Maybe I need to give the OG movies a rewatch, it's been a long time. Clone Wars was great, getting to see more of Maul was a highlight and CW also turned me into a big fan of Ahsoka. Too bad I had very high expectations for the Ahsoka series, looking forward to S2 though.yeah subjective obviously.
I watched it again after rewatching Andor S1 and then new season, and again felt the same.
Its ok movie for me, much worse than something like Andor and much better than force awakens which did not even feel like sw and was just copy pasting shit in a horrible way.
So it was a relief to watch R1 back when i first watched it but i see it more as a one time watch for me. It just seems so similar to so many other action movies with things jumping around, but in a reasonably well done star wars setting. I prefer original 3, clone wars and even the 2000 prequels to R1/solo movie ( maybe 1 and esp 2 were okayish with lots of issues but 1 had maul and one of the best fights in the series )
Clone wars expanded well on the 3 movies.
I also like jar jar binks, dont care if everyone hates him.
R1 coming after the disappointing TFA and being way way better than rest of the Skywalker saga that followed just makes it standout, until Andor came along. Andor 1, 2 and R1 make for a nice, even independent, trilogy.