I agree with anks, these places are recommended only if you know your way around. They're just waiting to swoop upon you if they sense you're a babe in the woods.
Check out Alfa, you might pay a bit extra compared to some of the other places, but the sense of security you get in not having been ripped off makes it totally worth it. If you need a landmark for Alfa, it's 5 minutes from Mithibai college. Not that the rickshaw guy or the common man on the street, won't know where it is, but just for your own reference.
@ sri_k: as far as i remember, they do.