which is better...

john_avi

Disciple
Nov 14, 2008
101
0
26
41
Hi guyz,
Please suggest me which is a better choice Intel Core 2 duo (2.9ghz) or AMD Athlon 245 (2.9 ghz). My main uses are casual gaming,music and some programming also.
 

desiibond

Skilled
Jan 19, 2009
3,120
1,481
253
41
Forget about core2duo. Get Athlon II X2 245 or pick Core i3.

and if possible, pick Athlon II X4 630 (5.5k )
 

ALPHA17

Cooler "Master"
Skilled
Jan 6, 2010
8,028
169
203
Delhi, India
Go ahead with the AMD try to get the Phenom II 550 its the best shouldn't be more than 6K as well don't buy i3 as it has got worst bandwidth. Worse than even the Core2 series :)
 

john_avi

Disciple
Nov 14, 2008
101
0
26
41
Thanks guyz

I have a doubt many ppl have suggested me not to take amd because of heating problem. is it true? does it still have heating issues? as u all are using it so must be knowing.
 

dreamCatcher

Disciple
Jan 23, 2010
145
11
81
john_avi said:
Thanks guyz

I have a doubt many ppl have suggested me not to take amd because of heating problem. is it true? does it still have heating issues? as u all are using it so must be knowing.

AMD had heating issues 6 years back, since Athlon64 they run super cool. In fact, I would say Intel runs hotter since the Prescott days.
Get your facts right, don't listen to those uninformed shopkeepers. The reason they say this is because their profits are less in selling AMD processors, and Intel gives them huge commission.
 

ALPHA17

Cooler "Master"
Skilled
Jan 6, 2010
8,028
169
203
Delhi, India
dreamCatcher said:
AMD had heating issues 6 years back, since Athlon64 they run super cool. In fact, I would say Intel runs hotter since the Prescott days.
Get your facts right, don't listen to those uninformed shopkeepers. The reason they say this is because their profits are less in selling AMD processors, and Intel gives them huge commission.

well said the shop keepers are all very biased due to the fact that they have to continually keep bleeding the no. of old out of demand Core2 Duo and Core2quads in stock, fact is some are still trying to pass of the older Prescott processors in their stocks as older version of Core2Duo and the unsuspecting people fall into the trap :mad:
 

desiibond

Skilled
Jan 19, 2009
3,120
1,481
253
41
AMD processors getting heated up is just a rumour. I usually hear the same thing word-by-word all over Andhra as if someone has told everyone to utter the same thing for the past decade. I have been using AMD for past 6years and I never faced problem with heat and my processors always stay overclocked.
 

crvinay_4u

Adept
Apr 29, 2009
334
1
0
31
john_avi said:
Thanks guyz

I have a doubt many ppl have suggested me not to take amd because of heating problem. is it true? does it still have heating issues? as u all are using it so must be knowing.
Even my friend claimed that you can't even use AMD based systems in summer because it runs very hot.I was feeling like :mad::mad: and kick his a** and put his head into an oven and make him feel real heat.:no:
 

chetansha

Skilled
Jun 30, 2007
2,682
1
2,879
477
Coimbatore
john_avi said:
Thanks guyz

I have a doubt many ppl have suggested me not to take amd because of heating problem. is it true? does it still have heating issues? as u all are using it so must be knowing.

LOL. They still telling these stories ? The Proccy that came before the Athlon XP series were hot ( i forgot the name, i still have a board and proccy running). But after the XP series its all Thanda Thanda cool cool
 

ALPHA17

Cooler "Master"
Skilled
Jan 6, 2010
8,028
169
203
Delhi, India
crvinay_4u said:
Even my friend claimed that you can't even use AMD based systems in summer because it runs very hot.I was feeling like :mad::mad: and kick his a** and put his head into an oven and make him feel real heat.:no:

Well Said :hap2: :eek:hyeah:
 

desiibond

Skilled
Jan 19, 2009
3,120
1,481
253
41
crvinay_4u said:
Even my friend claimed that you can't even use AMD based systems in summer because it runs very hot.I was feeling like :mad::mad: and kick his a** and put his head into an oven and make him feel real heat.:no:

he will get back to you and say, "This microwave oven has AMD processor and hence it's very hot inside. Told Ya!"

sunny27 said:
thunderbird ? duron? k6?

those were K5 processors and the main reason for that was AMD didn't provide cooling with CPU and people had to buy third party coolers which were not as effective as Intel's and hence the heat thing. But it all was gone from K6. Since the release of Athlon, AMD had been on the cooler side. BTW, remember those blazing hot Pentium 4s? :)
 

hyperknight

Disciple
Mar 20, 2010
184
3
0
38
AMD is definitely the way to go.

X2 will run you around 2.6k(2 cores), X3 will run you around 3.6k(3 cores) and X4 will run you around 5.5k(quad core). Instead of the dual core processors, consider spending 1000 more and getting yourself 33% better processing power.

AMD > Intel in my opinion. But then again, that's my opinion :)
 

john_avi

Disciple
Nov 14, 2008
101
0
26
41
Thank you guyz for your suggestion, I have finally ordered AMD athlon X4 (630) with a gigabyte mobo. Today I"ll be getting this. After few days I want to add a low-end decent graphics card which can run games like F.E.A.R and Far Cry on low settings. So please advice me. I am running tight on budget.
 

DarkAngel

Skilled
Apr 10, 2009
6,420
322
222
^ How much are u willing to spend on the GPU?
What is ur monitor size, the resolution u aim to play at and the PSU u have?
 

john_avi

Disciple
Nov 14, 2008
101
0
26
41
Sorry I am not familiar with the lingo here. What is the meaning of PSU?
I am having 15" monitor. Budget is around 4k.
 

DarkAngel

Skilled
Apr 10, 2009
6,420
322
222
You could have just googled it and the 2nd link would say PSU-> Power supply Unit. Also called as SMPS.
I guess you have a generic one as you are not aware of what PSU stands for.
For a 15" monitor a MSI ATI HD4650~3k should do. Gives decent frame rates for a 1024*768 resolution.