#ModiSarkar 1 Yr Coming Up : Your Experience?

Do you feel the difference in your personal life after ModiSarkar took charge?


  • Total voters
    20

Phenomenal

Disciple
So #ModiSarkar 1 Yr Coming Up : Your Experience?
It was interesting to see such a massive mandate so that a stable govt can be formed for the 16th the Lok Sabha.

What changes :
a)Did you expect before/after election?
b)Have you seen in reality?Examples would be great.
c)Do you feel the difference in your daily life (personal & professional both) after ModiSarkar took charge?If so,what are those?

All opinions welcome but views especially from somebody dealing directly with the Central Govt or sharing insider info you got from your dads,moms,chachas,mamas,chachis,mamis working with/for the govt would be really cool to know.
 
a) He's no mahapurush to change things in a year.
b)Corruption in Central Departments reduced.
- Resurrection in PSU such as Indian Railways is commendable.
c) Gave a sweet punch to the face of the startups/common man in the name of Taxes. Esp Service Tax.


Rating? 5/10

Is he doing the same overhyping before elections thing now? Yes, Showing the actual 2 feet mannequin projection as 10 Feet. Hyped.

Anything in future? Could be better by 10%
 
Last edited:
I have been very impressed with the foreign policy shift. The guy sells the country better than the last few PM's put together.

There is a ton of money that can be invested in the country if they can get projects moving. How long have those been stuck. Indian companies don't want to invest and prefer to do so abroad so unless things can be unclogged then foreign investors will be waiting as well.

A year is short. ask the question after three years.
 
First, I really could not understand the question itself.
He is not a magician who will take away all your problems and that too in just 1 year?
It would take another 5 years just to undo the damage already done by previous government and then you can see changes getting reflected in your personal life.
First year, he has made some great policy decisions like changing the planning commission to Niti Ayog and changing the way it works.
Another one is bank accounts/life insurance and health insurance which has impact on greater masses.
 
About selling the country.

Is it a Sarcasm?

Or it means he represents the country better?
No sarcasm.

He's our #1 sales man. Promoter.

Just like leaders from other countries come to visit us to win business for their companies.

I'm not into this lame ass cynicism. when he goes abroad for a foreign trip, wish him happy holidays when he returns then say 'welcome to india' (!)
 
Last edited:
India is not a investment friendly market and Modi is not doing anything to rectify that situation. Especially, the tax system. Rules are changed at whims and fancy and then applied retrospectively to companies to extract more taxes from them when ever they please. Then there is the politics, labor issues and other things which are all factors that affect investments. This kind of environment is bad in the long run. Sure Modi is getting pledges of investments or closing some deals here and there, but as they say, a fool and his money are soon parted and once these investors taste that, they won't invest more. The only exception may be for some specific markets where returns are guaranteed no matter who you end up doing.

After looking at what happened to Nokia and Foxconn, would any one want to setup a mobile phone factory in India.

God knows how many IT/Telecom and Manufacturing investments India has lost to china or for that matter even European countries.

I have heard that the Chinese even actively list the negatives about India in presentations to discourage potential investors from coming to India and instead invest in China. The fact that investors thought that putting manufacturing plants in costlier western markets is better putting them in than India says a lot about our market.

Hyderabad lost several big ventures to China and other countries during the Telangana statehood riots. The companies that were already here had to live in fear. Buildings were at risk of damage. Employees were at risk from violence. Riots and Bandhs resulting in ability to operate offices several times. Most of the companies in HiTech city area had to give massive amounts in protection money to KCR in order to keep functioning. Some smaller companies even ended up relocating to other cities after their existing leases ended.
 
Last edited:
So #ModiSarkar 1 Yr Coming Up : Your Experience?
It was interesting to see such a massive mandate so that a stable govt can be formed for the 16th the Lok Sabha.

What changes :
a)Did you expect before/after election?
b)Have you seen in reality?Examples would be great.
c)Do you feel the difference in your daily life (personal & professional both) after ModiSarkar took charge?If so,what are those?

All opinions welcome but views especially from somebody dealing directly with the Central Govt or sharing insider info you got from your dads,moms,chachas,mamas,chachis,mamis working with/for the govt would be really cool to know.

What India thinks.

timesofindia.indiatimes.com/what-India-thinks-of-the-modi-government/listshow/47305668.cms

I think it's our tendency to keep unreasonable hopes & laziness to change on our own. We still expect some miracle man will come and change the system.

If we come out of it, Modiji 1yr has been above average & definitely better than UPA.

Things I liked most.
1. Swachch Bharat Abhiyaan
2. Mandatory bank account openings
3. Social Security Schemes Accident insurance of 2 Lakh @ 12rs/ yr
Girl child insurance
4. MEA interventions to rescue stranded Indians from war zones, it's not a small task
5. Billions of investment coming & mostly successful foreign tours.
6. Most importantly India is pretty positive than ever before.

I traveled 500 kms to cast two Votes (myself and wife) for Modiji & I am happy with my decision so far !!
 
All those 'billion dollar deals' are great for sensational headlines, but they will remain on paper until the ground reality changes. No sane investor is going to put in money when there is so much uncertainty on land, labour and taxes. Case in point, POSCO. No amount of foreign trips and PR exercises will help.
 
India is not a investment friendly market and Modi is not doing anything to rectify that situation.
His administration is trying, the objection is the arrogant manner in which it is being done. First the opposition makes a noise because that is their job but there are also state govts that are crucial as in the end the buck stops with them. With the last administration you had a lot of small people with big shoes throwing wrenches in the system as a display of their power. It is less now but still a factor. CM's of Gujarat & Maha were in Shanghai to interact with their counterparts.

Where the hell was my CM ? he had more important things to do (!)

Especially, the tax system. Rules are changed at whims and fancy and then applied retrospectively to companies to extract more taxes from them when ever they please.
Jaitley & Modi have been at pains to reassure people abroad that they won't pull any of these stunts. But doubts are still there. They say they won't charge anything going forward but are happy to collect from the past. I read the other day that there was this lobby group in Hong Kong that filed a case in the supreme court challenging the govt over this point. This is the first time such a case has been filed by a foreign party and the results will be telling.

Then there is the politics, labor issues and other things which are all factors that affect investments. This kind of environment is bad in the long run. Sure Modi is getting pledges of investments or closing some deals here and there, but as they say, a fool and his money are soon parted and once these investors taste that, they won't invest more. The only exception may be for some specific markets where returns are guaranteed no matter who you end up doing.
Rajasthan & MP are experimenting with labour reforms. The idea is if it works there it increases pressure on other states to enact investor friendly legislation. States are free to go as fast or not as they please. centre can't shove things down anybody's throat. But when elections come around people will want to know what the progress has been and will give their verdict.

After looking at what happened to Nokia and Foxconn, would any one want to setup a mobile phone factory in India.

God knows how many IT/Telecom and Manufacturing investments India has lost to china or for that matter even European countries.
If things work out then you will see a reversal.

I have heard that the Chinese even actively list the negatives about India in presentations to discourage potential investors from coming to India and instead invest in China. The fact that investors thought that putting manufacturing plants in costlier western markets is better putting them in than India says a lot about our market.
The optics & atmospherics of the China trip were very good. When it comes to China set aside the border issue for now, that requires more political trust to develop before attempts to resolve it can work. Instead think of one number.

4.3 trillion

that the amount the chinese have in us treasury bonds earning low interest. If you owe the bank $1 million then the bank owns you. But if you owe the bank 1$ trillion, then you own the bank. Would China like to diversify elsewhere where they can get a better return. of course. The PM would like us to ask the question.

What is he doing to attract a portion of that number ?
What is he doing to make India is the best place in the world to invest.

Whether he gets another term or not will depend on that answer.

China in twenty years will age faster than India. So they will be even more dependent on returns. They most certainly want to invest here. Working costs are increasing there. Their gdp per capita is higher than us, they would like to shift work here if it makes sense. Not only them many others too. The Japanese & Koreans have been very patiently putting up with our crap. The Japanese have a strategic imperative to diversify out of China.

After Xi's visit in September the question asked was when $100 billion was promised why only a fraction materialised. The simple reason is we are unable to absorb more and this continues to be the case. Of this $20 billion, we have only secured 10% of the land required for the projects concerned. The ball is very clearly in our court.
 
Last edited:
We still expect some miracle man will come and change the system.
Expectations were created during the election campaign.

Then the media gets on it and says big bang reforms. well, if there are no such reforms then is it a failure ?

No, if a false premise is created then the problem is the premise.

We can't do big bang, it would be so disruptive as to instigate a full blown rebellion. How can you reform a people that are determined to fight you at every step. Not possible. Not advisable. Only way is buy in and that takes time.

I traveled 500 kms to cast two Votes (myself and wife) for Modiji & I am happy with my decision so far !!
I remember a thread here back in 2007 when Modi had won the state elections. Course at that time there was a narrative going on about him. But the Gujju's here were very supportive. I understand why only now.
 
To answer the question, NO.
I believe that this govt. is a well balanced one. It is however, far from perfect but I think this is the best govt. India can get in the current scenario of political parties.

The good:
1. Foreign policy
2. Disaster Management
3. Relief operations for stranded Indians in foreign countries. (https://twitter.com/sai_swaroopa/status/586226760448106496)
4. Taking steps for technological advancements & gathering opinion of people in decision making
5. Overall clean image of almost all cabinet ministers.
6. Less bullshit statements by politicians
7. More efficiency in parliament (This may be lass due to BJP & more due to small opposition in LS)

The bad:
1.The Hindu/RSS/Shiv Sena/VHP dramas like ghar wapsi.
2. Too much promises by Modi which even he knows he cannot fulfill.
3. Bad mouthing previous governments on foreign soil.
4. No response to criticisms and no response when opposition demanded statements in parliament
5. Following UPA policies which they opposed earlier: http://www.firstpost.com/politics/t...-sarkar-has-morphed-into-the-upa-2244364.html
6. Land Bill
 
People were expecting transformative change (as promised), they aren't even getting incremental change. The only good thing they're doing is Make in India.

BJP for last 3 years of UPA stalled every bill, opposed everything from FDI to GST. Interestingly NaMo was leading the GST protest as a CM of the state, along with other BJP states. Now they have made a u-turn on all these issues while the acts remain unchanged.

Now the tables have turned and congress very effectively is giving them the same treatment. And why not? The BJP thinks it can get away with its bullshit. Just yesterday they appointed the Principal Secretary for Deli through Lieutenant Governeror of Delhi, over riding an independently elected Delhi govt. Whereas Modi passed an ordinance in the Parliament to appoint Nripendra Misra who was in-elegible previously as the Principal secretary. So Modi gets to pick his team, but when Arvind wants to, they will try to derail them as much as possible. They will shame others for not supporting them, but the reality is no one supports them cause they have backstabbed them all.

It just shows how cunning the BJP is. Why should other parties have to sit and take it? Ofcourse, the nation gets ****ed in their tussle, but as long as they have blind bhakts nothing will change.

Hell even Mausi-ji doesnt like NaMo's year in office. -> Modi is like a new bride refashioning herself for a wealthy sasural, says Madhu Kishwar
 
Last edited:
Back
Top