I would go with the new City. I own one and love it, though mine is a manual.
My second choice would be the skoda Rapid. I think its a bit cramped, but good car non the less. Have driven the vento tsi (uncle owns it), super fun to drive but kinda dated looks.
Polo is kinda cramped for me so irrespective of how good the car is, its just not comfortable for me.
The top end S-cross sells at a really high discount, as high as 5 lacs. Check pricing.
Trust me, my family has all been in Honda's all these years.. 3 to be exact.. I had the Type II 1.3 , aunt has a ZX i-DSI which is now being retired & a ZX vtec with by bro in law.
So yeah.. Honda never really need convincing to get into but Honda's idiotic pricing over the years which now makes the City (at least the versions worth getting) sit above 11 lakh is kind of off putting
While we're on the topic.. this just comes in
http://www.motoroids.com/reviews/2017-honda-city-facelift-honda-greiz-design-review/