[NEWS] HC issues notice to telcos on SMS charges

vivek.krishnan

vivek.krishnan

BLR~ZRS-TX-1-MX
Skilled
HC issues notice to telcos on SMS charges
PTI | Dec 29, 2011, 11.22AM IST

MADURAI: The Madras High Court issued notices to 10 mobile companies on a petition seeking to bar them from charging extra for SMSes during festivals and other important days.

The high court bench issued notices while admitting a petition by a lawyer, seeking a direction to the companies and the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) not to hike the tariff for this period.

Petitioner Arunachalam also sought an interim stay on undue and sudden hike on SMS charges during important festivals and special occasions like New year's eve on December 31 and January 1.

He contended that mobile companies offered attractive packages while enrolling customers, including 200 Free SMS for Rs one a day, 50 paise per SMS but later announce they would maintain special SMS tariffs on December 31.

This forces users to restrict SMS and curtail private space and free communication on important festival days. Trai was also not taking steps to control it, he alleged.

Arunachalam said mobile operators, regardless of tariff plans would charge Rs 1.50 per SMS on Dec 31, "which is unfair." Last year SMS revenue of the companies was Rs 100 crore, he claimed.

The petitioner said users were being charged extra at a time when they want to use their mobiles the most, "fully violating natural justice and rights given in the Constitution."

Among important days on which extra tariff was collected was Pongal, Christmas, New year, Valentines day, Independence day and Diwali, he said.

The bench after hearing him, ordered notices to the Trai chairperson and Zonal/Regional Managers of 10 companies-- Bharti Airtel ltd, Aircel Ltd, Vodafone, Reliance, Idea Cellular, Unitech, Tata Docomo, MTS mobile, BSNL mobile and Videocon and posted the case for further hearing on January 21 2012.
Click to expand...

Source : HC issues notice to telcos on SMS charges - The Times of India
 
"The petitioner said users were being charged extra at a time when they want to use their mobiles the most, "fully violating natural justice and rights given in the Constitution."

Good! No more blackouts :bleh:
 
HC issued the notices on the basis of "Charging extra"

But what the companies do is not charge extra, but they withdraw discount

Similar things but not same

Its like if an item X has a MRP of Rs 100

Most of the year it is sold for Rs 5 at a 95% discount

But on certain days it is sold for Rs 100 with 0 discount

How can the court force the company to put the discount on the days with 0 discount?
 
mehrotra.akash said:
HC issued the notices on the basis of "Charging extra"

But what the companies do is not charge extra, but they withdraw discount

Similar things but not same

Its like if an item X has a MRP of Rs 100

Most of the year it is sold for Rs 5 at a 95% discount

But on certain days it is sold for Rs 100 with 0 discount

How can the court force the company to put the discount on the days with 0 discount?
Click to expand...

Which Company are you representing ? :p

BTW,good move from HC
 
Back
Top