Top Tier IEM WAR , Do Participate

Status
Not open for further replies.
bennysachdev said:
I beg to defer about the Hp vs Customs part. :)
Well, people's opinions will always differ. But this is my experience so far, mainly from CanJam.

I spent around 40 minutes with a HD800, another forty with the T1. The setup was in the Summit-Fi room, which was pretty empty, as most of the traffic was at the JHA booth, and the LCD-2/Cavalli Audio booth.

I managed to spend around 25 minutes with the JH16 as well as JH13.

The T1/HD800 setup was majestic (as well as a wallet demolisher). It was powered by a Phonitor(or Auditor, one of the two) which was being fed by a Ayre Q9. The total setup was around $4000. Mighty load on the wallet.

The JH13 was solely driven by the iPad, and the JH16 through the JH-3A prototype.

My most enjoyable music was from the JH16. (surprise, surprise.)

And keep in mind I listened to the same set of songs, many of them in my favorites playlist.

The HD800 had surreal soundstage, excellent precision, while the T1 was warm like. Both had equal frequency response, in fact it was not easy choosing between the two. But if I had to choose, I would choose the JH13/JH16 anyday. Here is why. (keep in mind they were universal mold.. but Jerry used special tips to adjust to the ears, and he personally oversaw the fit.. so I suppose I had the best fit you could get).

I'm not going to include price in comparison.

The customs didn't have as good soundstage, but their instrument separation and placement was as good. But they were more intimate, more enjoyable. They had excellent bass, the sound signature was nothing like I've ever heard, just surreal. The music was as detailed as the headphones, that too with an iPad as a source, especially when comparing to such a high end rig. My JH5's are close to the setup I had with my DT880's, and when you consider the monetary difference between the two setups, as well as portability, it's very hard to not consider customs when upgrading.

The only place in which the headphones beat customs is in the vast sound stage, when amplified properly.

In fact you'll find many people preferring JH13 over HD800, the amount of people at CanJam that preferred customs was what made me look into them. I mean, I also thought the JH13/JH16 hype was overrated, that was till I heard them. Its unbelievable.

Previously I was a total headphone guy, I didn't like any IEM's of any sort, if you look at my audio list, you'll see that I've owned many mid-fi headphones from K701, to Grado HF2, to AT W1000, to DT880's, but only one mid-fi IEM, (the CK10), and then the RE0 and RE-ZERO's and now the JH5. High end customs are in another world altogether when comparing with Universal's, they're in the same world as high end headphones, barring the top rare lines such as Stax and Qualia's and L3000 and O2's. (many of which are no longer in production).

And when you finally look at the total price you spend, the choice becomes even more clear, for me atleast.

According to me, below $800, nothing beats headphones at all. The HD650's, DT880's, markl D5000 and some of the ortho's as well are just awesome, VERY close to the high ends such as T1 and HD800, but customs as well as universal's are not close. But when you go above the $800-$900 bracket, the customs like the ES5, JH13/16 ( I've only heard these three, so can't speak for others ) are as good as high end headphones. You'll find many other people, especially those who've owned both setups will echo the same sentiment.

In the end, audio is HIGHLY subjective, you'll also find people who don't believe the same.
 
^ Well said . Havent heard a pair of customs till date but I really wouldn't be surprised if they can surpass or be on par with some of the most high end cans in terms of detailing , extension etc. I seriously feel that the TF10 I got to hear is almost on par or better in some departments when compared with most mid-fi cans like my D2K , the 702s Ive heard etc.

Soundstage is one thing one really cant compare an IEM with a pair of headphones or a pair of high end speakers cause each of them have an upper hand over the others due to the size ,bigger drivers etc. It will always differ due the physical and technological limitations .
 
I actually met someone at the Stereo store who owns the JH13 and the HD800 amongst other stuff and he said the only thing he feels is better on the 800 is the soundstage. Purely subjective again but still..............
 
Ritvik said:
I actually met someone at the Stereo store who owns the JH13 and the HD800 amongst other stuff and he said the only thing he feels is better on the 800 is the soundstage. Purely subjective again but still..............
There you go. Exactly what I thought when I auditioned the two. What's happening about your reshell btw?
 
Got them back a week ago, took exactly 5 weeks like the UM people said it would. Initial impressions (although I've had very little time with them) - quite transparent, great soundstage.......But what really has me happy is the instrument separation on these babies, its truly incredible even on crowded/complex bits of music. I'm guessing a UM reshell makes them sound a bit different from what JHA intended but I'm quite happy with the overall sound and the fit is perfect. The UM shell looks a lot nicer than the original too, almost no cosmetic imperfections, its not that important but nice when you've spent a bucket load of money on them.

Getting a imod soon, should be here in a couple of days from a head-fi member - quick specs (ipod video 30gb, mod compact flash 16g, elna duorex II 47uf/16v, rockbox + DIY LoD, 900mAH battery) ...................hoping they sound even better with a proper line out :D
 
Ha ha ! Perhaps I should try it out ! :P

Anyways I really wanted to know how the RS1s sound.

I wanted to hear Vandals pair but he shifted to Delhi. :(
 
They have a very wide soundstage. Live recordings to really feel live in this. There is no sense of listening from a can when you have these on. apart from the fact that they touch your ears, you will not feel that you are sitting anywhere except the actual live performance. I tried Eric Clapton and Alanis morrisette live and the sense of detailing, imaging and soundstage was amazing.
The bass is tight and punch, not boomy or bloated. They do go low but they don't have a decay, making them sound fast and accurate. Don't be fooled that being an open back they would be bass light. You will be surprised with the punch. I was when I heard Romeo and Juliet - Dire straits (1min 5secs) when the drums kick in.
The mids are smooth and forward as i expected out of a Grado. Nothing but the best. If one listens to metal or grunge rock, u'll love the growl in vocals on these. Quite the opposite of the HD650's laid back nature. You for one brendon should have this in your collection as I know you love the HD650's and these are exactly its opposite but retaining the level of quality expected from a Top tier HP. Kinda like God made the HD650, smooth and laid back and in response the Devil made the Grado Rs1i, packs a mean aggressive punch. ;)
The highs are really clean with a good extension. They do extend really high and are not sharp and piercing.

They were very expensive though dude. If you can strike a good deal with a used one, i'd even say that they're VFM. But for 1200SGD i think its a bit too much for them.
Makes me wonder what the GS1000 and W5000 would sound like :D
Thats the only one left to try right now since i already tried the HD800 at a friends place.
 
aren't you still in skool faheem? :P

--- Updated Post - Automerged ---

What I mean is bro....you can come here whenever you want to, finish off with your studies.
Its not like Jaben and Stereo are running off anywhere in a few years.
 
Ya , actually i was unaware of this fact . Lol , i used to think he must be some graduate .... haha but it doesnt matters !

Its just , that u keep a certain image of everyone in our mind and then talk to that person , from now on will talk to Faheem , like a schooooollll boiiii :P :P
 
No re he's not really in skool.......What I meant was going by his knowledge about audiophile equipment, he is more knowledgeable than most audiophiles twice his age, but that just means he's wiser than he looks. (pheww......what a quick save there)

coming back to the topic, need a more detailed review from Ritvik about the JH13s and still awaiting strategy's Miracle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.