Graphic Cards GeForce 7800 GTX cards compared Four aces

GeForce 7800 GTX cards compared Four aces

The first thing that should be said in any roundup of GeForce 7800 GTX video cards is that these cards are all essentially the same thing. NVIDIA doesn't just design the GPU; they create a reference design for the whole card, memory and all. NVIDIA's board partners then manufacture those boards according to NVIDIA's specification, usually with very little deviation from the original design. Outside of a few minor differences like the stickers on their coolers, the three brands of boards we're reviewing here today are virtually indistinguishable unless you examine them side by side.

Upon closer inspection, there are some minor differences. The hue of the green dye used to color the PCBs varies slightly from one board to the next. The XFX and BFG boards are made in China, while MSI's are made in Taiwan. But the more important things, like the size, type, placement, and brand of components on each card, don't differ. Even the coolers on all three brands of cards are the same.

What that means is that these products have to compete with one another on the basis of things other than the basic card design. Buy any decent brand of GeForce 7800 GTX, and you're getting essentially the same board. The differences between the products come in the form of warranties, default clock speeds, bundled extras, and the like.

Amazingly enough, once you start doing the math with that assumption in mind, picking out GeForce 7800 GTX cards probably gets harder, not easier. Fortunately, that's true in large part because all three of the brands we're examining today are good choices.

Overclocking

I used the NVIDIA driver's built-in ability to detect optimal clock frequencies for overclocking in order to determine the speeds for our overclocking tests. Sometimes it's possible to squeeze out a little more speed with manual trial and error, but the NVIDIA utility does a decent job of finding appropriate speeds. I even had to back the BFG card down from the 675MHz memory clock that the driver chose for it. The system was locking up with the video RAM at that speed.

Overall, overclock speeds were very similar, and quite good. All three cards topped out at GPU clocks of about 490MHz, or 60MHz above NVIDIA's stock reference card speed. Memory seemed to top out at about 660MHz, also 60MHz above stock.

Just to see what it could do, I also tested with MSI's D.O.T. set to the highest level, "Commander."

There are some small differences in performance here, but as you can see, once you get into specifying the clock speed yourself, all three brands perform pretty much the same. MSI's D.O.T. does manage to squeeze out just a little bit more speed than NVIDIA's driver-based overclocking tool, but we're talking less than one frame per second of difference.

Read Complete Article @ [rank=www.techreport.com/reviews/2005q3/7800gtx-comparo/index.x?pg=1]TechReport.com [/rank]
 
Back
Top