31-40k Motherboard and CPU combo advice required

Status
Not open for further replies.
Z

zero_cool

Forerunner
I am on the lookout to build an SFF pc. I am unable to reach a sound decision with my MB and CPU combo. These are the best options available to me and I would appreciate any feedback or suggestions. I am looking for most value for money build. I am leaning towards Intel only because I had to deal with bent CPU pins on an AM3 CPU when I was extracting it from the motherboard for a thermal paste job. I had since switched to Intel in 2011 and this issue never occurred again. I only need to purchase the RAM and CPU cooler apart from these, if that detail makes any difference.
  1. 2600 + B450 = Rs. 31,000
  2. 10400F + B460 = Rs. 32,000
  3. 10400 + B460 = Rs. 33,800
  4. 3600 + B550 = Rs. 35,000
  5. 10700 + B460 = Rs. 43,000 (personal preference)
  6. 5600x + B550 = Rs. 43,500
  7. 3700x + B550 = Rs. 49,500
  8. 5600x + X570 = Rs. 54,000
  9. 10700 + Z490 = Rs. 55,500
  10. 11500 + Z590 = Rs. 64,500
 
Last edited:
It depends on what do you want to do with the build. In case you go with Ryzen or a F series processor, you will have to shell out for a graphics card as well. On top of that, the GPU will have to fit the SFF chassis.
 
vaibhavyagnik said:
It depends on what do you want to do with the build. In case you go with Ryzen or a F series processor, you will have to shell out for a graphics card as well. On top of that, the GPU will have to fit the SFF chassis.
Click to expand...
GPU is a compact one so its size won't pose an issue. I intend to game occasionally and only on older titles or indie games. So, I will never consider a power hungry or triple slot GPU. The CPU cooler on the other hand needs some evaluation.
 
If you are going to run old games, you do not need a core i7. If you already have a GPU and not going to stream, you may go with a F series processor
 
  • Like
Reactions: zero_cool
vaibhavyagnik said:
If you are going to run old games, you do not need a core i7. If you already have a GPU and not going to stream, you may go with a F series processor
Click to expand...
Fair point. I just had future proofing in my mind but I think an 10400 should suffice (better to have that igpu). Also, I'll save money by going for 2666 RAM
 
  • Like
Reactions: Docsaab
zero_cool said:
Fair point. I just had future proofing in my mind but I think an 10400 should suffice (better to have that igpu)
Click to expand...
iGPU are a must. Besides acting as a back up if the dGPU fails, you can also use it for other purposes like video encoding in handbrake or while streaming
 
How about buying a deskmini from Amazon , put a r5 3400g or newer ryzen apu in it , it's a pretty good cpu with igpu
 
Docsaab said:
How about buying a deskmini from Amazon , put a r5 3400g or newer ryzen apu in it , it's a pretty good cpu with igpu
Click to expand...
I already have a case and a dedicated GPU set aside. The iGPU was mentioned as the choice was between F and Regular variant of the i5-10400
 
zero_cool said:
I already have a case and a dedicated GPU set aside. The iGPU was mentioned as the choice was between F and Regular variant of the i5-10400
Click to expand...
Sff are generally once a time build , maybe go with 10400 , you can even consider 10100 , old games with daily task will be great on it too if u are planning to save some money
 
Docsaab said:
Sff are generally once a time build , maybe go with 10400 , you can even consider 10100 , old games with daily task will be great on it too if u are planning to save some money
Click to expand...
After much deliberation and research, I have decided to consider Ryzen over Intel. The cost of building a PC in Ryzen is much cheaper and in the long term, I can hope to see a Ryzen ITX motherboard over an Intel one in case the current one turns faulty. The Ryzen 2600 at Rs. 16000 paired with a B450 motherboard will bring the cost of the combo to just Rs. 27,000 (which is less than the cost of the Intel 10700 or Ryzen 5600x). I would've loved to go with a Ryzen 3600 as it is more future proof thanks to compatibility with both B450 and B550 motherboards but at Rs. 21,000 it is overpriced for a 2 year old chip. The Ryzen 5600x is good chip but at Rs. 28,000, I feel, I am pushing my budget and also it is injustice to pair this chip with a cheap B550M motherboard which might limit its TDP.

I am seeking opinions on the Ryzen 2600 + B450 combo? I plan to use the savings towards extra RAM, CPU cooler and case fans.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Pats
Hey there, can you provide your requirements, what will you be using your PC for? How often do you plan to upgrade and given that is a mini itx build, have you zeroed in on a case?
 
Emperor said:
you may get Ryzen 2600/3600 much lower price in offline market, try your near by local shop
Click to expand...
I will check it out today and update here.


gawdfather007 said:
If I had a tight budget like yours I would go with R5 5600x + B450 mini ITX. You can find a good B450 mini ITXs now a days for good price.
Click to expand...
Interesting combination. I did not consider this initially. From the price of the components I have with me, the difference in the cost of a B450 and B550 motherboard will be Rs. 2,000 to Rs. 3,000, at most. Keeping the cost aside, I have read that such a pairing would limit the performance of a 5000 series chip.

Jasku said:
Hey there, can you provide your requirements, what will you be using your PC for? How often do you plan to upgrade and given that is a mini itx build, have you zeroed in on a case?
Click to expand...
This will be my primary machine for work and a bit of occasional gaming (titles from 2018 or earlier and indie games). I am right now using a laptop (8265u, Radeon 530 and 16GB RAM) which works well for all basic tasks such as excel, web browsing and watching videos but even running CS: GO makes the fan spin like a jet taking off (this is after repasting and thorough cleaning). While I don't think my usage will change drastically with the desktop, I don't want to throw away some decent hardware. The desktop will have a longer lifespan and I will prefer working on something without the worry of thermal throttling. The reason for not going after a B550/X570/Z590 board is I don't think I will utilise all the features for which I would pay. I do understand the importance of future proofing as I am coming from a Intel 2500 which was a beast until the motherboard gave away. Lastly, I only plan to upgrade its RAM to 32 GB, 1 or 2 TB NVMe SSD and add a monitor. I do have a case, Corsair 250D, that fits my existing ATX PSU along with my graphic card and SATA SSD. Depending on the platform, I will need to pick a cooler as well.
 
Last edited:
From your current requirements, the 5600x + Asrock B550M Itx (https://mdcomputers.in/asrock-b550m-itx-ac.html) should suffice, but if you have the budget, I would recommend a 5800x, you would be set fort the next 5years at least. For that case you will have to go with a 240mm cooler. The alternative would be a 10700 + b460, given your upgrade cycle, I doubt the platform cost matter, in any way next year, the cycle will change with DDR5 and Intel's alder lake. I think you should look at this as a 1 time investment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zero_cool
If u are going for ryzen build u must have upgradablity in mind , I wud consider buying b550 over b450. They reason being that it 'maybe' able to support more future generation of cpu . Although can't be sure . Ryzen was already planning to not support 5xxx series with b450 due to bios memory constraints
 
  • Like
Reactions: zero_cool
Jasku said:
From your current requirements, the 5600x + Asrock B550M Itx (https://mdcomputers.in/asrock-b550m-itx-ac.html) should suffice, but if you have the budget, I would recommend a 5800x, you would be set fort the next 5years at least. For that case you will have to go with a 240mm cooler. The alternative would be a 10700 + b460, given your upgrade cycle, I doubt the platform cost matter, in any way next year, the cycle will change with DDR5 and Intel's alder lake. I think you should look at this as a 1 time investment.
Click to expand...
Good point about this as a one time investment. Does make a lot of sense. If long term or one-time investment is the thought, then Ryzen is way to go. I am getting a a 3700x for Rs. 24,000 so pairing that with a B550 will bring the actual cost to Rs. 38,000, which is consideration worthy.

Docsaab said:
If u are going for ryzen build u must have upgradablity in mind , I wud consider buying b550 over b450. They reason being that it 'maybe' able to support more future generation of cpu . Although can't be sure . Ryzen was already planning to not support 5xxx series with b450 due to bios memory constraints
Click to expand...
Yes, I did read up on it. This will be the last hardware of this generation.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom