Nikhil said:
@QF --- I said in my post. I aM NOT blaming only Pak. It is just that it is stupid if a whole series is decided by a team's 2 bad days.
Blaming the pitch is absolutely unnecessary. The pitch was not entirely flat, but it wasn't so unfriendly to the batsmen that they coiuldn't even score a decent 300+ runs in both innings.
The series wasn't decided because of '2 bad days'. Pakistan won for the simple reason that they played better than India... even Greg Chappell admitted to that. As Boycott said at the end of yesterday's game, if India had played till noon on the fifth day and put up at least a 400+ score, then they could have said that they tried their bit and put in their best but 600 was just too much. But they didn't do that. They lost by a huge 341 runs! That's very poor cricket.
Why blame the pitch? In the second innings, Sehwag got out because his feet were planted to the ground - there was absolutely no foot work (nothing unusual for Sehwag). Dravid got out because he forgot the golden rule - there ought to be no gap between the bat and the pad when you defend the ball. Ganguly got out because he lost concentration after tea. Tendulkar - tried playing the ball on back-foot when he should have played it on front-foot. And Yuvraj Singh was dropped twice before he scored his century... the first drop, when he was at 77, was a lollypop. If he hadn't been dropped, India would have lost by an even larger margin. So thanks to Mr. Faisal Iqbal for saving India some more embarrassment.
Indian bowling was very poor. India no longer has a fast bowler! Zaheer Khan and Irfan Pathan both bowl in the 120kms/h range now. :-\ And more over, Pakistan batted very well. All the first seven batsmen in their line-up scored at least a half century in the second innings. That's amazing, to say the very least. And it goes to show that either Pakistan batted exceptionally well, or India's bowlers put up a very bad bowling attack, or that it was a mix of both.
I was very impressed by Abdul Razzaq's bowling. Yuvraj had a very tough time playing him after he'd reached his half-century. His batting too is nothing short of impressive. He can hit hard or slow as the situation demands. He's your perfect all-rounder.
I think Dhoni should be kept for ODI games and Dinesh Karthik should be played in test games. That would do the Indian cricket team a whole world of good.
The whole series was good. If the the pitches on the first two games weren't so flat, perhaps we may have had more fun watching the teams play, but anyway, at least the third game turned out to be quite good. The upcoming ODI series should be good too. Let's see what happens there.