Guide The Hunt for the BEST Controller (Hall Effect)

bssunilreddy

Luminary

The Hunt for the BEST Controller (Hall Effect)​


This is the ULTIMATE showdown of game controllers that we missed in our last video; we’ve got over 20 remotes and we’re trying to find which is THE BEST! What has the lowest input latency? Which has key features like Hall Effect Sticks and Triggers? Which feels comfiest? Which is the best for the budget? We’re covering it all, and including a handy tier list.


9chUB6T.png


PNXfuu0.png
 
Last edited:
This doesn't seem to be a particularly exhaustive list of popular options. Also Hall Effect sticks are being replaced by TMR which addresses some of its shortcomings. Not going to watch the video but don't see options like the Vader 4 Pro and Cyclone 2 on the list that are regularly recommended.
 
I use the Gamesir Tarantula and its a pretty good controller. Comes with the PlayStation layout. One gripe I do have is that the trigger buttons don't have a lot of feel and this is especially pronounced in racing games.
 
This doesn't seem to be a particularly exhaustive list of popular options. Also Hall Effect sticks are being replaced by TMR which addresses some of its shortcomings. Not going to watch the video but don't see options like the Vader 4 Pro and Cyclone 2 on the list that are regularly recommended.
The Cyclone 2, seems to be way better and similar to the price of the G7 SE. But is it XBox certified/compatible and all?
 
Then the G7 SE would be better choice as I want to play some Minecraft with it on a M1 Air. I think X-Input controllers are supported on macOS now.

If you don't need to use the controller with an actual Xbox console, you might not need to get a licensed controller (although licensed controllers might include some extra features like impulse triggers that are supported in select titles even on PC).

Virtually all current PC controllers including the Cyclone 2 would support XInput on Windows (I don't know about Mac support).
 
Well they don't mention macOS but it's possible it might work in XBox mode, theoretically.
It works with mac os connected using type c to type c cable, usb dongle. And android tv and PC when connected with dongle no bluetooth. Controller is light weight , left and right sticks have good precision for direction, triggers are ok not pressure sensitive. Used with retrobat, not completely lag free. Overall good for casual gaming .
 
Been using Cosmic Byte Stellaris for some time. Best part is that it can be connected to PC, Android phone, iOS/macOS/tVOS device, windows, Nintendo devices (flick of switch at the back). Great buttons and sticks but range is a big minus. It has to be in line of sight with the dongle and BT is scratchy. Works much better with Apple TV in living room and I have no idea why. With PC, I cannot even go half the distance.