The Pod vs Zune thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Keane 16

Contributor
Which one do you think is gonna rule the roost ?
I've decided to wait for the Zune .. but I can put *dloaded* music on it right ?
How big is the Zune as compared to the 30gig pod ? Weight ? Video formats playable ? Actual memory available ?
 
U can also go through a hands on here(copy pasted below for convenience....)
All Zune colors were present, brown, white (or off-white) and black. The brown design was by far my favorite color of the three.

I had expected the player to be fairly heavy, but after holding the Zune in my hand it was clear that I was wrong. It is not as light as the latest video iPod, but compared to my fourth-generation iPod, the Zune was lighter. The top of the Zune had a clear glass layer while the exterior had a tactile feel to it, nothing like the hard metal and plastic of the iPod devices. The ‘skin’ of the Zune was a ‘rubberized’ material that had a smooth seductive feel to it. I found myself unable to stop stroking the device, so much that the demo assistant asked me to put it down
Click to expand...

User Interface
Laughing off the uncomfortable silence, I focused on the player and the user interface (UI). The interface is amazingly responsive to my actions. The "home" screen had a user-configurable background for all the major sections of the device such as music, video, radio, community and settings. Click on any one of these major sections and the background zooms in a bit, giving you a feeling of probing deeper into the device. Within a section, categories are listed at the top of the device such as artists, songs, play lists and genres.

Clicking on artists causes a list of albums to display on the top of the interface. Clicking on an album will then display a list of songs and the top of the UI will list the band’s albums. Anytime you want to go back, just click on the back button. The album art is large, filling the whole display. The current position of the song is displayed by a white dot with an aura on a white line.
Click to expand...

Video Playback
Video on the device was bright and fluid. I watched several music videos with no dropped frames or stutters. The radio interface is large and easy to tune and read. I didn’t look at the photo capabilities, myself, but looked over the shoulder of the guy next to me and the slideshow capability looked fluid.
Click to expand...

Music Sharing
Clicking on the "community" button allowed me to see the other two Zunes nearby. I decided to send them my community member a song. Browsed to my music folder, found to a song and, instead of selecting to play it, I chose to send it. Prompted with a list of Zune’s nearby, I chose one and sent it. Watching the other Zune, the user was prompted to download and accepted the request. It took less than 20 seconds to send the whole song which included album art. The other user sent me a folder of pictures with, roughly, a one-second per picture transfer rate.

Upon a successful transfer, the music is wrapped with a digital rights management (DRM) layer which will give the user a three day or three-listen license. I don’t know about many of our readers, but I can listen to a song over and over again. Three plays... please! Beyond that limitation, I asked the demo assistant if there was any means I could get a copy of the songs from my "community" Zunes to help me find new artists to listen to. He said there was no way to do this on a Zune, but you could send whole playlists to other Zunes and check out the artist list that way. I thought that was very nice.
Click to expand...
Zune Setup
Upon initial setup, you will give yourself a "ZuneTag," simiar to a Gamertag on the Xbox Live service. This ZuneTag is based on the Microsoft Passport service so, if your Xbox Live Gamertag is associated with Passport, then it will become your ZuneTag. I asked what would happen if someone wanted to be known as my gamertag before I could purchase my Zune. "No Problem, we reserve the ZuneTag for you if your Gamertag is associated with Microsoft Passport."

As a side note, your Microsoft points you use on Xbox Live Marketplace will be available to buy songs from the Zune music service. Talk about convenience.
Click to expand...
Zune Software
Microsoft has also created new software to manage your media and access the Zune music service. No fear for those Windows Media Player fans, they can be installed side-by-side. An interesting feature of the new Zune software is the "Journal" tab that kept up with the songs you downloaded from other players as well as the music you played recently. This should be a helpful feature since I only get three plays for the shared songs and that will last me all of 15 minutes (I have a memory of a goldfish.)

Another great feature of this software is it's ability to access the Xbox 360 music interface. You'll be able to play songs you've purchased or may already be on your computer as well as play video so you'll no longer need to have Windows Media Connect on your PC.
Click to expand...

Overall

All in all, any reservations I had about the device melted away after I had a few moments with the Zune. Yes, it is a first-generation product but I really like the direction Microsoft is taking with the Zune. Regardless of either the Zune or the iPod, the consumer will be the winner of this new front in the battle for our entertainment lifestyle. Though I really enjoy the few moments today with the Zune, I secretly look forward to Apples response. Hopefully it will be better than dealing "massive damage to the giant enemy crab’s weak point." d’oh!

No we don't work for Microsoft and I'm pretty sure they have no idea who 2old2play is. If they did, Im dont think they would use our site to talk about the Zune, do you?
Click to expand...
 
They showed the New Ipod 80 GB on CNBC TV18 which is available for around 16.5K in the grey market (according to them).It now has the search feature for alphabetical search on artists/albums etc.
 
Zune anyday.Scratch-pods suck big time with its small screen and crappy video playback.Zune is so much better. ideallly you should decide between a creative zen vision m and zune. If you want divx playback then go for creative else get zune.

just take a look at this video:-

Zune complete interface walkthrough video - Engadget

Also check out this link:-

http://www.techenclave.com/forums/which-portable-mp3-player-creative-vs-81354.html

I still don't understand why people go for apple.The only reason to go for apple is gapless playback and support for audio books from audible.com.Apple nono is okay but video pods!!!!

Zune has better audio quality,better usablity and has the right amount of weight and unlike the ipods is scratch resistant.Zune has much better build quality It's the best mp3 hardware out there.The defects it has is in the software department where it only supports wmv vdieo format so you would have to convert everthing to mpeg 4 format and then let the zune software convert it to WMV.

Man ! i am sick and tired of defending zune in every thread.
 
But the zune is bulkier and heavier than the Ipod, and frankly the video quality in all PMPs is almost similar.
 
Don't bother about the so called extra wieght and size.It has the exact weight and size that makes it really confortable and pleasant to hold.

And plz don't tell that the videos in all mp3 players look the same.:bleh: :bleh: Ipod videos appear washed out compared to zen vision.Even zune video appear somewhat washed out but it nowhere as bad as ipod.To enjoy videos you need at least 3-4 inch.screens.And that's why zune offers the best video viewing experience.

If you have to choose between zune and ipod, choose a zune because zune is better than the ipod in every feature except maybe looks.

But remember zune only plays wmv files, if you want more format support check out zen vision.
 
So the Zune has a bigger screen too ? And battery life ? (Both video and mp3) ? And what's with all the DRM shite ? I can put my **downloaded** MP3s & videos on it without and issues na ?
 
Would the Zune fit in my jeans' pockets ? Or is it too big ?

As compared to the 30 gig pod, how big is the Zune ? And also the ZVM ?

And the WiFi on the zune could in the future be used to connect wirelessly with the comp right ? When they come up with Zun(lin)ux or whatever :S ...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom