Adani group, an Evil corp?

The infra adani makes is not for himself but for the countrymen. If you had basic understanding of Geopolitics, you would know who this attack is to.

what a redundant statement!

whatever software microsoft makes is not for themselves but for the whole world..
whatever phone apple makes is for the entire world ..
whatever oxygen linde india makes is for the countrymen
whatever cars tata makes is for the countrymen

i can go on and on - whats your point?

all of the above including adani is making money - but the fact that someone is making/ getting the opp to make, buy and do so much infra while pumping up stocks [ manipulation, fudged holdings ] is the focus point

to your statements :

adani is not running a non profit or, as we like to label it, doing social service or country service !!


coming to geopolitics or the lack of it, if adani didnt make infra, L&T would, other firms would. no way the work would stop or disappear
:)

there is a hint of governmental, governing body collusion because these facts have been called out multiple times within the country and there are investigations ongoing which are dragging along. there are also some watered down fines and penalties imposed on multiple members of adani group
@Sobirvs hey man don't get offended pls... but you're very wrong and I mean you're way off from zone. Let clear few thing... and pardon me I don't quite figure out how multi quote is working so...
EVERYTHING WILL ONLY MAKE SENSE TO YOU IF YOU CONSIDER
- Adani is a public ltd company, not a govt, not a nation. FULL STOP

1. contract can be awarded to anyone who goes for proper bidding process.
My view- Most of the govt. bidding already get finalized (behind door) even before actual/legal bidding started.

2.You think you targeting your own Indian company will make any dent to Adani? The dent will go to the citizen's invested in the company and the citizen's employed in the company. Yes I do see it as a target Indians being one of a citizen here and you don't speak for me and countless others.
My view- It's not about our own Indian company, the question is about a company who get allegations on using all kind of mal practice in the system and taking advantage of current bjp govt. Never underestimate Public sentiment, you can refer to share market trend for refernce.

3.The infra adani makes is not for himself but for the countrymen
My view- SERIOUSLY BRO...

Honestly I think you know already but politics makes you throw your own concesnes under the bus just coz you believe adani (alleged involved in malpractice pvt. company) = bjp (alleged provided backdor to their electrol funding partners) =India (a sovereign nation)

aptly conveyed, should have read this before posting my prev post.
 
Last edited:
@Sobirvs hey man don't get offended pls... but you're very wrong and I mean you're way off from zone. Let clear few thing... and pardon me I don't quite figure out how multi quote is working so...
EVERYTHING WILL ONLY MAKE SENSE TO YOU IF YOU CONSIDER
- Adani is a public ltd company, not a govt, not a nation. FULL STOP

1. contract can be awarded to anyone who goes for proper bidding process.
My view- Most of the govt. bidding already get finalized (behind door) even before actual/legal bidding started.

2.You think you targeting your own Indian company will make any dent to Adani? The dent will go to the citizen's invested in the company and the citizen's employed in the company. Yes I do see it as a target Indians being one of a citizen here and you don't speak for me and countless others.
My view- It's not about our own Indian company, the question is about a company who get allegations on using all kind of mal practice in the system and taking advantage of current bjp govt. Never underestimate Public sentiment, you can refer to share market trend for refernce.

3.The infra adani makes is not for himself but for the countrymen
My view- SERIOUSLY BRO...

Honestly I think you know already but politics makes you throw your own concesnes under the bus just coz you believe adani (alleged involved in malpractice pvt. company) = bjp (alleged provided backdor to their electrol funding partners) =India (a sovereign nation)

Alright finally someone who wants to talk.

Adani is a pub. ltd company correct, however, yes they do tons for the nation and so do MSME's. Anyone who do attack regardless outsiders or citizen's, I have full right to defend, but my first instinct is never to defend but to read what the accusations are and anyone doing this to startup's/MSME's/billionaire's I will defend, specially when it's company from a space who takes short's position. The report was made in last 1 month? They announced 2 years back, are you aware of it? MSME's/traders/wealth generators makes a nation, including the state however state changes and so does nature of state.

1. Behind door? so make a solution for it, do you have it? Taking tender's from PSU's, I do have experience of this, and yes, it does happen. But not having solution and attacking just coz you don't like an ideology and a political party is you yourself are putting your nation down.

2. Do check what I said, quite irrelevant what you said and the allegations come all the time so? Go to courts, are you promoting media trial and if that is the case, let's adopt Taliban's style of justice, why not?

3. Again, understand what happens when businesses get's attacked is the sole reason why WB is where it is today or Punjab.

First of all .. not acceptable. We can have a meaningful discussion without resorting to aggression, tagging etc. If not, I'll rather happy to not engage in conversation with you.

If you can't handle argument, read Internet 101. It's not for you. You are here to debate, then debate. OP opened a thread where he clearly said it doesn't have to be ideological fight for ruling party but where has anyone made a point without mentioning the ruling party? I actually kept seeing the debate that someone will talk some sense, but most of it was circle jerking as usual for one thing - BJP bad.
Defending anyone is fine, there are no problems with that considering its a free country.
The problem is that not a single post in the defense goes beyond rhetoric.

Its almost universally a toxic mix of ad-hominem attacks on the entity that raised the question, or worse, an extreme generalization of said attack on the West as a whole.
Hell, even the CFO of said org compared this report to the Jalianwala bagh tragedy (seriously?)

Some go beyond that and make a complete anti-national strawman of anyone who even so much as attempts to think otherwise.

Every single defense post I have seen here or elsewhere falls in one or more of the above categories and I am genuinely hoping that someone proves me wrong by showing me a valid counter :|


You nailed it man
Never thought I'd see people defending literal billionaires on the internet. Straight fight between Elon Twitter Stans vs. Adani Desi Fans.
Never thought liberals would be against FOS/E or I guess they were always like that? They love only that speech they love. Hypocrisy of liberals is widely known in the country from quite a while now. Wtf, how can someone defend billionaires, let us attack them!!!

raised the question, or worse, an extreme generalization of said attack on the West as a whole.
Hell, even the CFO of said org compared this report to the Jalianwala bagh tragedy (seriously?)

Some go beyond that and make a complete anti-national strawman of anyone who even so much as attempts to think otherwise.

Every single defense post I have seen here or elsewhere falls in one or more of the above categories and I am genuinely hoping that someone proves me wrong by showing me a valid counter :|

what's the problem here though?? whoever gave the orders for jallianwala bagh, who fired though? weren't those Indians? is truth really this bad that you can't digest it?

Yes, we all should voice our opinions, ask questions whenever need arise. Why should one keep mum and accept wrong doings ?? As I mentioned, If Adani's case is also proven to have wrong doings it will be at such a big scale that it cannot happen without the knowledge of higher ups in govt. Fair enough. Then do we have info on which govt official(s) / bureaucrat(s) are named in chargesheet ? How many of them got suspended and are facing enquiry ? If yes, then it will be a good action. If not then what I mentioned holds good.
Here's the problem with this statement right, you have already accepted adani has done wrong doings without any credibility. Why do we have courts in the country? So, till you can prove what you think, that keeping mum applies to nobody, and do please research on actions taken on officials and the contractor for Morbi and let's talk.

Also what are your thoughts on

Just one point here, if we are so sure of transparency, what happened to electoral bonds - Isn't transparency required there as well? What about changes in stand for pm cares - from govt to pvt to out of RTI etc .

Transparency on what? If the case is you want to know the donors, then it will apply on all political parties and there's a reason we don't have transparency who votes which political party in electoral process, so if one wants to know the donors and the amount, it won't happen as it will involve alot of violence if it happens and any small business MSME or big corp won't be able to survive regardless which political party will be in power. Tomorrow the info comes out that someone is funding AAP/Congress/TMC and let's say in a BJP MLA/MP constituency, they would love to strong arm the business or donor to direct funds to their party and if not, violence will happen and vice-versa to other parties aswell. So think what you are asking for as transparency will be for all parties not just BJP and for all donors.

Patriotism is like a religion. Runs high in this forum.

All I see is people have made being anti national their religion here on this forum. I don't have a problem with that as long as counters from all sides are allowed including yours. What a time we live in where a conservative inclined has to tell to allow FOS/e from all sides.

Its always hilarious to see a 'nobody' defending a billionaire/celebrity/politician/corporate as if they care for you or need you.

Stupidity has no limit.

I don't think Pappu is a nobody. He is our youth leader. Stop attacking our youth leader.

I don't recollect seeing any business of Adani that is technically advanced enough to command the PE ratios that suddenly swung up post Jan 2021.
Can someone here who is a "Supporter" of Adani group explain the changes in business warranting the change in market valuation?

Also to the shills advocating that Adani is doing stuff for the country - please refer my question above - what business is Adani is that is so technologicaly advanced that only Adani can pull it off? Infra projects?
LMAO!!!
You mean if Adani is not there then there is no other company in India that could implement the project???

are you saying some other company if implements the project, they won't be attacked??

and is your criteria of a company doing good for the country only if they have contributed to Tech?? and not leverage the tech? by that logic, MSME's are contributing nothing to the nation? what kind of fundamentalism is this where traders are seen not supporting or contributing to the nation?? btw Tesla did contribute to tech advancement and space and they get attacked, do you see your nonsense question here?

Simping for corpos is like Cringe Pro Max Ultra Plus

attacking the corpos coz your political leaders say so is equally cringe. Atleast the political leaders I follow don't tell me to defend the corpos unlike in ur case where it's clear where your orders are coming from.

I don't think they are directly defending or simping for Adani etc. It is based on political affiliation.

If tomorrow any of these rich men accuse the same politicians, imagine how these defenders will react.

It has already happened. Have you seen the same rich men accusing some politicians, how the supporters react?? They defend their political masters.

and I hope you know who defend A Raja in the country and who support him and who are allying with the party he associates with.

and I am loving the intellectualism coming from forum members whoa are replying with memes. The education really paid off.

what a redundant statement!

whatever software microsoft makes is not for themselves but for the whole world..
whatever phone apple makes is for the entire world ..
whatever oxygen linde india makes is for the countrymen
whatever cars tata makes is for the countrymen

i can go on and on - whats your point?

all of the above including adani is making money - but the fact that someone is making/ getting the opp to make, buy and do so much infra while pumping up stocks [ manipulation, fudged holdings ] is the focus point

to your statements :

adani is not running a non profit or, as we like to label it, doing social service or country service !!


coming to geopolitics or the lack of it, if adani didnt make infra, L&T would, other firms would. no way the work would stop or disappear
:)

there is a hint of governmental, governing body collusion because these facts have been called out multiple times within the country and there are investigations ongoing which are dragging along. there are also some watered down fines and penalties imposed on multiple members of adani group

so this whole attack and big hawua is all because of a "hint"?? and if penalties are being imposed, and prev SEBI has taken action on adani group about a year back if you remember, then saying Govt is colluding here would end up being a Lie.

and your post indicates somehow that making money while serving the nation is somehow bad??

I never said someone else can't do the work, but why would you want to limit someone for bidding process though?? And wealth generators are helping in geopolitics with srilanka, US, Israel, Myanmar, ME and african countries. If you see a wrong doing, we have courts where elite judges sit who come from within 300 families from last 70 years. Feel free to reach those masters aswell.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I actually kept seeing the debate that someone will talk some sense, but most of it was circle jerking as usual for one thing - BJP bad.
What is wrong with that. It is only since last few years that blaming ruling party makes people go full defense. The "how can he be wrong" mentality never leads to a healthy debate. Every political party be it ruling or opposition can be blamed , questioned. That's never been a problem before.


If you can't handle argument, read Internet 101. It's not for you.
Yes. I do not want to go 'throw rocks' mode. Those who want to have discussion can always do, with open mind and sans aggression.
I'm out.
 

Attachments

  • FeathersofAkind.png
    FeathersofAkind.png
    543.8 KB · Views: 58
Last edited:
Another thread which will soon be locked again. :confused: This topic was actually quite important but can't really blame the mods here. I see at other forums and they are having a very civilised and highly technical discussion going on this very topic. For some reason, those guys don't feel like their family was insulted by Hindenburg report. How weird is that?

Anyway, yesterday I had an opportunity to learn the share manipulation done by the 'A'. I was dumbfounded because it was stupid simple. It was right in front of everyone and still nobody could see it? I'm not even talking about mauritius or whatever happened there. That's another matter. But how could SEBI overlooked it or was made to? I mean artificial scarcity was created in the share market. So there are like only 5-10% company's worth shares traded in the open market by retail investors like us. And this whole act was literally deciding the worth of the company? This stupidity of retail investors literally made him second richest person in the world. I mean who bought those shares? What were you thinking? It's exactly like bitcoin. Create artificial scarcity and give bullish signal to the market. Everyone runs after it because they see everyone else is running too. Nobody bothered to take a pause to think?

Hindenberg is right 99% of times given their past records. Like 'A', Hindenburg also shorted shares of a chinese company and did you know what chinese govt did? They completed the job Hindenburg started. I, of course, don't see that's happening here. 'A' isn't a wealth maker like Tata Ambani. 'A' is a perfect example of an Oligarch. I don't think Indians yet understand what an Oligarch is, which is why they are putting 'A' in the same boat of Tata Ambani. The difference is, a govt can fail a wealth maker (like Vijay Mallya). But only an oligarch has the capacity to fail the govt in return. 'A' will be given a slap on the wrist and he'll remain in business. Current ghotala will be remembered as just some price corrections for 'A' shares.

In a nutshell,
(before Hindenburg) Everyone and their dogs: " 'A' shares are overvalued bro."
Hindenburg: "You are right bro"
Everyone: "Bro, don't talk shit about our country"
Govt: "You heard our men, get out bro"
 
Even though everyone feels short selling is evil, it’s needed for maintaining balance of power.
There are few activist short sellers who have brought some really nasty scams to light. Yes they have made money in the process but it is a balancing act without which there would be too many scams.
For those interested; try watching a documentary called china hustle. https://m.imdb.com/title/tt7215388/
1675196160848.png
 
Last edited:
Everyone runs after it because they see everyone else is running too. Nobody bothered to take a pause to think?
Unfortunately it is something that is hard wired among investors aka humans and happens more often than we realize.
 
Yes. I do not want to go 'throw rocks' mode. Those who want to have discussion can always do, with open mind and sans aggression.
I'm out.

I too would have liked to see a logical counter argument that does not devolve into the exact rhetorical fallacies listed.
I guess I was expecting too much.. I'm out too

Good that you guys learned the lesson. I've added some members to ignore list for this reason. They're not worth engaging with.
 
They're not worth engaging with.

Agree.. I just wanted to see if someone atleast accepts/gives constructive criticism and meaningful counters to maintain a healthy discussion.

But nah, you raise a meaningful point and all you get is Nehru, Indira, congress, Gandhi, genocide, commie and all the whataboutism.
I don't understand whether they believe in these theories or just byheart them for a job.
 
It is not only the people who bought the shares directly, mutual funds, index schemes, ETF etc have exposure to these at various levels. Information is available here, last updated Dec 2022. Steep decline of these shares are going to hurt many, directly / indirectly for sure
 
so this whole attack and big hawua is all because of a "hint"?? and if penalties are being imposed, and prev SEBI has taken action on adani group about a year back if you remember, then saying Govt is colluding here would end up being a Lie.

and your post indicates somehow that making money while serving the nation is somehow bad??

I never said someone else can't do the work, but why would you want to limit someone for bidding process though?? And wealth generators are helping in geopolitics with srilanka, US, Israel, Myanmar, ME and african countries. If you see a wrong doing, we have courts where elite judges sit who come from within 300 families from last 70 years. Feel free to reach those masters aswell.

SEBI does not take actions on hints. they investigate
their investigations are slow and dragging is the suggestion and the issues prevail is the allegation

wow, you did a complete u-turn in terms of what you posted and i posted :

i thought it was your post that was singing praises *of working/making for the country* it is a redundant and lame statement.
questionable, opaque, and shady business practices, even supposedly criminal / illegal activities cant be under any garb especially of making/working for the nation.

hindenberg has questioned companies in different countries, heck most companies are global and multilisted geographically and business wise.

lets cut the crap on the sensationalism of nationalism.
 
Back
Top