Kaminey - 7/10
Finally watched it... and seriously liked it.
First 20-25 mins were bit weird for me... it was bit of the effect of hype wearing out and guy ritchie movies resemblance kicking it. But then as the introductory part got over and main events started kicking in, it was really good.
In my opinion, Vishal Bharadwaj played out of his comfort zone of simple, straightforward movies and scored well in his first attempt. And yes, like I mentioned earlier and others before me, you can't help but notice the Guy Ritchie movies resemblance. I think for many, it would also be potential dealbreaker, as it would feel quite frankly been-there-done-that stuff. But If you are really willing to slide past your Hey-I-have-seen-this-kind-of-movie-before attitude and give it a chance you'll notice that VB had handled this very very skillfully and was able to add his own touch.
Overall, Kaminey was pleasant experience, so worth recommending.
PS: Did anyone else saw the trailer of Ishqiya?? The next upcoming flick by VB, feautring Arshad Warsi, Naseer and Vidya Balan? I sure wanna see that one.