The India - South Africa Series thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dhoni's post match speech: "Well Ofcourse", my prime motive today was to win the toss today and I did. Screw You all.

Well Ofcourse, one can always blame the _uckworth Lewis method for the 3-2 loss. I hope Rajinikanth knows how the _uck this _uckWorth Lewis method works. Well Ofcourse!
 
Hmm.. this tour proved credentials of Kohli, Pathan over Raina, Yujraj..

At least Yuvraj consolidated with his bowling, but Raina will still be preferred based on his big hitting in subcontinent.

Good to see Pathan actually choosing bad balls to hit, rather than reckless hitting, a la Afridi
 
Really India has luck to come out of series 3-2.

India should have lost 5-0.

Cmmon Dhoni "Ofcourse" you never take the blame.

Totally worried about world cup. 3 Players (Sachin, shewag, Gambir) are cmming out of injury. 2 Players Completely out of form (Dhoni, Raina). No Guarentee that kohli would play and Munaf Patel will fire. Yuvraj I think has scored less runs than raina in the series.

"Ofcourse " pitches are different but it is not the pitch that got them out all these matches.

Dont know what will happen
 
i think gambhir would had been a better captain dhoni for this tour of fit.

I still fail to understnad why chawla is their in team.The team this days look more to be ipl flavour lobbying rather than providing opportunities in absence of shewag,sachin.

Also i fail to understand how all greats get all well but in tours they are down with injuries.Though benefit of doubt can be given to sachin as he do missed first ipl games in great numbers.
 
Sachin took a break from srilanka series (or some series after he hit that 200 runs) if i am not wrong but played champions Trophy. He is no saint. Only thing is he keeps his mouth shut.

Also why does rohit sharma and Murali vijay are being selected as replacements. They are failing again and again. These people should be replaced by new set of replacements so that chances are being given to new players.
 
MAGNeT said:
I still fail to understnad why chawla is their in team.

Clever strategy to rest Piyush Chawla for 30 months after his last ODI on Jul 2, 2008. He must be quite fresh now, well ofcourse. :|
 
sg3707 said:
Sachin took a break from srilanka series (or some series after he hit that 200 runs) if i am not wrong but played champions Trophy. He is no saint. Only thing is he keeps his mouth shut.

Also why does rohit sharma and Murali vijay are being selected as replacements. They are failing again and again. These people should be replaced by new set of replacements so that chances are being given to new players.
Well in that case Cricket Australia forced Hussey and Bollinger to play in CL T20 coz its the Indian, Australian and CSA board that organises this tournament and you cant have your players missing from it.

Sachin never ever missed a Test match and just the meaningless ODI's against SL ( I guess we have played some 5-6 series in 2 yrs)

How a team's captain opt out when they have made it to a gloabal tournament after finishing runners in the domestic league!!!

Anyways he is certain to retire from ODI's after the WC. He never played a ODI after the SA series in Feb 2010 till this year. At 37 one has pick and choose games rather than playing all games and get injured.
 
DarkAngel said:
Well in that case Cricket Australia forced Hussey and Bollinger to play in CL T20 coz its the Indian, Australian and CSA board that organises this tournament and you cant have your players missing from it.

Sachin never ever missed a Test match and just the meaningless ODI's against SL ( I guess we have played some 5-6 series in 2 yrs)

How a team's captain opt out when they have made it to a gloabal tournament after finishing runners in the domestic league!!!

Anyways he is certain to retire from ODI's after the WC. He never played a ODI after the SA series in Feb 2010 till this year. At 37 one has pick and choose games rather than playing all games and get injured.
i completely agree with you.... has anybody noticed total number of runs Dhoni scored in SA ODI series....we need to throw him out. look at ponting....if he dont score there is hell after him but here Dhoni seems enjoying his place by doing nothing..
 
DarkAngel said:
Well in that case Cricket Australia forced Hussey and Bollinger to play in CL T20 coz its the Indian, Australian and CSA board that organises this tournament and you cant have your players missing from it.

Sachin never ever missed a Test match and just the meaningless ODI's against SL ( I guess we have played some 5-6 series in 2 yrs)

How a team's captain opt out when they have made it to a gloabal tournament after finishing runners in the domestic league!!!

Anyways he is certain to retire from ODI's after the WC. He never played a ODI after the SA series in Feb 2010 till this year. At 37 one has pick and choose games rather than playing all games and get injured.
After CLT20 they joined their national squads. They did not take rest voluntarily nor did they skip any series before playing CLT20.

Are ODI's with srilanka more meaningless than CLT20. They should have pride in playing for the nation each and every match whatever be the opposition.
 
sg3707 said:
After CLT20 they joined their national squads. They did not take rest voluntarily nor did they skip any series before playing CLT20.

Are ODI's with srilanka more meaningless than CLT20. They should have pride in playing for the nation each and every match whatever be the opposition.
T20 is differnt from 50 overs cricket and needs more effort. Plus one +ve of Sachin not playing ODIs is the ODI team is Kohli cementing his place and emerging as a reliable ODI batsmen.

He was represting a Indian Club/franchise in CL T20.
 
avi_avadhut said:
i completely agree with you.... has anybody noticed total number of runs Dhoni scored in SA ODI series....we need to throw him out. look at ponting....if he dont score there is hell after him but here Dhoni seems enjoying his place by doing nothing..
Going the Ganguly way I presume
 
In india, players batting performance goes down after getting captaincy, for eg: sachin,ganguly,rahul dravid...
 
I'm surprised to see these kind of sachin bashing :(... that even after so many years he survived in this cricketing world...

All said, sachin will be key person in this world cup series.. :)
 
smnrock said:
All said, sachin will be key person in this world cup series.. :)
Since that is the only achievement left for him to achieve and this being his last opportunity to be part of WC winning team: world cup is ours! :P
 
RS4 said:
In india, players batting performance goes down after getting captaincy, for eg: sachin,ganguly,rahul dravid...
Can't say it better, we better start giving captaincy to Nehra, Munaf, et al :P
 
smnrock said:
I'm surprised to see these kind of sachin bashing :(... that even after so many years he survived in this cricketing world...

All said, sachin will be key person in this world cup series.. :)
There is always a set of anti-sachin fans out there :P If Sachin skipping SL ODIs and playing in CL T20 is unacceptable then there are loads of players who have retired from Intl cricket and playing in IPL and CL T20 instead of representing their country. Whatever argument you have they will come up with another meaningless counter. I try hard not to reply to such posts but couldn't stand any Sachin bashing :)

From previous editions accordingly this time India should lift the cup :)

1992 - Sachin's 1st WC (avg performance from Sachin) - Didnt make to semis

1996 - Sachin's 2nd WC (excellent performance from Sachin) - Losing Semi finalists

1999 - Sachin's 3rd WC (above aavg performance from Sachin) - Super 6

2003 - Sachin's 4th WC (MOS performance from Sachin) - Runners

2007 - Sachin's 5th WC (avg performance from Sachin) - Ahem Ahem

So by this trend he performs excellently in even WCs and when he performs well India reaches knock outs. Go Tendlya. You deserve this cup. Make us proud :)

2011 - Sachin's 6th WC (MOM in fianls and MOS) - India wins WC :ohyeah:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.