Storage Solutions Hitachi Vs Seagate Vs WD :> Help!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

dj_faithless

Contributor
Guys...im jus about to buy a 1tb hdd (16mb/32mb buffer depending on price)

Plz suggest which 1 shud i go for ??:S

Hitachi charges a hefty premium for its 32mb buffer 1tb hdd wch is 1k more den WD. But the performance is good.

WD Caviar 1tb only 16mb buffer available. But den its 5400rpm & i heard its slow tho it consumes less power.

Seagate I heard is having a lot of issues with 7200.11 or sumtin :(

Plz help asap as i need to place an order today. I need a reliable hdd with decent service. Any suggestion along with sum pricing wud b of real help :)
 
Go with WD
onsite RMA which is the best. they do it so professionally

no noticable difference between 16 and 32mb

Hitcahi RMA is provided by dealers/resellers and is known to have issues
Now, seagate also offers only 3 yrs warranty
 
Wd service is really good . I got my replacement drive within 1 week after their pickup. Seagate service center for me is far away, costs lot of fare and long lines . Go for WD AAKS series for performance .
 
u get WD 1tb AAKS model also rite??? is dat 32mb buffer??

WD Caviar 1tb 16mb buffer = Rs.5600

Seagate 1tb 32mb buffer = Rs.660
 
^^ so far Wd has the best after sales service..

the seagate 7200.11 drive issues were solved after a firmware upgrade..
 
buy a WD10EACS for 5.4k

WD10EADS & WD1001FALS are faster & have 32MB cache but don't know the prices

there is no WD10000AAKS
 
What is this 1TB drive going to be used for? If its primarily for mass storage like HD, Music, setups etc. u can pretty much bet on the WD 10EACS.

Well, the EACS is the newer series of Green Power drives from WD, the recent ones being the 3-platter version as opposed to the 4-platter ones they've had before. Runs pretty cool and silent. For the price, nothing beats it.

Please do read this one as well: http://www.techenclave.com/962977-post1.html

And it might be advisable to stay away from the 7200.11 Seagate drives. There's an entire thread here dedicated to the failures of the the 7200.11 drives.
 
Gunman said:
What is this 1TB drive going to be used for? If its primarily for mass storage like HD, Music, setups etc. u can pretty much bet on the WD 10EACS.

Well, the EACS is the newer series of Green Power drives from WD, the recent ones being the 3-platter version as opposed to the 4-platter ones they've had before. Runs pretty cool and silent. For the price, nothing beats it.

Please do read this one as well: http://www.techenclave.com/962977-post1.html

And it might be advisable to stay away from the 7200.11 Seagate drives. There's an entire thread here dedicated to the failures of the the 7200.11 drives.

1. The problems been fixed :P (finally, yes, they took time n a lot of bad press in the meanwhile ;))

2. The greenpower series is listed as variable speed / alternately as 'between 5400 and 7200 rpm' :P

It actually runs at 'slightly' more than 5400 (around 5405 I think :P) So the marketing claim is correct, but perf takes a comparative hit.
 
techie_007 said:
The greenpower series is listed as variable speed / alternately as 'between 5400 and 7200 rpm'

I have read this in reviews, but I have not come across this statement on WD's site, what WD's stand on this issue is that they say the GP drives can spin at any speed between 5400 and 7200RPM - depending on circumstances (they dont mention what these circumstances are :S ), they are NOT supposed to have the capability to vary the RPM. In their reviews, the WD GP HDDs have been tested by Anandtech and SPCR and were found to run at 5400 RPM ONLY.

I have the 1 TB WD 10EACS and the WD 7500AAKS and I dont see any noticeable difference when I copy files to either of these HDDs. They both seem to copy files around the same speed. They both run at the same Temperature.

I have 2 WD HDDs and many many more Hitachi HDDs and my experience with the 2 RMA's with Hitachi have been VERY good, both times the HDD problem was due to my fault and Hitachi replaced the HDDs in about 10 days without a question.

I dont use Seagate HDDs, no special reason for this. I use Hitachi's because of all I have read at StorageReview.com
 
Eazy said:
I have read this in reviews, but I have not come across this statement on WD's site, what WD's stand on this issue is that they say the GP drives can spin at any speed between 5400 and 7200RPM - depending on circumstances (they dont mention what these circumstances are :S ), they are NOT supposed to have the capability to vary the RPM. In their reviews, the WD GP HDDs have been tested by Anandtech and SPCR and were found to run at 5400 RPM ONLY.

I have the 1 TB WD 10EACS and the WD 7500AAKS and I dont see any noticeable difference when I copy files to either of these HDDs. They both seem to copy files around the same speed. They both run at the same Temperature.

I have 2 WD HDDs and many many more Hitachi HDDs and my experience with the 2 RMA's with Hitachi have been VERY good, both times the HDD problem was due to my fault and Hitachi replaced the HDDs in about 10 days without a question.

I dont use Seagate HDDs, no special reason for this. I use Hitachi's because of all I have read at StorageReview.com

Exactly, as per all the reviews and info available on the net, its 5400 rpm or close to it only ;)

WD just wont go ahead and say it, tho they are technically being correct when they say it spins between 5400 and 7200, they just dont want to give the impression that its a slower 5400 rpm drive :rofl:

WD Green Power: A New Benchmark in HDD Acoustics & Power | silentpcreview.com

Our 750 GB sample is 5,400 RPM. Storage Review's 1 TB sample was 5,400 RPM. WD's literature lists the possible speed range as 5,400~7,200 RPM, but we have yet to hear reports of any models above 5,400 RPM.

It's quite simple, really. Most of a drive's power is consumed by the motor that spins the disk inside the drive. Reduce the speed of the disk, and you reduce the amount of power required. However, Western Digital doesn't want to say that they're selling 5,400 RPM drives — those became second class in the desktop market years ago. Instead, they rate the drive's speed as "IntelliPower" and take pains to emphasize that there are other factors that affect performance.

Western Digital has caught a lot of flak for withholding the rotation speed of the Green Power, especially when the product was first launched and the marketing material listed the rotation speed as 5,400-7,200 RPM. This led some to speculate that the rotation speed changed dynamically during use — which would have been an impressive engineering feat had it been true. The reality is revealed by a sentence that Western Digital added to the description of IntelliPower: "For each GreenPower™ drive model, WD may use a different, invariable RPM." In other words, Western Digital reserves the right to release both 5,400 RPM and 7,200 RPM drives under the Green Power name — without telling you which are which.

We were able to confirm that our 750 GB Green Power had a spindle speed of 5,400 RPM by doing frequency analysis on a sound recording of it. Why sound? Sound is vibration; the pitch of the sound corresponds to the frequency of the vibration. Hard drives vibrate at the speed of their motor, so they produce a noise at the same frequency as their rotation speed. Our sample had a sharp spike at exactly 90 Hz (cycles per second). Multiplying that number by 60 (to get cycles per minute) yielded a measured rotation speed of 5,400 RPM.

It's possible that other Green Power models use a higher spindle speed — but we doubt it. Storage Review tested the 1 TB version of the drive and determined that that model also spun at 5,400 RPM based on a calculation of the drive's latency compared to a previous Western Digital model. That leaves the 500 GB model — which Western Digital says is even lower power than the larger capacity versions. With the majority of the Green Power's efficiency advantage coming from its lower speed, it seems impossible for the 500 GB model to use a higher rotation speed. It's possible Western Digital intends to release a 7,200 RPM version at some point in the future.

Its still a good drive though, all the speed claims notwithstanding, + supposedly very quiet as well.

It's the quietest desktop

drive we've ever tested. It's the most efficient drive we've ever tested. And it comes in capacities up to 1 TB. What more do you want? As far as SPCR is concerned, this could be the perfect drive — at least until flash media takes over.

We didn't think we'd ever find a drive to replace our trusty Barracuda IV — but then, we never expected a manufacturer to release a mainstream 5,400 RPM drive either. We are pleased and surprised to discover we were wrong on both counts.

The only real question mark hanging over the Green Power is how much the rotation speed affects performance. And, while no reports show it leading the pack, it doesn't seem to be far enough back to worry about. Its high capacity 250 GB platters help mitigate the lower spindle speed.
 
lol...thanks guys for d info...im stil in a dilemma....hitachi charges such a hefty premium... but performance n reviews are good...sad part its not dat easily available.....

again den der is seagate wer i dont want to buy n update firmware n do all dat hastle...

ny final suggestions?

sigh! :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.