Kotak Mahindra or SBI?

Status
Not open for further replies.

scott1391990

Galvanizer
Fed up with PNB and its shitty CC, I have finally decided to switch bank. Anyone who has used both and can tell which one is better?

I mostly do online payments for shopping and sometimes transferring some amount but nothing else. Which one would best suit me? I am thinking about the pros of SBI as it mostly provides coupons and cashback for various sites. While Kotak provides 6% interest. How much does SBI provide?
 
While Kotak provides 6% interest

IIRC, this is applicable only if you have balance above 1L.

EDIT: Fine print says same
* Earn 6% interest p.a. on savings account balance over Rs. 1 Lakh. Balances up to Rs. 1 Lakh will earn 5.0% interest p.a.
 
Last edited:
Scott, why are you fed up with pnb?
If all you do is shop online and make transfers, it wouldn't matter which bank it is. Kotak requires a MAB unless it's a jiffy account you are referring to.
 
Like most of the govt employees, the workers in my branch are too arrogant and don't wanna work properly. And changed my mobile number when only I wanted to update my address. Now when I am facing issues their CC is just plain stupid. Better to bang your head on the wall then to talk to them.
Are you referring to minimum account balance? How much do they ask for? And whats jiffy account?
 
I have my primary account in Kotak Mahindra and I am pleased with the service so far.

- Online transactions are fuss-free.
- Ordered a new cheque book online and it was delivered within 2 days.
- I wanted to take car loan from SBI, I got the ECS form and signature verified within 30 min from the nearest branch (there are 3 branches in 3 km radius!)
- ATMs are present everywhere! I guess more than SBI!

One problem is that they called me daily for credit card a few days back. Though they don't call anymore but it took more than once to make them understand that I don't want a credit card and to stop calling me.
 
if all you want is good service then you can't compare a private bank with sarkari. if you have deep pockets then go with the private bank because you'll be wasting a lot of time with sarkari banks... and you know, time is money!

- ATMs are present everywhere! I guess more than SBI!
i haven't done the fact checking, but when you talk about physical presence in india, SBI is quite far reaching than any of the private banks. SBI would definitely have more than double the ATMs of Kotak.
 
Avoid SBI. Apart from shitty service at its branches, SBI has quite become the Airtel of banking sector (Milking customers due to availability). SBI charges ₹114 per year for its debit card that doesn't work on international sites. Plus ₹15 per quarter for SMS. They were charging fee for using debit card online above a particular number of times last year but I am not sure if they still do.

If you can maintain ₹10k balance, I will suggest that you go for any private bank like HDFC, Axis or Kotak. After ING-Kotak merger, it has become the 3rd largest private bank in India, so ATM and branch availability should not be an issue.
 
I currently have my only banking account with SBI and it's clearly time to move on. Back when I got the account opened, majority of the staff was middle aged and you encountered 'sarkaari' attitude often. For the past couple of years or more, most of that old staff has been replaced by youngsters with even the BM being a late 30s dude. At the same time, the workload for these new peeps has increased enormously. This new bunch is polite and courteous but has too much on its hands, which makes me feel it's only a matter of time before they start snapping too, leading to too much waiting times. Anyway, earlier I had to wait a minimum of half-an-hour to make a deposit but since it was a rare event, it was alright. But then the bank introduced paperless deposit feature and deposits through CDM. So yes, they are trying to make it easier for the consumer but I think the pace is just not satisfactory, especially as you mature into your work life and time becomes increasingly scarce.

So ICICI it is for me from now on but as I'm a renter, an SBI passbook's standing as a valid residential proof document will still keep me holding onto their savings account for now.

EDIT: If you're really gung-ho about a public-sector bank, would advise to look at one of the associate state banks like SBH, SBBJ, SBT etc. Go for newer branches of these banks in your area. The new ones in my area wear a deserted look all the time with often one person managing the different duties at the branch.
 
My friends boss gave him 10k to deposit in his PNB account. He used the CDM machine to do so and the machine counted only 8k out of the 10k he put in it. He informed the bank and they told him to give them a written complaint. He did so and was told that when the machine is opened in the morning the stuck notes will be found and deposited in his account. 3 days passed and no amount was credited so he went back to the bank and was told that they didn't find any stuck money in the machine. On top of all this they shouted at him saying that he lied and that he is trying to get free money from the bank. This wasn't the case as i was present when he did the deposit and the machine even showed "out of service error" immediately after it. I am never going to recommend PNB to any one ever.


Now let's talk about AXIS. I have 2 accounts with them. On one account i cant use the CDM machine, everytime i try, it throws "Service unavailable error". It will however work for the next person in line or pretty much anyone else.. On my second account i don't get any sms notifications at all and my name is stuck to "Sample embossa name". I have complained about these issues to the bank countless times and they never figure out the problem. "Saar hamare end me sab sahi hai, aap dubara try kare" is what they tell me every time. The only other response i get from them is "Saar naya account open karwalo sab sahi chalega", as if i have nothing better to do. They also charge 500rs as their card fees and require 10000rs minimum balance.
Also when i was opening my second account with them i filled the form for a savings account and it somehow ended up being a current account. I didn't even bother complaining about this as they would simply tell me to open another account with them.
People at axis also lie a lot. They were running some promotion for a 0 balance youth account a long time ago and that was when i went to them for the first time. The guy that came to talk to me told me they had no such account and that i was required to maintain a 10000rs minimum balance. I had to show him the details of the account on the banks website for him to even admit that the account existed. He was really pissed after that, he didn't said anything to me but it was pretty clear by the way he was talking to the other employees throughout the whole account opening process.
The only reason i am still with axis is because they gave me a preapproved credit card.


TLDR: PNB steals money and AXIS is a total mess.
 
Wow. I am guessing I have been lucky so far with HDFC. However I must say that I haven't used cash deposit machines or anything like that. Used to deposit cash at their counter and operate my account online for every other purpose. For 500 buck a year, got their platinum debit card which means I could take out 1L from ATMs in a day, whenever needed. I used to book and cancel my FDs online too.
 
I got an ICICI account from 9 years now and its absolutely fuss free (provided thats your salary account which it is in my case :p) Their site is a breeze to traverse through with no clutters or confusions.
 
Avoid SBI. Apart from shitty service at its branches, SBI has quite become the Airtel of banking sector (Milking customers due to availability). SBI charges ₹114 per year for its debit card that doesn't work on international sites. Plus ₹15 per quarter for SMS. They were charging fee for using debit card online above a particular number of times last year but I am not sure if they still do.

If you can maintain ₹10k balance, I will suggest that you go for any private bank like HDFC, Axis or Kotak. After ING-Kotak merger, it has become the 3rd largest private bank in India, so ATM and branch availability should not be an issue.

Totally agreed. I have a SBI account linked to a PPF account and I also have a 2 Lac Fixed Deposits linked with the account. I am still charged SMS fees and the like and for what? Because they send the OTP when you make a transaction online. They also charge me every time I do an NEFT which none of my private banks do (salary account or not). Thankfully, I did not get an Debit card for this account, otherwise, I would be charged fees for that too. My mom's and sister's account are charged fees for the card as well.

Furthermore, you would be left utterly helpless if anything goes wrong while doing a transaction whether its online purchase/credit back after cancelling an order or any bank related transaction. They have a call center and toll free number whose sole job is to tell you to go to the home branch for whatever issue.

And let me assure you that visiting their branch is an exercise in testing your patience and endurance. Most of the time, they will have large queues piled up and employees are inefficient as hell. They have electronic cash counters and still the guy behind the counter will count cash twice with the electronic counter and 3 times by hand even while the queue is piled up till its outside the main door. A lot of times, they will complain that there is some problem with the network or the systems and they will be happily playing solitaire while customers wait in lines.

Online facility is nothing great either. You can book an FD online or cancel an FD only during official working hours only.

If you don't make any transaction for a few months, your account will be locked out and you have to visit the home branch and get it unlocked, you have to submit a ID proof and apparently you cannot use a document that you used in the past. For instance, if you opened the account with your passport as proof, you apparently cannot use a passport as proof when the account gets locked out, so you have to submit something else like the Aadhar card. Either you be careful not to let your account get locked out or every time this happens, you better be prepared to pull a fresh id proof out of your ass or your account will not be unlocked.

They also apparently have one of the worst history of bank related frauds and mistakes. They don't scrutinize well where it matters. Several times, fraudsters have picked up cheques dropped by customers in ATMs, got a account created in SBI with a similar name with fake documents and managed to get the cheques deposited and withdrew the amount.

Every time I had to deal with SBI has been a taxing experience. The only reason I even have the account is because of the PPF account and because the bank won't easily let me migrate my PPF account to ICICI without a fight.
 
I am lucky that my employer gave me a Standard Chartered salary account which lets me withdraw cash from any bank's ATM (worldwide!) without any charges unlimited number of times per month. Plus the daily withdrawal limit is 3 lacs (which is the max cap by RBI). The same benefits requires minimum balance of 3 lacs to be maintained for a non-salary account.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.