Doing the right thing here:
Agree with this. Add local mother tongue too..
I said the THEORY of ayurveda is illogical and unscientific and most importantly, unprovable. I did not say that knowledge of herbs and techniques is also illogical. Anything in Ayurveda that works can and is being assimilated into modern medicine. Ayurvedic research institutions funded by the government are trying to do this through their trials. So there is no potential being left on the table. It's just that people think there is a treasure trove of revolutionary medicines in there when in reality the trials are disappointing. So it's the over-hype by babas and ayurvedic practitioners that is causing this perception.
Agree with this to a good extend, however it was knowledge of it's own time which was eons earlier.
Okay, good...! so now, from where does this knowledge came from in Ayurveda ?
Right, agree. This is only what am saying too. But to say Ayurveda totally is merely dumb text to start with, will not help it.
In India they started comparatively recently. In west they did much earlier and wanted patents on those natural herbs and whatever?
See am totally not into babas of any kind, nor into pseudo science side of Ayurveda.
No doubt through experimentation. If the theory was sound then the treatments that didn't work would have been discarded by Ayurveda itself, but they are not discarded in the name of tradition. People in the past tried all sorts of things, herbs, techniques, practices over thousands of years. Some of it works some of it doesn't work. If you think that they were able to achieve some understanding of the human body that modern medicine has not been able to deduce, then it must show in the theoretical fundamentals of Ayurveda. You should read the Ayurveda texts yourself, they are easily available online, it will become clear that it's a product of its time and some extremely incorrect things are mentioned in there.
Patents have nothing to do with science, patents are only for business purposes. You can patent completely useless things that don't have any benefit as long as you are the first to file the patent. Patent trolling happens in all fields and those people basically apply for large number of broad vague patents so that in the odd chance some beneficial use is discovered, they can file a legal case and make money. That doesn't mean that the thing is useful. What Indian government is doing is also the same thing. The patent every herb mentioned in Ayurveda, not just those that have been proven to work. So this is a completely different topic.
Hmm...
mOkay...
So, that which works is logical ? Or totally farce ? What is it ?
Where was modern medicine thousands of years earlier when Ayurveda was being 'experimented' ? There was no modern science developed anywhere to autocorrect Ayurveda, so it evolved with it's own issues.
That is not what proponents of patents claim.
You can patent completely useful things too.
Isn't Indian govt. stance against patent on living things ?
If it works it works. Modern medicine readily adopts treatments that work clinically even if there is no mechanism understood behind it. For example penicillin was discovered by accident and it was proven to work clinically, there was no understanding of how exactly the drug acts on bacteria, yet it was adopted. So modern medicine never shies away from using things without explanation and it will readily steal anything from Ayurveda that is proven to work.
I am also saying the same, and like I said, it is not being ignored, on the contrary it is getting excessive resources from the government when compared to what it's able to give back in terms of results.
No you are wrong about this, please look this up a bit more, anyway this is not the main topic here so I won't go in depth.
Good, this is how it should be, at least we reached some balanced approach on this. Liked the word you used, what I dislike is the when thief says they don't steal and is a puritan satyavaan, and when the stolen asset was his from the beginning
I do not care whether it's modern medicine/Ayur/Homeo, as long as it actually works.
Just speaking your own tongue to help you understand. Logic clearly doesn't work
This is the problem with people like you.
Duh !!! Suddenly you got enlightened by me now ? lolz.
Good that you are learning to think right wayJust speaking your own tongue to help you understand. Logic clearly doesn't work
, if you go forward like this, I'll have to admit you're becoming self aware. lolz.This could be understood that the reasons were not legal.
Didn't realize you were a Bodhi tree. Go read my first reply to this thread before making yourself more of a fool and showing that you can neither read nor write, but eager to call names.
You purposefully ignored and didn't highlight "due to some" part of the sentence, which could've made a difference in your understanding. Willful ignorance is innate with your comments anyways.
English is not my native language, I made a linguistic error.
I admit my lack of linguistic skills in being more nastier than you.
Right. In fact, much worse things are getting lots of resources on research : https://www.telegraphindia.com/indi...andrayaan-clashes-with-cow-wisdom/cid/1972995
