrs back & ull get the answer abt the reliability of DVDs over a external HDD...

Yeh I agree. Forget abt 1 yr. I burnt a few DVDs 15 days back. It contaned RS rars of movies as my PC HDD was full. Now, as I have bought 1TB Ext HDD, I started to transfer this files to Ext HDD, 4-5 files i.e. .8-1 gb of data from each DVD is showing cycling redundancy error. Each DVD was read perfectly after burning. Now, fisssssssssssssssss.
 
clown_abhi said:
Imagine ur 1TB HDD going conk all of a sudden...:bleh:
Backup all ur data on DVDs for a longer lifetime and data security. :cool2:
And DVDs are just 10-11 bucks a piece.

Thanks, see 1TB would be a 3.5" drive, shall be kept on a table stationary!

Not yet sure about DVD's, it shall be a huge pileup!

ranjitonly said:
Before u even think of using DVDs as a long terms solution for data storage, please try to access a media from any DVD which u might hav burnt 1 1/2-2 yrs back & ull get the answer abt the reliability of DVDs over a external HDD...

Thanks, that's what worries me too!

Kevin Lane said:
4-5 files i.e. .8-1 gb of data from each DVD is showing cycling redudency error.

Open the files showing error & skip downloading, they shall start working.

Gaurish said:
run chkdsk on the drive and see if you get any file system errors.

Thanks, drive is working as of now, but I can still see the external casing open due to the fall!
Will the open external casing pose some problem?

naveen58 said:
IMO ask WD for a replacement.
Thanks, that's what Im thinking, but worry they might refuse the claim citing mechanical damage.
 
Originally Posted by naveen58 View Post
IMO ask WD for a replacement.
Thanks, that's what Im thinking, but worry they might refuse the claim citing mechanical damage.

Yeah. If it is hard disk fault then they would replace. Atleast if it is not working now then you are having a chance. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.