dOm1naTOr said:
A VX450 is more than enough to power even a power hungry card like HD 4890/HD 5870 as long as its a single GPU card.
Please read the entire thread sir.
Mephistopheles said:
You don't get it, do you?
I said it can handle, I do not recommend it. Ever heard of "Minimum requirements" and "Recommended requirements"? And anyways as Aces said that a person who will buy a 20k+ GPU will have a budget higher than 4k for the PSU.
Stop hiding behind OP or Aces, please speak for yourself
Did the OP ever say that he had a 5870 and needed suggestions regarding what PSU he should buy? You were the first one who brought up the 5870 here, very confidently running on a VX450 at that
His question was whether or not VX450 had enough in it to power a GPU which required two 6-pin PCI-E connector and as I myself have experience of running a 5850 on it (which required two of these) I wrote he shouldn't have any problem.
--- Updated Post - Automerged ---
OMG!
My apologies sir, sorry for having argued with you. It was my arrogance that I was not able to acknowledge my very apparent mistake
Anything below a VX550 for HD5770 is serious stupidity and the one who doesn't understand this will repent later when his GPU or motherboard gets fried
there is no direct correlation between any product and PSU, depends on full config- we cannot generalise.
All that had to be said has been said in the earlier posts, whether it was from me or you.
Read the entire thread and any links when you are calmer and thinking a bit more clearly.
You started off with confident statements and later seem to be beating a hasty retreat.
To state why one may find your defence weak, esp the 5870 part, "OP asked xyz, so i said ABC", etc- i can give a few examples.
eg. 1>
One guy asks on forums if consuming poison will kill them.
One smart guy says- NO, it won't. I know someone who tried committing suicide once and consumed poison but didn't die.
OP has poison and dies.
People accuse the smartie.
Smartie says- i said he/i consumed and didn't die. I never said OP should consume poison.
eg.2> Someone may stand in the middle of a busy street every day of their life, despite seeing the warning signs and never get run over by any vehicle.
That doesn't mean someone else will be as lucky or the knowledgeable/smart/sensible person will suggest others ignore the warning signs and do the same.
The only thing i would add here and might not have mentioned previously is-
Say one is running an E8400 rig and is buying 5770 and asks for psu.
Everyone says buy VX450 and they are not wrong (just about adequate for now imho).
But do we buy good quality PSU with "5" years warranty to have to upgrade it year or 2 down the line"
Year or 2 down the line, we mostly have some quad or X6 or x58 setup.
By that time, anyone who affords a good card now will upgrade to a good card of that time.
And then the VX450 might not enough even though there's quite some warranty left.
Would it seem feasible to sell the psu and buy something new then.
Or rather spend a bit more now and make it last longer?
These are just some thoughts i present and it's for the reader to decide.
I am not shoving them down someone's throat.
Keeping a slight headroom or thinking slightly into the future is not an unwise thing imho.
All-in-all, i had great fun in participating in this discussion.
I guess the apparently wrong or absolutely wrong claims, doubts and mostly both sides have clarified their stand.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion and the right to make a decision.
I simply prefer being safe than sorry.
We gain or lose, as per our own intellect/understanding and can't blame anyone else for our wrong decisions.
All the best to everyone.