Graphic Cards Denial of RMA by NVIDIA/RPTECH and MSI for PCI Express Slot and PCI Express Pad burn

rsaeon · Sep 24, 2024

r2d3 said:
someone please clarify .. afaik, only 75 watts goes through motherboard PCIe slot and GPU can only pull 75w from motherboard PCIe slot ( otherwise every time someone forgets to plug PCIe 8pin/6pin cables to the GPU, there would be a burnt card and a burnt motherboard ) .. how can GPU try to pull more power from PCIe and get burnt?

sstiwari said:
for the usual weekend gaming ritual, I powered on my PC after 5 days

Failure occurred during a cold start 5 days after last power-on, it could be anything.

It was during summer, so no condensation due to rains unless if there was both a humidifier and AC in the room.

It's possible it's premature failure of some component that happened during cool down after the last power-on. Most systems with this kind of hardware aren't powered off for such long time periods so I haven't been able to find much information on social media.

Some animal or insect could've decided to make itself at home or leave gifts behind. A random relative could've knocked over the tower and put it back without saying anything. A pet could've jumped on or off of it causing it to rock and unseat the card slightly.

Without a timelapse recording of the entire 5 day period, it could be anything. I have TAPO cameras pointed at everything that's worth 5 digits or more. I set that up because we have more cats than humans here and all windows and doors are locked down but one or two still manage to find a way in to snoop around and leave paw prints behind.

If this card has international warranty, then sending it to the US looks like the best option since it might take months or years to resolve legally here.

?dOuBtFiRe? · Sep 24, 2024

Corsair's Support is legendary in a good manner and MSI Support is legendary in a bad manner. As expected.
Pray that this gets resolved in a humanely manner. The way this goes, trust is lost on all parties involved.
However the real question is what caused this to happen at first. I think its the bane of the 4000 series.
I am guessing it will get buried first.

sstiwari · Sep 24, 2024

nRiTeCh said:
@sstiwari Share the gpu and also the mobo pcie burnt pics to get an better insight.

Added some more snaps of the card and mobo.

rsaeon said:
Failure occurred during a cold start 5 days after last power-on, it could be anything.

It was during summer, so no condensation due to rains unless if there was both a humidifier and AC in the room.

It's possible it's premature failure of some component that happened during cool down after the last power-on. Most systems with this kind of hardware aren't powered off for such long time periods so I haven't been able to find much information on social media.

Some animal or insect could've decided to make itself at home or leave gifts behind. A random relative could've knocked over the tower and put it back without saying anything. A pet could've jumped on or off of it causing it to rock and unseat the card slightly.

Without a timelapse recording of the entire 5 day period, it could be anything. I have TAPO cameras pointed at everything that's worth 5 digits or more. I set that up because we have more cats than humans here and all windows and doors are locked down but one or two still manage to find a way in to snoop around and leave paw prints behind.

If this card has international warranty, then sending it to the US looks like the best option since it might take months or years to resolve legally here.

The PCIE Pad/Fingers of the graphics card sit flush into the PCIE Slot of the mother board, there are no exposed PCIE Pins outside the PCIE Slot, and moreover, if you see the pictures closely, you would notice that the PCIE Pins on the card have not melted, they are intact. Surge has come from inside of the card, melting/shorting Copper traces, and Epoxy resin on PCB, that has condensed on the PCIE Pins of the card. Check 1st two Pics in this post.

Even if an insect went on the exposed part of PCIE Pad that is essentially an extension of PCB, the black Epoxy Resin is supposed to provide thermal & electrical insulation to the PCB.

To me the sequence is, some manufacturing defect on the Copper traces supplying +12V power from PCIE side, have resulted in shorting, then overheating, melting the Copper and Epoxy insulation, which has then flown into the PCIE Slot. The PCIE Power Pins/Fingers on the Card are still intact, just a bit of epoxy/Carbon deposit.

And all this happened in like a couple of seconds. This happened in end Mar'24, and frankly I accepted this as my fate. But the energy here is coaxing me to give it another shot.

If someone can help me with email ids of Nvidia Head in India and RPTech Head, I can drop them an email regarding final call for help, and then file a compliant to consumer court.

Emperor · Sep 24, 2024

sstiwari said:
RP Tech guy said, if NVIDIA explicitly writes to us to accept card for RMA, we will accept it. When I mentioned this to Nvidia Level 2, he said, he has no solution.

so it is NVIDIA and not RP Tech who should blame for not replacing product in warranty and no fault of user.
I smell downfall of NVIDIA is near corner..
Intel did same with my Intel Original Motherboard in 2005-2006 year and what I wish at that time came true for Intel in 2024

nRiTeCh · Sep 24, 2024

Emperor said:
Intel did same with my Intel Original Motherboard in 2005-2006 year and what I wish at that time came true for Intel in 2024

+1 the almighty socket 775 era but Intels original mobos were rocksolid not the chipset ones.

Emperor said:
I smell downfall if NVIDIA is near corner..

Not gonna happen.

sstiwari said:
Added some more snaps of the card and mobo.

The PCIE Pad/Fingers of the graphics card sit flush into the PCIE Slot of the mother board, there are no exposed PCIE Pins outside the PCIE Slot, and moreover, if you see the pictures closely, you would notice that the PCIE Pins on the card have not melted, they are intact. Surge has come from inside of the card, melting/shorting Copper traces, and Epoxy resin on PCB, that has condensed on the PCIE Pins of the card. Check 1st two Pics in this post.

Even if an insect went on the exposed part of PCIE Pad that is essentially an extension of PCB, the black Epoxy Resin is supposed to provide thermal & electrical insulation to the PCB.

To me the sequence is, some manufacturing defect on the Copper traces supplying +12V power from PCIE side, have resulted in shorting, then overheating, melting the Copper and Epoxy insulation, which has then flown into the PCIE Slot. The PCIE Power Pins/Fingers on the Card are still intact, just a bit of epoxy/Carbon deposit.

And all this happened in like a couple of seconds. This happened in end Mar'24, and frankly I accepted this as my fate. But the energy here is coaxing me to give it another shot.

If someone can help me with email ids of Nvidia Head in India and RPTech Head, I can drop them an email regarding final call for help, and then file a compliant to consumer court.

You are not alone, to me it looks like a chipset design flaw!

You can google more form 4090 burning issues and slap these on nvidias face.

4090 pcie melt - Google Search

rsaeon · Sep 24, 2024

Most of those are about the PCIe cable, but the first one has the same burn marks — on the edge connector:

The repair disables power draw from the motherboard slot, so there's hope! The card will work, but draw power only from the PSU connector (unless if you do the mod in the second half of the video).

ARAV · Sep 25, 2024

rsaeon said:
Most of those are about the PCIe cable, but the first one has the same burn marks — on the edge connector:

The repair disables power draw from the motherboard slot, so there's hope! The card will work, but draw power only from the PSU connector (unless if you do the mod in the second half of the video).

This looks promising , will try it out with my card too. If i can find it first

cranky · Sep 25, 2024

r2d3 said:
someone please clarify .. afaik, only 75 watts goes through motherboard PCIe slot and GPU can only pull 75w from motherboard PCIe slot ( otherwise every time someone forgets to plug PCIe 8pin/6pin cables to the GPU, there would be a burnt card and a burnt motherboard ) .. how can GPU try to pull more power from PCIe and get burnt?

PCIe slot is rated to 75 watts maximum. In fact there is quite a bit of headroom, each pin is rated for 1.5A continuous and 2.5A peak with an acceptable temperature rise. Same rating is applicable for all slots from PCIe 1x to 16x, only some of the first 18 pins are used for power. We used this to build a 30-channel modular amplifier for a client and we used the PCIe connector (obviously with a different pinout) to supply the power, signal and get the speaker output from a single backplane. There are 5 +12V pins and 7 ground pins in a default x1 slot, at 1.5A each that's about 90 watts from the 12V rail alone. Then there are more 3.3V pins.

The 75W limit is set by PCI-SIG and is not the limit of the connector surface. Motherboard manufaturers only need respect the PCI-SIG spec to pass certification and market their boards. On the GPU side, thigns get complicated. While most cards are limited to run 50-65 watts from the slot, depending on how the rails are wired it is entriely possible that they draw too much current from the rail for an instant. For cards that conflate all their supply rails into a single large rail, this could cause the card to lean harder on the slot power than the incoming +12V power connector. Typically this is rare, as the slot rails are directed specifically to the board logic and some of the minor auxiliary circuitry. It may also be used to power the VRM chips (not the VRM itself, just the chips) and sometimes the front end video encoders.

To the burn, if you had it at power on it's most likely overvoltage - a brief surge that caused the regulation to fail before cutting out the output voltage. Not vetting the build thoroughly after getting a smoke signal, and then proceeding to power on again was the death warrant, if the first power on didn't kill it the second one surely did. This was a hardware failure, it sucks, but what's done is done.

There is an outside chance that the card is OK. It may be just a trace failure along with whatever else vaporised instantly. Motherboard is likely unrecoverable. The depth of repair needed may be just too high, because motherboards tend to bury power layers and if soemthing there opened p you won't be able to get to the layer. GPUs still run most of their power up top and bottom, so even vaprosed tracks can be (mostly, but not always) fixed. There are guys who advertise PCB evel repairs on GPUs. I would hesitate using their services.

anpl · Sep 25, 2024

MSI UNRELIABLE PRODUCT AND WORST CUSTOMER SUPPORT DONT BUY MSI

sstiwari · Sep 25, 2024

cranky said:
PCIe slot is rated to 75 watts maximum. In fact there is quite a bit of headroom, each pin is rated for 1.5A continuous and 2.5A peak with an acceptable temperature rise. Same rating is applicable for all slots from PCIe 1x to 16x, only some of the first 18 pins are used for power. We used this to build a 30-channel modular amplifier for a client and we used the PCIe connector (obviously with a different pinout) to supply the power, signal and get the speaker output from a single backplane. There are 5 +12V pins and 7 ground pins in a default x1 slot, at 1.5A each that's about 90 watts from the 12V rail alone. Then there are more 3.3V pins.

The 75W limit is set by PCI-SIG and is not the limit of the connector surface. Motherboard manufaturers only need respect the PCI-SIG spec to pass certification and market their boards. On the GPU side, thigns get complicated. While most cards are limited to run 50-65 watts from the slot, depending on how the rails are wired it is entriely possible that they draw too much current from the rail for an instant. For cards that conflate all their supply rails into a single large rail, this could cause the card to lean harder on the slot power than the incoming +12V power connector. Typically this is rare, as the slot rails are directed specifically to the board logic and some of the minor auxiliary circuitry. It may also be used to power the VRM chips (not the VRM itself, just the chips) and sometimes the front end video encoders.

To the burn, if you had it at power on it's most likely overvoltage - a brief surge that caused the regulation to fail before cutting out the output voltage. Not vetting the build thoroughly after getting a smoke signal, and then proceeding to power on again was the death warrant, if the first power on didn't kill it the second one surely did. This was a hardware failure, it sucks, but what's done is done.

There is an outside chance that the card is OK. It may be just a trace failure along with whatever else vaporised instantly. Motherboard is likely unrecoverable. The depth of repair needed may be just too high, because motherboards tend to bury power layers and if soemthing there opened p you won't be able to get to the layer. GPUs still run most of their power up top and bottom, so even vaprosed tracks can be (mostly, but not always) fixed. There are guys who advertise PCB evel repairs on GPUs. I would hesitate using their services.

View attachment 209052

Mobo was still booting, with another graphics card in 3rd PCIE slot. I think, just by replacing the PCIE Slot, mobo would have turned fully functional again.

cranky · Sep 26, 2024

It might be. Worth a try. Does the second x16 slot not work? Both of those are connected to the same bus, so if the second slot works you're good.

After looking at your pics in more detail the solutions suggested in #45 and #46 are probably the way to go. It's worth a shot. Given that I also use a MSI x570 board with a 4090 (and is powered on only weekly), this is a new fear unlocked for me as well.

ninjenstein · Sep 26, 2024

enc0dex264 said:
Wow, its time to lawyer up for sure.. these schmucks at RP tech need to be taught a lesson.

This is why i always buy brands whose RMA's are handled by kaizen.. for eg: zotac, corsair etc.

My RMA experiences with Kaizen have been nothing short of excellent.

My local dealers also warned me that the technicians at RPtech who intially investigate the product for RMA's are idiots.. and they try to find every reason to deny warranty.

I can attest to this.

Don't know if it was kaizen, but my customer experience with Corsair was great. I needed long screws to install new fans in my Corsair Carbide 100r case that I had bought over 3 years ago. I had lost the ones that came with it, I so I emailed them to ask where I can buy them. They actually replied, and not just that, they shipped me a set at their own cost! Since that experience, I'm a Corsiar man.

I also own a Zotac GPU. I bought it used, knowing that it was used for mining (remember when GPUs were scarce during the mining craze in 2017-18?). I never had an issue with it so cannot say anything about the RMA experience, but hey that's a good thing.

Graphic Cards Denial of RMA by NVIDIA/RPTECH and MSI for PCI Express Slot and PCI Express Pad burn

rsaeon

?dOuBtFiRe?

sstiwari

Attachments

Emperor

nRiTeCh

rsaeon

ARAV

cranky

anpl

Market Restricted

sstiwari

cranky

ninjenstein

Attachments