Film Scanner recommendation needed

Simar

Enclave Plus
Discoverer
I had hundreds of physical prints of images going back 20-30 years ago and some much older, that were affected by moisture and were ruined. I still have negatives for a lot of these images and am looking for a film scanner that one of you might have had the experience of using. I found a well-reviewed one - KODAK Slide N SCAN but it costs 23k and I'm not looking to spend more than 5-6k, or maybe a bit more if it can get me quality results. I just want digital scans as of now, and printing isn't a priority.

Have you guys used any film scanners and could recommend one?
 
Why don't you take a high-res scan with a normal scanner? I'm sure you can scan the whole roll in one go.

Then use some software to turn negatives into positives.
 
The one I used in my office could scan around 6200+ dpi and costed 1L+. I don't remember the name of that device now. These cheap ones don't do more than 1080p or 1200dpi. Flatbed scanners etc can't compare to the real stand alone negative scanners.
 
The one I used in my office could scan around 6200+ dpi and costed 1L+. I don't remember the name of that device now. These cheap ones don't do more than 1080p or 1200dpi. Flatbed scanners etc can't compare to the real stand alone negative scanners.
I don't remember the resolution, but a consumer scanner I had could scan to unholy resolutions which would make the file un-opanable on any app.
 
I don't remember the resolution, but a consumer scanner I had could scan to unholy resolutions which would make the file un-opanable on any app.
Consumer scanners have max 600dpi optical resolution and the extra resolution is through fake interpolation. Prosumer/Pro scanners have a true resolution starting from 600 dpi all the way to max you can afford with lenses, backlight settings etc. If you used a flatbed scanner and a digital camera, you would find out the difference in a few seconds. We tried a flatbed scanner with adapters first but it didn't give the results we wanted. Then the boss reluctantly bought the real scanner. Normal flatbed scanners are fine for home use. For pro use, never.
 
I need a solution to this too. If you buy one, please rent it to me once you are done. I will handle the shipping cost. I have so many films too. Asked around locally for Film to digital conversion, but was being quoted silly prices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Simar
Consumer scanners have max 600dpi optical resolution and the extra resolution is through fake interpolation.
Could be, who knows. But I do remember the resolution could go to 2400 dpi, and it would take half an hour or something to scan an A4 page. That's why, I thought it might work.
 
With the budget you specified, you might not achieve great resolution. Why not consider using a DIY scanner?
Do you mean using a light source like a light table for the film, shooting them with my camera, inverting the colours in post and doing other post-processing? I am considering that, but the amount of effort involved puts me off. If I can't find anything that makes life easier, I'll consider giving it a shot.

Why don't you take a high-res scan with a normal scanner? I'm sure you can scan the whole roll in one go.

Then use some software to turn negatives into positives.
The document scans I've done with my good ol' cheapo HP deskjet don't turn out great and there's a lot of lost detail. But I've never thought about trying it with negatives. I'll see if I can bump up the DPI and get acceptable images.

Could be, who knows. But I do remember the resolution could go to 2400 dpi, and it would take half an hour or something to scan an A4 page. That's why, I thought it might work.
Damn, mine take a few seconds at best lol

I need a solution to this too. If you buy one, please rent it to me once you are done. I will handle the shipping cost. I have so many films too. Asked around locally for Film to digital conversion, but was being quoted silly prices.
Just out of curiosity, what quotes did you get?


I'm also open to increasing the budget to 10k-ish if it means getting something with an alright resolution and some support, so none of the imported no-name Chinese ones where I'm out of money if it doesn't work or has issues.
 
Last edited:
I have done the research on this couple of years ago.

The scanner idea doesn't work because for negatives you need light coming from BEHIND the film slide, but the scanner is designed to scan paper. So it doesn't scan the negatives very well. I tried to be clever and placed my phone at full brightness behind the negative, but to my surprise that makes the scans black and white! This is because the light you see coming from the scanner slide is not actually white, it's flickering quickly between R/G/B, and the sensor can only detect intensity of light, it's a B&W sensor. So the way they scan color is by quickly switching between R/G/B lights and combining the three B&W values it scanned. So without the scanner controlling the light source, it will not be able to give you a color image.

Because of this reason, the scanners designed to scan transparent material are fundamentally different. Your best bet is giving your negatives to a professional scanning service that has the scanner. This is going to be hard to find, but is worth is because it will only get even harder in future.

The only actual DIY alternative is photographing the negatives with a high quality camera, while they are being backlit from behind. But this is harder than it sounds because photographing a flat surface close to the camera without any DOF blur around the edges is very difficult unless you have a very good and expensive macro lens.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lockhrt999
Years ago when I had Nikon camera I rented a Nikon ES2 and a 60mm f2.8 lens to try to convert a few negatives I had. But that solution would be quite expensive if you dont have the camera or a way to rent the lens.

 
  • Like
Reactions: roadrash99