Home air purifiers effective for improving indoor air quality?

View attachment 217089

Air purifier filter in just 15 days.

How much of our lives are we throwing it away by merely breathing in an Indian city?
This is what we can see that prefilter catches. Pm 2.5 we cant even see easily. So if PM 10 is low and PM2.5 is high then air might look ok but is still bad.
My asthma and allergy symptoms are much better after using AP + regular Vaccum cleaning + regularly wash bed stuff and curtains.
But there is still exposure when i get out and also in air pockets around windows where air is leaking in.

Every city i have been outside India (Canada/US/Israel) has had very clean air and i never had any respiratory issues at all. In India its reverse ..
Also Indian houses don't have hvac type stuff generally, perhaps because temperatures are moderate ( but it can be so cold in winter in north).
 
@lockhrt999
Which city are you in? What model purifier? In the Living Room or Bedroom?
Pune.
Xiaomi 4 lite.
Kitchen.
This is what we can see that prefilter catches. Pm 2.5 we cant even see easily. So if PM 10 is low and PM2.5 is high then air might look ok but is still bad.
Very true. There's no visual cue for PM2.5 pollution. It perhaps gives a uniform bluish tint (from the sky) to very distant dark shadows on a nice sunny day.

Pune, on most days, has higher PM10 pollution than PM2.5. And, that's what we see on the prefilter.
 
Last edited:
Do the air purifiers remove second hand bidi/cigarette smoke? Some downstairs neighbour of mine is a chain smoker and if i keep the windows open, all the second hand smoke comes in my home. I just can't stand the smell and have to close the windows immediately. The smell takes long time to go away. Can these air purifiers help in such case?
 
Do the air purifiers remove second hand bidi/cigarette smoke? Some downstairs neighbour of mine is a chain smoker and if i keep the windows open, all the second hand smoke comes in my home. I just can't stand the smell and have to close the windows immediately. The smell takes long time to go away. Can these air purifiers help in such case?
Yes, in a closed room
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6pack
Do the air purifiers remove second hand bidi/cigarette smoke? Some downstairs neighbour of mine is a chain smoker and if i keep the windows open, all the second hand smoke comes in my home. I just can't stand the smell and have to close the windows immediately. The smell takes long time to go away. Can these air purifiers help in such case?
I doubt any Air Purifier works if you keep Windows/Ventilations/Door etc. Open, as they are meant to work in close door environment, check before you buy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6pack
yes, and you will need carbon(gas) filters for smoke (cig/fire). And carbon filters that come with AP usually get used up within a couple of months from what i read.
So maybe something that has much more activated carbon would be better if available.

Just google and see how to filter smoke
Ex
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6pack
I plan to pick up the regular 4 (non-lite) for the living room.
The non-lite version comes with a negative ionizer. In theory, it's great to eradicate mold or that stuffy smell you get from mattress and wardrobe clothes. So you may want to put a non-lite version in the bedroom too.
I doubt any Air Purifier works if you keep Windows/Ventilations/Door etc. Open, as they are meant to work in close door environment, check before you buy.
You are right. But I think it's still better to have an air purifier even with the windows open, rather than no purifier at all.
 
The non-lite version comes with a negative ionizer. In theory, it's great to eradicate mold or that stuffy smell you get from mattress and wardrobe clothes. So you may want to put a non-lite version in the bedroom too.

You are right. But I think it's still better to have an air purifier even with the windows open, rather than no purifier at all.
My room PM2.5 count goes up quickly when windows are open. Depends on cross ventilation/wind too and how much window is open.
Probably if AP is beside you and between you and window, it might help a bit.

I keep AP running 24x7, it hardly uses any power anyway. But i only open windows when needed else it defeats the purpose.
To get outside clean air, we will need filtered intake.
 
@6pack how if you grow some wild Tulsi Plant, grab tulsi seeds from any open grown (not in pot soil but in soil/barren land etc. area) so it might stop some smoke and provide you fresh Oxygen round the clock. source
 
@6pack how if you grow some wild Tulsi Plant, grab tulsi seeds from any open grown (not in pot soil but in soil/barren land etc. area) so it might stop some smoke and provide you fresh Oxygen round the clock. source
Tulsi plant will be in balcony. What will I do inside the house where there is no sunlight? That guy smokes continuously from 6am till 12am at midnight. I think even plants will die trying to clean the air in my hall. I smell like a smoker even without smoking. :(
 
Tulsi plant will be in balcony. What will I do inside the house where there is no sunlight? That guy smokes continuously from 6am till 12am at midnight. I think even plants will die trying to clean the air in my hall. I smell like a smoker even without smoking. :(
buy pedestal fan, face it toward balcony from where smoke coming in, keep it on and it will partially stop major part of smoke to enter in hall. Out of 4-5 windows panel, just keep open one slide only thus tobacco smoke will not enter in hall from other open slides.

if have good/fresh air from kitchen window or bedroom window, install 'outside in' heavy duty exhaust fan and let the fan suck all out side good air inside and pedestal fan in hall will throw that air out of hall.
If already have exhaust fan in kitchen to throw inside air out, add one more fan to bring outside air in and make sure not to use both at same time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6pack
I had a good Philips air purifier AC4080 which also did de/humidification. used it for over a year, and it worked great. when it came to changing the filter though it was a shocker cause the filter itself was like Rs. 8000 and I had paid around 20k for the purifier, this was back like 7 years ago, I stopped using it and didn't feel the need to purchase it, when car filters which are essentially the same don't cost so much.

back in November of this year, when my son started getting sick regularly due to dust and pollution, I started looking at the market again. and still saw the overpriced Philips filters. the cheapest 3rd party filter option I found was still around 6000, I figured I'd rather get an updated purifier with WiFi and all the bells and whistles than use an old one. so I settled on Agaro Royal Air Purifier replacement filters, which are just under 3000. The purifier works great, it turns on and off automatically on schedule. if you leave it running for 5-10 minutes you can feel the air is lighter than in other rooms where it feels heavier to breathe. we only turn it on during the night, it's off for the rest. As we only open our windows during the day between 11-5 rest of the time it's closed.

I was interested in Xiaomi 4 lite but it was not in stock the entire week I was looking into this, mainly cause I could have integrated it with my home assistant. I am still looking to place one in my living room so let's see.