Eh.. that is early by their standards.
Sobering write-up, sometimes you do realize that there may be a divine power at play.
Indian Railways Train Journey Discussion.
- Thread starter solo_wing
- Start date
Sobering write-up, sometimes you do realize that there may be a divine power at play.
Yes I know. I have been 14 hrs late also but that was few years ago. My point was at this age when we are making big claims of superfast trains coming and bullet train etc. We cant even run normal trains on time.
true.
PoBoy
Herald
I've traveled by train quite a few times in the last few years - mainly between Mumbai and GUJ/RAJ/MP/MAHA/GOA.
By and large the trains have been on time +- 15 min. Actually few times the train has reached the destination (last) stop a bit early.
Once a train starting from Mumbai was going to depart 4 hrs late, I got a SMS well in time - so I left home 4 hrs later.
I'm not complaining - especially seeing how <s>much</s> little we pay. Few years back I would travel Mumbai-Ahmedabad (sleeper, night journey) for Rs 180. Where else would you be able to do something like that? I did Mum to Guj like 30-40 times, LOL. I would travel, to, say, Ahmedabad one night, spend the day sight seeing, and return the same evening.
Karnataka is next this winter. I'll report.
By and large the trains have been on time +- 15 min. Actually few times the train has reached the destination (last) stop a bit early.
Once a train starting from Mumbai was going to depart 4 hrs late, I got a SMS well in time - so I left home 4 hrs later.
I'm not complaining - especially seeing how <s>much</s> little we pay. Few years back I would travel Mumbai-Ahmedabad (sleeper, night journey) for Rs 180. Where else would you be able to do something like that? I did Mum to Guj like 30-40 times, LOL. I would travel, to, say, Ahmedabad one night, spend the day sight seeing, and return the same evening.
Karnataka is next this winter. I'll report.
My complain is with the maintaining the time atleast . For what we pay the conditions can be accepted and that I still partly understand Govt. point of view.
but just because we pay less does not mean going 3-4 hrs late on average is acceptable too. That is just poor efficiency from their part .
BTW trying to get into the dept of things - on this economics of this whole thing that we pay less and we should not accept much. and that Govt. already running these on heavy loss. Now I was reading recent articles where Himachal State Bus service is suffering from heavy loss.
Now There are many Deluxe and semi-Deluxe buses operating with nice leg rooms, AC, plus provide waterbottle, Vomit bags etc operating from Delhi to Shimla and some other major towns in Himachal . They are charging even less than govt. ordinary bus or close to same price. I fail to understand How come they still making profit or able to run their business while Govt. with such poor maintained ordinary bus is showing loss.
There is either big ghapla again or they have their business model all wrong.
PoBoy
Herald
I don't think "going 3-4 hrs late on average" is correct.
Things are def improving, I remember what it was like years ago.
e.g. My relative who has a house in Goa would regularly drive down - I would tell him he must be in the Limca Book of Records. These days, after Vande Bharat, he prefers train. Less than 7 hours from Panvel in comfort.
Traveling sleeper has been a eye-opener, for me at least. You meet so many people - then realise some of them would not be able to travel had it not been for the low train fares.
So many other factors like fog in winter. heavy rains in monsoons ; I'm amazed we have a railway system at all. It might be the 4th largest national railway - keep in mind countries like US are actually 4 to 5 times larger than India. If you don't mind I'll quote ChatGPT :
"The national railway with the most number of passenger trains is Indian Railways. As of the latest data, Indian Railways operates over 13,000 passenger trains daily, serving millions of passengers across the country. This makes it the largest railway network in terms of daily passenger train operations in the world. Indian Railways is known for its extensive network and the large volume of passengers it handles, making it a critical part of India's transportation infrastructure."
Things are def improving, I remember what it was like years ago.
e.g. My relative who has a house in Goa would regularly drive down - I would tell him he must be in the Limca Book of Records. These days, after Vande Bharat, he prefers train. Less than 7 hours from Panvel in comfort.
Traveling sleeper has been a eye-opener, for me at least. You meet so many people - then realise some of them would not be able to travel had it not been for the low train fares.
So many other factors like fog in winter. heavy rains in monsoons ; I'm amazed we have a railway system at all. It might be the 4th largest national railway - keep in mind countries like US are actually 4 to 5 times larger than India. If you don't mind I'll quote ChatGPT :
"The national railway with the most number of passenger trains is Indian Railways. As of the latest data, Indian Railways operates over 13,000 passenger trains daily, serving millions of passengers across the country. This makes it the largest railway network in terms of daily passenger train operations in the world. Indian Railways is known for its extensive network and the large volume of passengers it handles, making it a critical part of India's transportation infrastructure."
according to report last year...one in every 4 train runs late and they are counting short distance trains too in that.
As for weather.... I have been on Russian- Siberian 4 day train that has to deal with heavy snow and extreme winter condition. On every station we were mostly on time.
yes things have improved for sure but they are very slow compared to what other countries are achieving at much faster pace.
Vande Bharat trains are also very slowly being introduced as only handful runs between few major cities on short distances but yes they have recently introduced 2-3 Vande Bharat trains for long distance.
Edit: my bad the sleeper class Vande Bharat not yet introduced for long distance only mid-range distsance.
Last edited:
tr27
Discoverer
Got on the train without ticket, did some groping , some verbal abuse to passengers with ticket, still occupied a seat, trashed the place, did some selfies hanging out of the train door , luckily not dead, came in without any money or luggage but when I got off the train I had a few wallets and few luggage.. 10/10 would recommend.
psyph3r
Innovator
You forgot about the squeaky clean toilets and the Rs.50000 bonus if the train derails and you break your bones.
Good that you had enjoyable trip, are back safe and sound.
Actually was waiting for update on this thread, I remembered commenting here about troubles traveling in rainy season to Kerala.
techenclave.com
It was a sad tragedy, extremely draining for locals in that region.
How was your visits to beaches, if you had such.
Actually was waiting for update on this thread, I remembered commenting here about troubles traveling in rainy season to Kerala.
Indian Railways Train Journey Discussion.
Hello Guys, I have a trek coming in Kerala Next month. I'm travelling by train . I have experienced North Indian Railway Train journeys many time and it is horrible 60% of the time. I'm sure many of us have seen recent videos and even experienced it...people boarding without tickets and I am...
techenclave.com
How was your visits to beaches, if you had such.
Ssreek
Guide
The smell issues and cleanness issues are everywhere in trains, no matter if it is travelling to north or south, but it's little bit horrible in north related trains. Staff does clean every now and then but situation becomes terrible during mornings when everyone is busy going to the washrooms or brushing their teeth wandering all over the coaches.
Regarding random people occupying seats without relevant tickets, seems very common in north.
I've boarded few times in 2nd ac or 3rd ac coaches, there were always these people who will either enter with general tickets or without no tickets at all and simply occupy our seats. There was a day when I complained to the tc, he told them like 'just don't bother people with tickets' and left. Then the guy sitting beside me (whole berth was mine), moved to a different seat saying, 'no problem bhayya you can sleep'. I sarcastically thanked him for his sacrifice.
Thanks....
Yes. I feel so lucky but at same time sorry to see such a disaster.Actually was waiting for update on this thread, I remembered commenting here about troubles traveling in rainy season to Kerala.
It was a sad tragedy, extremely draining for locals in that region.Indian Railways Train Journey Discussion.
Hello Guys, I have a trek coming in Kerala Next month. I'm travelling by train . I have experienced North Indian Railway Train journeys many time and it is horrible 60% of the time. I'm sure many of us have seen recent videos and even experienced it...people boarding without tickets and I am...
Very major hill stations or tourist spots are awaiting disaster tbh and ticking time bomb with no proper planning and rampant corruption in allowing construction of Hotels etc.
Here in Himachal too we are usually very scared during Monsoons and pray that it is limited. Even the Villages are only increasing their floors.
will go bit ott-
The trip was amazing otherwise. Beach were amazing, Backwaters lovely . Did some kayaking too in beautiful backwaters. What an experience!
This is my first time in my life in South India and I'm amazed of the culture and food and beauty of the place and people too.
Kerala has been bit of eye opener. So many Churches, Mosques and Temples very close to each other and still being so calm. However, I found there was like some competition going on to see which religion has most temple. Mosque and church. Because they were too many on every nook and corner still happy to see the harmony.
Food is so rich with clear Arab influence in Keralean Food beside its own rich traditional local food.
People were mostly cool too. Did had some language issues but nothing major to be complaining off. My only wish was atleast bus and all could have english names mentioned too. It really helps tourist specially when your place/town is a touristy town . then why make things so difficult for others to move around without taking help from local people.
Anyways amazing place. I will go again next year .
will share some pics on the camera thread later.
That is because you probably started travel primarily from northern regions of Kerala which made an impression.
The moment you reach towards central to southern regions culture changes subtly. Oblivious to outsiders, even though its a very small state, local culture and dialects etc. changes if you travel few dozen kilometers.
You might've seen pvt. bus boards in Hindi in Kochi area, etc., generally lot of north Indian workers there.
In northern India, there are lot of misunderstanding about Kerala due to political propaganda, once they visit the place their view changes a lot. Have seen my friends who visit occasionally totally having drastically changed perspectives about the state after their visits.
Backwaters are generally in southern side of Kerala, so traveled a bit, good to know that.
As for trains, good to know you had better experience, but locals are suffering a lot these days, from today's news (people are fainting and collapsing in trains, translated using google transalte):
കാലു കുത്താന് ഇടമില്ല, കുഴഞ്ഞുവീഴുന്നത് പതിവ് കാഴ്ച; പേടി സ്വപ്നം ഈ യാത്ര
പാലരുവി എക്സ്പ്രസിലെ ദുരിതയാത്രയെക്കുറിച്ച് വനിതകള്ക്കും പറയാനുണ്ട്. ലേഡീസ് കോച്ചുകള് വളരെ ചെറുതായതിനാല് ശ്വാസംമുട്ടിയാണ് യാത്ര. വലിയ ലേഡീസ്.palaruvi express, journey, ladies, ladies coach, train, railway
Another horrible experience with Indian railways to share.
Need to head to Kolkata from Delhi.
There were several special trains going from Delhi to Patna and I was planning to change from there.
They cancelled few and mine didn't get cancelled( which I do feel lucky about) but got rescheduled and so my other change of train ticket has to cancelled.
They mention about reschedule at 8 am for 1pm train.
Is 5 hours enough for people travelling from 500 -600km to the railway station (had to leave a day before.)
Forget about me...I saw people whose train were cancelled trying to catch other trains in rush.
Why the F*** take the booking if you going to cancel 2 special trains back to back.
Why put so much people in stress...there are people who travelled with senior citizens and kids too.
God bless sardarji's who came to station with langar food to help many stranded people.
The people running railways in India are doing absolutely pathetic job.
I feel like doing A Wednesday movie like thing on these people.
Need to head to Kolkata from Delhi.
There were several special trains going from Delhi to Patna and I was planning to change from there.
They cancelled few and mine didn't get cancelled( which I do feel lucky about) but got rescheduled and so my other change of train ticket has to cancelled.
They mention about reschedule at 8 am for 1pm train.
Is 5 hours enough for people travelling from 500 -600km to the railway station (had to leave a day before.)
Forget about me...I saw people whose train were cancelled trying to catch other trains in rush.
Why the F*** take the booking if you going to cancel 2 special trains back to back.
Why put so much people in stress...there are people who travelled with senior citizens and kids too.
God bless sardarji's who came to station with langar food to help many stranded people.
The people running railways in India are doing absolutely pathetic job.
I feel like doing A Wednesday movie like thing on these people.
Last edited:
nRiTeCh
Northstar
Thats the usual SPL IR train behavior on most routes...
I have traveled by such trains esp. labelled as SPL Duranto and after a few 100 kms at some point such trains are parked in an unknown Farcry type deserted zone on an abandoned track for a good 3-4hrs only to let pass-by some 30 trains incl. goods and local passenger trains only to restart the journey where the schedule goes for a toss! Train arrives late by 5-6 hrs to the destination..
Last edited:
Delay is one thing ( not acceptable but still )but cancelling them totally is just not right for people who got the bookings done.
Why take the bookings only to cancel it later.
nRiTeCh
Northstar
Because SPL trains schedule is an adjusted schedules sandwiched and forced between already cluttered schedule of regularly running trains.
If few of these regular trains get delayed then there's no schedule left for these SPL trains and hence the cancellation!
exactly.
These special trains booking were announced one month before to deal with festival rush.
They already know the schedule and still rescheduling is still understandable but completely cancelling it for almost 1000 people stranded on each train.
Almost two thousand people ...
Labour people with wife and childrens , senior citizens travelling.
It is their job to give them alternative.
Then what is the use of special trains if they cannot manage that too just for a month also.
My point is if you doing something do it properly otherwise don't do it.
Same with Tatkal issue too.
Atleast people will know where they stand.
Har jega half hearted attempt.