Forum Feedback Why Have This Mandatory In the Market Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Amarbir

Inactive
Explorer
hi ,
I Could under stand that its mandatory to have your product photo ,But whats The Point of the folowing

1 :Writing your Name On Paper Along with Your TE Username and Clicking Photo
2 :Writing The Date On Paper Along with the TE Name And Clicking Photo

A Better thing would Be Coding the Product with the TE Name and Date Current Walli Using a Marker ......

:@
 
well if you code the product then it cannot be removed right ...i wont like that in any product i buy ...also the photo is to show that you have the product in your hands
 
kippu said:
well if you code the product then it cannot be removed right ...i wont like that in any product i buy ...also the photo is to show that you have the product in your hands
Click to expand...
Hi ,
It could Be Removed Simply with ISO or CTC solution ,And the Member Could Show What He Has and The Reciever Should Also Should What He recieved .Also Writing the Date On The Same Is for what .................
 
oh dear!!!.

You didnt read all those feedback threads did you :P

I am not gonna post it all again here. there are 3-4 threads in feedback regarding this. Go through them. And the rules are not becoz someone will steal these images. its there to prove you actually have the product in possession. A small practice commonly observed on most online forums to reduce frauds or misunderstanding between buyer and seller.
 
the date :: i am assuming you have not seen the kidnapping movies ..you are photographed next to a newspaper showing the date :P...lucky here its only writing a date
 
Whats the big deal, a photo is mandatory anyway, writing your name and date on a paper alongside shouldn't be too hard . Its actually quite a fool proof way of verifying the product .....I'm all for it :)
 
Anish said:
Yeah right! Try some of that solution on plastic or a card box box and see what happens!
Click to expand...

Anish ,
I Know What Will Happen With CTC ,It Will Mass The Plastic And Even Desolve It ,But If You Code The PCB Part It Could Easily Remove The Marker sign .
Funky said:
oh dear!!!.
You didnt read all those feedback threads did you :P
I am not gonna post it all again here. there are 3-4 threads in feedback regarding this. Go through them. And the rules are not becoz someone will steal these images. its there to prove you actually have the product in possession. A small practice commonly observed on most online forums to reduce frauds or misunderstanding between buyer and seller.
Click to expand...

Funky ,
I Was Asking Something Totally different Now ,What the Idea To Have The Date On That PIC ,Infact Next Time I Am Going to stand By The Product and Tell Someone To Click My And The Products Photo also Like This No Need To Write The Name On Paper Also ,10000000000000% solid Proof .

:ohyeah:

shrey said:
Whats the big deal, a photo is mandatory anyway, writing your name and date on a paper alongside shouldn't be too hard . Its actually quite a fool proof way of verifying the product .....I'm all for it :)
Click to expand...

Boss ,
I Explained It Right Above what and why I Am Saying Specifically About The Date .

PS :Does Anyone ever Take a suggestion From The Mods In TE,Please Post Me One Thread In Which They Have Done so,I am Dying To See That .Also Do Not Take this in a Sarcastic Way .this Is What a Close Knitted Community is All About right .I Would Be Away For 2 ~3 Days From My Hometown And Would See This Possible When i come Back .
 
Please dont double post this has been discussed many times as funky said..

Dont understand y this thread hasnt been locked yet..
wee've been here and done this discussion..
 
Amarbir[Chandigarh] said:
Boss ,

I Explained It Right Above what and why I Am Saying Specifically About The Date .
Click to expand...

Date fool proof's it that you actually have the product with you in reality at this certain date... Without a date it would be impossible to be certain that you have the product when its listed at TE for a sale....

Its not that hard to understand & really easy to do so....

With the marker & solution to remove the code... well nobody will go out looking for such troubled approach to get the marker out from their product...Its not practical, economical or time worthy ie.

So nothing wrong to have a simple solution which every user can adhere to...

Hope you understand....
 
racy1 said:
Date fool proof's it that you actually have the product with you in reality at this certain date... Without a date it would be impossible to be certain that you have the product when its listed at TE for a sale....

Its not that hard to understand & really easy to do so....

With the marker & solution to remove the code... well nobody will go out looking for such troubled approach to get the marker out from their product...Its not practical, economical or time worthy ie.

So nothing wrong to have a simple solution which every user can adhere to...

Hope you understand....
Click to expand...

Hi ,
If I Have a Product And i Click a Photo of That And Also Write My Name On The Paper As They suggest And Post ,Its,nt the Post Date Enough For The Thing You Said .
Party Monger said:
Please dont double post this has been discussed many times as funky said..

Dont understand y this thread hasnt been locked yet..
wee've been here and done this discussion..
Click to expand...

Boss ,
Please Forward Me The Links So That I Could Read ,And Sorry atleast i did Not Post This useless Discussion in The Feedback righto Boss .:P
 
Amarbir[Chandigarh] said:
Boss ,
Please Forward Me The Links So That I Could Read
Click to expand...
Discussed Here
--> http://www.techenclave.com/feedback-corner/pictures-in-market-111198.html
--->http://www.techenclave.com/feedback...mbers-wrongfully-spamming-threads-111252.html
Hope you wouldnt need any more spoon feeding..
Amarbir[Chandigarh] said:
And Sorry atleast i did Not Post This useless Discussion in The Feedback righto Boss .:P
Click to expand...
Oh great sonny..You want a candy??
Amarbir[Chandigarh] said:
If I Have a Product And i Click a Photo of That And Also Write My Name On The Paper As They suggest And Post ,Its,nt the Post Date Enough For The Thing You Said .
Click to expand...
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
The date is to verify that you are in possession of the trade item and NOT for remembering the date of posting the sale...duh..
 
Ok, in short about the logic behind the username and the date.

Username is to prove that you have the product with you in your posession. I am sure you agree to it coz you donot have an issue with the pic with the username on it.
Next, the date, the purpose it serves is to provide a means to show that you were in posession of the product in that perticular condition on the mentioned date. I could post a pic which is one year old with my username next to it. How can someone tell the difference??

PS: Does Anyone ever Take a suggestion From The Mods In TE,Please Post Me One Thread In Which They Have Done so,I am Dying To See That .Also Do Not Take this in a Sarcastic Way .this Is What a Close Knitted Community is All About right .I Would Be Away For 2 ~3 Days From My Hometown And Would See This Possible When i come Back .
Click to expand...
I didnt get what you wanted to convey with that message. Please correct me if I am wrong but heres what I understood from the above:
You wish to ask if anyone here does take suggestions given by the mods? And wish to have a link to a thread where someone has actually listened to the mods?
But just as a small side note, if one is taking the effort to take a photograph with their usernames handwritten next to the product, I really donot see how writing a date can pose a problem. How much time does it take? 15 seconds or maybe 5 mins if you are really slow with writing? :P
Seriously speaking, we decided the rules after giving it much thought and discussion. I personally, donot see a reason why anyone should have an objection to it. Its a practical and a very feasible solution that has been proposed. And there are times, when things are done for the overall good. Explaining the exact thought that went behind the same isnt possible to everyone who comes up with a question. Its a matter of perception. However, one doesnt always question why a certain rule was made the way it is right? If everyone trusts us with maintaining this place, I donot see why anyone should doubt us making rules which would in the end make things harmful to others.

Sorry if this post hurt the feelings of anyone. Its not meant to be that way :)
 
Amarbir[Chandigarh] said:
Hi ,

If I Have a Product And i Click a Photo of That And Also Write My Name On The Paper As They suggest And Post ,Its,nt the Post Date Enough For The Thing You Said .
Click to expand...

This is basically to confirm that the seller actually has the posted item with him. Its to prevent selling of hardware that may have already been sold, or was with the seller at a previous point of time (but not currently). It can also be used to prevent a scammer from attempting to use the same product multiple times (say, on different forums) to dupe unsuspecting buyers.

Ofcourse, there are easy ways to get around this with a little forethought by a scammer; but since it involves so little work on the part of a real seller, it is an accepted practice in forum markets.

Edit: one way to take care of the vulnerability of the current system is, in fact, the newspaper thing mentioned above. but since having a copy of the day's newspaper isnt the norm any more, it would pose a problem. Maybe a website which generates a random string everyday which is archived. and then you write down the string on a piece of paper and photograph it with the product...
 
Friends ,

Can i answer and question After 2 Days ,Some things Still Popping In My Mind ,As i Am convinced That i Could Not Communicate What i WAnted To Ask Clearly ,Like Our Friend Party Monger Trying His Level Best To Explain .....

PS :I will Ask My Question After 2 Days ,
 
Lol.. No one is explaining the real logic behind writing dates..If there is a scammer selling a product, why not lie about the date as well?? Is there something to prevent me from writing a future date?? Why would anyone want to sell something which isn't in his possession at the time of the post?

As Grease Monk said, Newspaper would do justice for the date problem.. thats the only way to confirm the date. it is not a question of how much time it takes to write the date, its the necessity of writing it..

How about writing that day's news headline :P
 
sri_rng said:
How about writing that day's news headline :P
Click to expand...
unfortunately, the issue with that is we're assuming everyone gets the same newspaper. they all dont have the same headline on the same day.
 
everyone who asks this question miss the entire point. Nothing is bullet proof. And we are not trying to make it too hard for the members. These are just simple things. Whats your problem with hand writing a date on piece of paper? Tell me that. And this is not the perfect world. Once in a while a scammer pops up every where. And thats why even these simple rules are there in place.

These simple things do work. Its time proven methodology. We didnt invent it but we have adopted it. A person trying to pull scam will have to do that much more and that puts off 90% scammers out there.
 
Amarbir[Chandigarh] said:
Anish ,

Boss ,
I Explained It Right Above what and why I Am Saying Specifically About The Date .

PS :Does Anyone ever Take a suggestion From The Mods In TE,Please Post Me One Thread In Which They Have Done so,I am Dying To See That .Also Do Not Take this in a Sarcastic Way .this Is What a Close Knitted Community is All About right .I Would Be Away For 2 ~3 Days From My Hometown And Would See This Possible When i come Back .
Click to expand...

Had you believed it to be a close knitted community...
You wouldnt have been waiting for the payment to reach your account to despatch the material..... :P
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom