I have the hardware and have been using Vista for 3-4 months now
After the initial charm wore off, I think I prefer XP ...
If I wasn't so lazy, I'd have reverted back to XP
i think it all depends.
if you have the matching hardware, then its really good experience. even then, if you compare, on same hardware, xp will definitely give better performance and stability.
Coming to think of it, the moment I upgraded from ME to XP, there was no turning back, even on hardware that barely ran XP (a P-III 550 with 192 MB of RAM)
I turned off the graphical effects of XP just to keep that running, it was that good an upgrade....
With Vista, its a love-hate story (actually more hate)
Disclaimer: All my machines running Vista are a lot better than MSFTs recommended configuration for Vista
Love
- The spotlight clone feature (real time search): Though nowhere as good as Spotlight, the Vista Search is infinitely better than XP search
However, I hear that Google desktop on XP is also fairly neat
- The somewhat improved battery life on my laptop which went up frm arnd 3 hrs on XP to 3:30 on Vista with aggressive power saving settings
Hate
- The much annoying constant disk thrashing
- Lack of drivers for some hardware(should improve with time)
- some programs/applets are painfully slow (like Network and sharing center)
The most annoying thing abt Vista though is this...
There are times when Vista will be inexplicably cranky and behave weirdly
Things which would have worked fine the last time will sometimes refuse to work-randomly
and this can get very annoying when it happens
It's hard to explain but I'll just give you a few examples
- Stuck copy paste operations 1 in 10 times (esp while copying over network)
LOL...this will typically happen when I am in a hurry and just need to grab a few ..files on my lappy from the b**ch rig and run out
- Cranky hibernation which takes Vista almost as long to resume from hibernate than a restart (not always, but sometimes)
-DHCP troubles on every nth resume (n=5-10)
And so and and so forth....
XP felt much more user friendly and almost as stable as a mainstream Linux distri like Mandrake
Vista feels maybe a little more user friendly (?) but the crankiness is a big killjoy