Alternatives for ET Money, which app do you use for mutual fund or stock investing

Renegade said:
That all of these apps do, have noticed this with ET Money as well. I assume a scam to rip people off their money by allotting funds when the NAV has increased. Pocketing the arbitrage.
Click to expand...
exactly from BSE to all AMC everyone is involved in this
they replied

WhatsApp Image 2024-12-05 at 6.19.06 PM.jpeg


Screenshot 2024-12-05 at 6.17.09 PM.png
 
rsaeon said:
I haven't understood a single thing discussed in this thread. Following and grateful for learning from all of you.
Click to expand...

If you are inferring that the financial talk is going over the head and since I have no idea what your age is, I would recommend you start getting acquainted with finance things. It helps you only and finance is something that you have to take care of your money. No one else will as they will just try to siphon money from you.

I tell my wife to know basics too as my argument is, if anything happens to her, I can still have someone cook for me and kids but if something happens to me, no one will help her with finance and people will try to take advantage and try to get our money. (I know this sounds morbid) .
 
  • Like
Reactions: rsaeon and Simar
raksrules said:
If you are inferring that the financial talk is going over the head and since I have no idea what your age is, I would recommend you start getting acquainted with finance things.
Click to expand...

My financial literacy starts and ends with understanding that I have none. I'm about the same age as you — just without any assets or investments. Have a lot of catching up to do. Spent most of my younger years travelling more than I needed to on a salary that was paid out in cash in countries with no income tax. I didn't have or need a bank account, until I returned here five years ago. Didn't even have any ID other than passport because I was out of the country at 18. It was a little funny, getting a drivers license here in my late 30s.

My friends circle from then/there are the same, no investments, payday means dining out with the better three-quarter, living in a rental in the same city they were born in.

Friends from my schooling years in India are on a completely different level — they've either bought or are finishing up construction on a second residence (farmhouse). They just stare blankly at me when I mention that I bought a robot vaccum on a two year no-cost emi in the last Amazon sale.

I know that I'm at a disadvantage but I don't think it's insurmountable. A lot of what is discussed here and in other threads has given me things to look into and learn about.

Grateful, and following.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: cisco_tech, Kevin Lane, raksrules and 1 other person
Renegade said:
That all of these apps do, have noticed this with ET Money as well. I assume a scam to rip people off their money by allotting funds when the NAV has increased. Pocketing the arbitrage.
Click to expand...
Nothing of that sort. Before calling it as scam, you need to first understand the whole process of it. When you make payment on these aggregator platforms like Groww/etc, the payment first goes escrow account of these platforms and then to BSE Star platform and from there, it goes to the bank account of respective AMCs. Now if the amount is debited from your account at 12:45 PM, that doesnt mean that it has reached to the bank account of the AMC and hence, you were not alloted NAV of the same date.

Further, the mail which you have received clearly mention the same that if you account is debited at one particular time, that doesnt mean that its reached to the AMC's bank account!
This is one of the reason that HNIs and Institutions, who invests Lacs or Crs of Rs and are particular about when they are getting the allotment, directly transfers the funds to the AMC's bank account and get same day NAV.

Hope its clear now !
 
raksrules said:
@rsaeon you can start today.


I think the NSDL one only comes if any transaction has happened in particular month. If none then you don't get CAS for that month.
Click to expand...
I do get for all, even the ones which I haven't touched in years.

Edit: Misread that. It maybe true, haven't tested it actually. I get every month probably because of sip.
 
Last edited:
mani0993 said:
Using the respective broker's Mutual Fund platform.

For tracking the overall Portfolio I use Google Sheets.
Click to expand...
Exact setup and works beautifully. You have total control on how you want to track your investments and tweak anything and eveything as needed.

Yes there is initial setup needed but after that it is just punching monthly changes to invested value / units and sheet takes care of eveything else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mani0993
Can anybody using MFCentral ans below Q:

1) Do they allot same day NAV if payment is done through netbanking before cutoff, say 1 pm ?

2) 'XYZ' has single holder folio/account with them, how to create another folio/account 'XYZ + ABC' (Joint holders) to invest in a new, previously never invested AMC ?

MFU says you can create as per (2), but could not find such option on MFC.
 
Top Bottom