PC Peripherals Gigabyte or Liteon DVD Writer

Status
Not open for further replies.
Guys i am really confused between these 2 dvd writers.

Speeds as DVD +R/-R/+RW/-RW/+R Dual Layer/CDR/CDRW

Liteon SOHW-1673S 16/16/8/6/4/40/24
Gigabyte GO-16166 16/16/4/4/4/40/24

The Gigabyte has a very low CPU utiization and Liteon has a higher CPU Utilization.

Both have buffer 2MB

Liteon
Seek Time Full - [ms] - 199|214
Spin Up / Spin Down [DVD] - 2.2|3.19
Spin Up / Spin Down [CD] - 2.2|3.19
File Ripping VOB - 70 sec
Audio Extraction - 110 sec

Gigabyte
Seek Time Full - [ms] - 187|171
Spin Up / Spin Down [DVD] - 0.06|0.01
Spin Up / Spin Down [CD] - 0.06|0.01
File Ripping VOB - 98 sec
Audio Extraction - 45 sec

I have never used any Gigabyte optical product but have seen Liteon products they are gr8

Liteon - 4995
Gigabyte - 6075

Costs might have come down now these were the costs 2 months ago.

Help me decide between these 2.

Also wanted to know how much is 1X Transfer speed for CD & DVD
 
Yeah i'll second that, using a 1600 flashed to 1620 ! Gr8 drive, regular formware updates and gr8 compatibility with various media. Becareful though if you are from mumbai, since the drive seems to be in shortage right now. Also refer to the optical drive guide stickied in the gen hardware section.
 
Stay away from LiteOn drives,they are choosy about the media used with them.

Best Bet-
BenQ,Asus,Pioneer,LG
 
Well this is further confusing me now .

Stay away from LiteOn drives,they are choosy about the media used with them
@ darky are u sure on this

As one of my friend has a liteon 1653s it and it seems to write on any media
he has thrown at it.
 
Writing is not a problem but the c1/c2 errors fluctuate a lot with media.
If thrown decent media like Ricohjpn or T Y then its no problem.
Infact MB India is considered one of the best dies in DVD media but my LiteOn gave horrible scans on it.
Whereas the same media gives excellent scans on my Benq.
 
Darky is absolutely right... the Liteys (and the sonys which are liteon oem) give horrible PI/PIF scans with media other than Taiyo Yuden/MCC/Ricoh jpn. The more PI/PIF errors, the quicker the DVD will turn into a coaster. So even though data burnt by a 1673 might not seem to have a prob now, after a few hundred reads, the disk will be totally screwed and unreadable. In DVD burners these days, the prime issue is neither time reqd to burn or cpu utilization but the write quality. Currently the pioneer a09/benq 1620/nec 3520/plextor 716 drives have the best burn quality. Asus is pioneer oem, msi is benq oem. So either of those are okay as well.
 
Quad Master said:
How about Pioneer DVR-108

Also wanted to know how much is 1X Transfer speed for CD & DVD
Its a very good drive. But try and get the 109. Its quite a bit faster than the 108.
 
The Pioneer DVR-109 is gr8

Key features
Writes and reads DVD-R/RW, +R/RW and CD-R/RW formats

DVD/CD buffer under-run protection

Max. 16x writing speed for DVD-R/+R
Max. 6x writing speed for DVD-R Dual Layer and +R Double Layer Discs
Max. 6x writing speed for DVD-RW
Max. 8x writing speed for +RW

DVD data capacity of 4.7 GB per single-sided disc and 8.5 GB Dual/Double layer discs

Full Info:- http://www.pioneer-eur.com/eur/product_print.jsp?product_id=9914
 
Guys what so gr8 about the benq drive that you rank it above all others
writers.

also wanted to know what do you feel about the pioneer dvr109 mentioned aboue i have to ge tmy writer in 2-3 days so please let me know
 
Wots so gr8 abt the benq: Umm amongst the best write quality, one of the fastest writers i believe, regular firmware updates and a gr8 price to boot make it one of the best drives out there. If you have reservations about the Benq brand (which i believe u do) then go for the Pioneer 109 !

Also do chk out reviews @ AT, cdrinfo and cdfreaks to get an clear picture. Maybe techhead can add more to this ............ :)
 
Wots so gr8 abt the benq: Umm amongst the best write quality, one of the fastest writers i believe, regular firmware updates and a gr8 price to boot make it one of the best drives out there. If you have reservations about the Benq brand (which i believe u do) then go for the Pioneer 109 !

Also do chk out reviews @ AT, cdrinfo and cdfreaks to get a clear picture. Maybe techhead can add more to this ............ :)
 
Found a bit of advantages of Pioneer DVR 109 over Benq
- Pioneer also supports DVD-RAM reading at CLV 2x

The new Benq DW1640
The BenQ DW1640 supports 16x DVD±R, 8x DVD+RW, 6x DVD-RW and 8x DVD+R9 DL writing technology, allowing dual layer discs of 8.5Gb to be written. So far this is the worlds first DVD-burner to support the DVD+R9 DL format at 8x.

More Info:- http://www.cdfreaks.com/article/193

Taken from - www.BenQ.com

Performance
[DVD+R DL]
Data Transfer Rate /double layer write: 88.64 Mbit/sec (8X)
[DVD+R/+RW]
Data Transfer Rate /write: 177.28 Mbit/sec (16X)
Data Transfer Rate /rewrite: 88.64 Mbit/sec (8X)
[DVD-R/-RW]
Data Transfer Rate /write: 177.28 Mbit/sec (16X)
Data Transfer Rate /rewrite: 66.48 Mbit/sec (6X)
[DVDROM]
Data Transfer Rate /read: 177.28 Mbit/sec (16X, Max.)Access time: 120 ms
[CD]
Data Transfer Rate /write: 7200 KByte/sec (48X)
Data Transfer Rate /rewrite: 4800 KByte/sec (32X)
Data Transfer Rate /read: 7200 KByte/sec (48X, Max.)
Access time: 120 ms

Interface
E-IDE/ATAPI

Supported IDE mode
PIO mode 0/1/2/3/4
DMA mode 0/1/2
UDMA mode 0/1/2

Buffer Size 2 Mbytes

Writing Mode
[DVD+R/+RW]
DVD Data and Video
[CD-R/-RW]
Track-at-Once, Disc-at-Once, Multisession, Packet Writing (fixed & variable packet), CD Digital Audio, Direct-Over-Write on CD-RW, Test Write

Disc Size
[DVD] 120 mm disc
[CD] 80 and 120 mm discs

Disc Formats
[DVD]
DVD+R DL 8.5GB, DVD+R 4.7GB, DVD+RW 4.7GB, DVD-R 4.7GB (closed session), DVD-RW 4.7GB (closed session), DVD-Video, DVD-5, DVD-9, DVD-10, DVD-18
[CD]
CD-DA, CD-ROM XA (m1, m2f1/m2f2), CD-R, CD-RW, Bootable CD, Photo CD (single & multi-session), Video CD, Super Video CD, CD-Extra, Mixed-mode CD, CD-Text

Audio Performance
Signal-to-Noise ratio: 76 dB min.
Number of stereo channels: 2
Analog audio line output: 0.75 VRMS at 470 Ohm
Analog headphone output: 0.6 VRMS at 34 Ohm
CD sampling frequency: 44.1 KHz

Power Requirement
+5V± 5%, ripple: 100mVpp
+12V ± 10%, ripple: 200mVpp

Environment Conditions

Operating temperature:
5 0C~50 0C (410F~1220F) at humidity of 8-80% RH
Non-operating temperature:
-40 0C~60 0C (-40 0F~140 0F) at humidity: 5%~95% RH

Reliability Characteristics
MTBF: 125,000 POH (20%)
Non-recoverable read error < 1 block in 1012 bits (CD and DVD)

Firmware Update
Flash memory upgradeable

Panel Design
Front side:
open/close button and read/write status indicator LED
Rear side:
40-pin ATA-2 dual row flat-cable connector, 4-pin DC power connector, 3-position device jumpers, digital audio output and analog audio output

OS Compatibility
Windows XP, 2000, ME, 98SE
Speciality
The ventilation system/feature called Air Flow Cooling System (AFCS) and Anti-Dust Cooling System (ADCS)
check:- http://gfx.cdfreaks.com/reviews/benq_dw1640_pre/image015.jpg

Dual Cooling System
BenQ's exclusive Dual Cooling System (DCS) features an Anti-Dust Cooling System (ADCS) and Air Flow Cooling System (AFCS) to effectively reduce the risk of over-heating during high-speed reading and writing.

Air Flow Cooling System (AFCS)
AFCS accelerates the circulation inside the drive and speeds up the heat elimination through the drive's steel housing.
Check Image:- http://gfx.cdfreaks.com/reviews/benq_dw1640_pre/image026.jpg

Anti-Dust Cooling System (ADCS)
With an integrated heat chimney design, ADCS redirects the heat flow out of the drive, while still providing protection from dust.
Check Image:- http://gfx.cdfreaks.com/reviews/benq_dw1640_pre/image027.jpg

Positive:
Supports DVD+R/R9 DL/-R at 16x/8x/16x
Supports CD-R/RW at 48x/32x
Supports bitsetting for all types of DVD+R/R9 DL/RW (sets auto. booktype to DVD-ROM)
Supports disc quality scanning
Can read 99/100 minutes CD-R’s
Reads DVD+R/-R at 16x
Reads DVD+RW/R9 DL/-RW at 12x
Reads DVD-Video SL/DL at 16x/12x
Good Software package
Cheap price

Negative:
Does not support Mt. Rainier
Does not support LightScribe
Reads CD-RW only at 40x
Green LED for both reading and writing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Benq DW1640 looks much much better than Pioneer DVR109


Discussion on Benq DW1640 to be carried here:-
http://www.techenclave.com/forums/showthread.php?p=20696#post20696


But please answer my doubts here
- I wanted to ask if Benq DW1640 is available here this really has gr8 features.
- And want your opinion on this benq dw1640 writer.
- You people have more optical drive knowledge than mine so please let me know.
- Also wanted to ask that did anyone have a bad experience with any Benq DVD Writers
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top