Guide A short guide to Sound Card

Status
Not open for further replies.


Introduction


This is my first article and I am not very good at writing articles.

From quite some time I was hunting for a sound card and I hope many

other are in same dilemma about which sound card to go for. This

dilemma leads me to do short research(not that short though :P) and inspired me for writing this article.

The sound card is the element of the computer system that deals with input and output of sound : voice, music, sound system.

It mostly present in three forms:
  • A chip (chipset) integrated into the motherboard
  • Internal card
  • External card.
Each of these corresponds to certain needs.

[BREAK=Introduction Continues....]

Most manufacturers are increasingly integrated its chips into the motherboard. Their power and their capabilities are limited but still

large enough to feed PC speakers as part of a basic use of computers.

If one would opt to take advantage of technology innovated sound (5.1,7.1 or so on) or connect your computer to a stereo is better to opt for an internal card. It offers a choice of connections in a more complete manner and offers better sound quality.

If your computer must be used to compose music, your preference will certainly towards external sound card designed for this purpose. In this case, according to your needs, consider how well your sound card will be connected to the computer. USB is universal practice, but much slower than firewire, essential if you have plans to open heavy.

[BREAK=Do You Need a Sound Card?]

The first thing to do is ask yourself whether you even need a sound card. Many motherboards include

on-board sound. So if you’re only after basic audio support, this could be a suitable, cost-effective

option for you.

Some motherboards even support 5.1(even 7.1) surround sound and a range of optical ports, so you

shouldn’t rule out on-board sound without giving it a decent look. If you’re just a simple computer user

or gamer who doesn’t require super quality sound, going with on-board sound is probably a good choice.

I further try to differentiate users into following categories:

The answer depends on what you are going to be using it for.

Office User

If you are just using your PC for office type applications then the answer is NO.

The sound you have will just be fine even for listening to internet content.

Gamer

If you are using your computer to play games, then surprisingly the answer is possibly NO too.

On board sound cards as they are called now offer great sound at a small price, many supporting 5.1 surround sound and

other neat features.

If you really love games and enjoy its full effects then you probably will want to go that little bit further and get yourself a

decent sound card.

Musical Composer

If you do intend composing or producing music on your PC then you probably will want to go for a good quality sound card

with MIDI support.

Movie Fan

If you want to use you computer to watch DVDs then you want to ensure you sound card can cope with AC3

(better known as Dolby Digital) and DTS to allow the use of 6 speaker surround sound.

[BREAK=Sound Card Components]

In addition to the basic components needed for sound processing, many sound cards include additional hardware

or input/output connections, including:
  • Digital Signal Processor (DSP): Like a graphics processing unit (GPU), a DSP is a specialized microprocessor.

    It takes some of the workload off of the computer's CPU by performing calculations for analog and digital conversion.

    DSPs can process multiple sounds, or channels, simultaneously.

    Sound cards that do not have their own DSP use the CPU for processing.
  • Sampling :This is the frequency in hertz, or kilohertz sampling, ie the number of sample products every second.

    Over this frequency, the higher the quality.
Even high sampling rates, however, cause some reduction

in sound quality. The physical process of moving sound through wires can also cause distortion. Manufacturers use two

measurements to describe this reduction in sound quality:

  • Total Harmonic Distortion (THD), expressed as a percentage
  • Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR), measured in decibels
For both THD and SNR, smaller values

indicate better quality. Some cards also support digital input, allowing people to store digital recordings without converting

them to an analog format.

  • Memory: As with a graphics card, a sound card can use its own memory to provide faster data processing.
  • Input and Output Connections: Most sound cards have, at the very minimum, connections for a microphone and speakers.

    Some include so many input and output connections that they have a breakout box, which often mounts in one of the drive bays,

    to house them. These connections include:
  • Multiple speaker connections for 3-D and surround sound.
  • Sony/Philips Digital Interface (S/PDIF), a file transfer protocol or audio data. It uses either coaxial or optical connections for

    input to and output from the sound card.
  • Musical Instrument Digital Interface (MIDI), used to connect synthesizers or other electronic instruments to their computers.
  • FireWire and USB connections, which connect digital audio or video recorders to the sound card
  • Compatibility standards: Some sound cards allow you to take advantage of its specific technologies.

    These are usually clearly stated by the manufacturer. Some cards can be THX, ie high quality and compatible

    with Dolby technology, allowing you to get a home-cinema.
[BREAK=Getting a Right Sound Card]

Numerous factors affect a sound card's abilities to provide clear, high-quality sound. Things to look out for when selecting sound card:
  • ADC and DAC data capacity, measured in bits
  • Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and total harmonic distortion (THD)
  • Frequency response, or how loudly the card can play sounds at different frequencies
  • Sampling rate
  • Output channels, such as 5.1 or 7.1 surround sound
  • Supported application programming interfaces (APIs)
  • Certifications, including Dolby Master and THX
Anyone investing in a top-of-the-line sound c

ard should also have high-quality speakers. Even the best sound card cannot compensate

for poor speaker quality.

[BREAK=Worthy Mentions]Realtek ALC889
  • Provides DACs with SNR rating of 108dB and ADCs with SNR rating of 104dB
  • 10 DAC channels support 16/20/24-bit PCM format for 7.1 sound playback.
  • DACs and ADCs sample rate support upto 192kHz
  • EAX 1.0 and 2.0 compatible
Creative Labs Audigy 2

Sound Blaster® Audigy™ 2 provides 24-bit ADVANCED HD™ sound output. It delivers astonishing clarity

and audio details that are inaudible on current 16-bit audio solutions bringing your music

M-Audio Revolution 7.1
  • PCI solution for high-quality surround sound up to 7.1
  • 24-bit/192kHz audio playback on up to 8 channels
  • Digital out transmits PCM, AC-3 and DTS (coaxial)
  • DTS output and Dolby Digital 5.1/EX (6.1 DVD) decoding
  • 8 analog line outs (4 stereo 1/8" mini jacks)
Creative X-Fi Series

One of the newest advances in sound card technology is X-Fi, or Xtreme Fidelity, from

SoundBlaster manufacturer Creative. X-Fi features:
  • "Active Modal Architecture," which gives people different sound options for games, leisure

    use or music creation
  • A Digital Signal Processor (DSP) with 51 million transistors
  • Multiple processing engines, each of which performs specific sound operations
  • A 24-bit Crystallizer, which reverses some of the sound quality loss inherent in 16-bit CD recording
Xonar DX

Xonar DX provides solid gaming performance and exceptional sound quality. Manufacturer ASUS has put some feature:
  • Combination of Cirrus Logic CS4398 and CS4362A DACs to feed its analog output ports.
  • Provide SNR rating of 116dB (front), 112dB (center, rear, side)
  • Feature 7.1 analog output channels.
  • Capable of encoding Dolby Digital Live bitstreams in real time.
[BREAK=Last Words]

Hope this guide helps u for selecting a right sound card for your setup. Any comments/suggestions/recommendations,

whatever about good and bads are always welcome. :)

As this guide is first attempt towards writing article for any forum :ashamed:, please bear with me Gurus.
 
nice attempt for a first try. how about adding some pics and your opinions :)

this reads like a textbook :P
 
to watch DVDs then you want to ensure you sound card can cope with AC3 (better known as Dolby Digital) and DTS to allow the use of 6 speaker surround sound.

I don't agree this as we have Software Decoders for AC3/DTS. The decoders in Sound card is only useful if you wish to pass through the AC3/DTS signal thru SPDIF to digital speakers. Any entry level 5.1 card will play AC3/DTS with analog output using AC3Filter.
 
jennifer123 said:
The decoders in Sound card is only useful if you wish to pass through the AC3/DTS signal thru SPDIF to digital speakers.

:S

soundcard with spdif does not need to decode ac3/dts. It just passes it through to an external decoder.
 
soundcard with spdif does not need to decode ac3/dts.

Can you confirm this? Are you using the internal Decoder of your soundcard to play 5.1 Movies with your analog speakers? Can you show us the procedure?

It just passes it through to an external decoder.
If you have an External AC3/DTS Decoder you will have an option in sound card to bypass the internal decoder (Its called Bitstream out).
 
I always wanted to know whether nowdays do we really need an external soundcard

There is no use of investing for an external sound card in the range of 1000-3000. They wont perform well than the recent Realtek HD codec. If you have good set of speakers, you can really enjoy the power of the lossless music using some high end sound cards like X-FI/Xonar/DIGI/Auzentech.

But the low end sound cards may help you sometimes with its own dedicated processors/memory, Hardware Upmix technology, ASIO routings etc. But these things are no more valuable as we have dual/quad processors, Software Upmix technologies like SRS/Neo/ProLogic and ASIO4ALL.
 
jennifer123 said:
I don't agree this as we have Software Decoders for AC3/DTS. The decoders in Sound card is only useful if you wish to pass through the AC3/DTS signal thru SPDIF to digital speakers. Any entry level 5.1 card will play AC3/DTS with analog output using AC3Filter.

AC3(or Dolby Digital) can contains upto 6-channel and DVD supports also upto 5.1 channel output...So ur sound card should support these for optimum reproduction of sound
 
Please correct the typos and factual errors. Read the article from beginning to end, and corroborate each fact with multiple sources, and you will see where the mistakes are - I spotted at least three technical errors, and a few language issues - incomplete sentences and things like that.

As for digital formats, the card can support decoding through hardware or software (drivers). If using the digital connection, the card only needs to support passthrough but this is trivial, as cards from 6 years ago can do this. In this scenario we do not use the card's decoders, the downstream receiver or decoder does it. The more advanced 'consumer' cards support upmixing and encoding through digital outputs, whereas professional cards for music production focus on routing, mixing and software optimisations, as well as conversion quality.

In short, the card's decoders are used only when using analog hookup, and passthrough or encode when the digital output is used. AC3Filter is indeed a software decoder, and can be used to decode/encode DD streams (not DTS, though). The card itself does not need to support DD for this to happen - in fact most integrated chips and a lot of entry-level soundcards depend on the software player to decode the streams for them, and have no hardware support for multichannel sound formats.

I do not understand fancy proprietary terms such as 'bitstream out'. I see a lot of FUD and confusion in the posts below the article as well, a lot of jargon being used without any understanding of the terms. This is usually the result of an incomplete article, so it would be good if you can expand on it after doing a little more research. Focus on practical applications - choosing the right card, hooking it up.

Get a little deeper into the subject - what is analog, what is digital, how a soundcard works (basics), what is multichannel, how is a signal decoded/encoded, what are the formats. This is a very basic piece, and could do with both embellishment and depth. It's a brave attempt nonetheless, but to make it stick it needs more hard work.
 
AC3Filter is indeed a software decoder, and can be used to decode/encode DD streams (not DTS, though).

Are you sure, My AC3Filter decodes DTS streams too!!!

I do not understand fancy proprietary terms such as 'bitstream out'.

'Bitstream out' is nothing but a 'pass through'. Bitstream - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

If I am not a stupid, this Dolby Digital/DTS inbuild decoders are some marketing tricks. Any entry level sound card will support Digital pass through and you can use the Digital speaker's inbuilt decoder to play DD/DTS.

As for as I know, you need DD/DTS Decoder in a sound card if you are using a Digital Speaker without inbuilt decoder. If you have a digital speaker with inbuild decoder, you need Dolby Digital Live or DTS Interactive Encoders in the sound card.

Dolby - What is Dolby Digital Live?

DTS Interactive Technology — Reviews and News from Audioholics

In short, the card's decoders are used only when using analog hookup, and passthrough or encode when the digital output is used.

I get confused. Can you please explain the procedure of using the card's inbuilt DD/Dts decoder for my 5.1 analog speakers?
 
jennifer123 said:
Are you sure, My AC3Filter decodes DTS streams too!!!

Can I see a screenshot? Of it in action?

'Bitstream out' is nothing but a 'pass through'. Bitstream - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Fancy. Bitstream is a generic term for any digital transmission. I will wait for you to post a reference of the correlation between passthrough and 'bitstream out'. Passthrough requires the interrupt handler on the soundcard to recognise the stream and pass it unmanipulated. It is not 'dumb', which a bitstreamer is.

If I am not a stupid, this Dolby Digital/DTS inbuild decoders are some marketing tricks.
The Audigy 2 cards support hardware decoding of DD streams. There are specialised MPEG decoder cards that can also decode DTS and DVD-A streams. It's really not as simple as you think.

Any entry level sound card will support Digital pass through and you can use the Digital speaker's inbuilt decoder to play DD/DTS.
Not always. Very low end chips will not be able to pass a DTS signal at all, as the use of any control on the driver panel will violate the stream and the receiver will not be able to decode it.

As for as I know, you need DD/DTS Decoder in a sound card if you are using a Digital Speaker without inbuilt decoder
You know wrong. I have a detailed addendum below, but if your digital speaker has no decoder it cannot play back multichannel digital at all unless you are connecting it through I2S, which you can't without severe hacking.

If you have a digital speaker with inbuild decoder, you need Dolby Digital Live or DTS Interactive Encoders in the sound card.

Not necessary. A card will passthrough will work, as long as the source material is multichannel. Encoders are only needed if you have content that is not natively embedded in a DD/DTS stream, and you want to do that so the receiving system can play it back in multichannel. The most common example of this is games, which stream directly to discrete analog outputs. A card with (eg) DD Live! (or DTS Interactive) will encode these discrete streams into DD (or DTS) and pass it through the digital output. For movies with DD/DTS tracks, the encoder is not required, just that the card supports pass-through.

I get confused. Can you please explain the procedure of using the card's inbuilt DD/Dts decoder for my 5.1 analog speakers?
First, you need a card that actually is able to decode in hardware - not all do - actually, most don't do this at all. If you are using such a card, you have to use the waveout as the sound output and disable decoding in the player application. This will expose a single bitstream with the DTS padding to the card's hardware decoding. Hardware decoding does not work through the digital output at all, only through analog. This is automatic and requires (AFAIK) no manual intervention, though this can depend on the card's drivers.

You need to understand how this works. DD and DTS are format specs, not the streams themselves. The audio stream is submixed with a code. This code has to be generated (by an encoder, if on the fly) or be present when the data is burned onto the medium (eg DVD). All a decoder does is look at the code and separate the streams into 6 channels. All a passthrough has to do is look at the code and not mangle it, recognising that something downstream will handle it. An incompatible digital output (and this is not uncommon with some ADI chips, for example) will only pass two channels of PCM audio if it cannot recognise the rest of the datastream.

When a decoder (on the card or in the reciever or digital speakers or whatever) receives the correct sequence of codes, it generates three or four (depending on 5.1/7.1) substreams of I2S, which become available on its digital (or analog) outputs. There are chips like the ESS9008 which take a single PCM stream and can render upto 8 channels directly. The padding and demux code for DD and DTS are proprietary and cost money to license, but a licensed chip will have this code embedded (drivers cannot carry this code) and some of them present the output as a single stream with the demux for the DAC (if one DAC is used) in a case like this. If there is no decoder there is no cheese, there has to be at least one (and ideally only one) decoder in the entire chain, and it is usually located just before the final conversion to analog.

There are cards which cannot decode, but can encode. The C-media chips are a good example of this, as are the ADI 1988B/2000B, which support DTS-interactive but have no decoding capabilties, so you still have to have a multichannel licensed copy of a software player or a receiver capable of decoding. Same with Xonar DX, which cannot decode DD in hardware but supports DD Live!, which is a encoding capability.
 
Fine. I agree you all.

to watch DVDs then you want to ensure you sound card can cope with AC3 (better known as Dolby Digital) and DTS to allow the use of 6 speaker surround sound.

I agree this too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.